InthetwelfthcenturytherebegantobeintroducedintothelanguagesomeofthetermsofAristotle’sphilosophy。andtowardsthesixteenthcenturyoneexpressedbyGreektermsallthepartsofthehumanbody,theirdiseases,theirremedies。whencethewordscardiaque,cephalique,podagre,apoplectique,asthmatique,iliaque,empyeme,andsomanyothers。AlthoughthelanguagethenenricheditselffromtheGreek,andalthoughsinceCharlesVIII。ithaddrawnmuchaidfromItalianalreadyperfected,theFrenchlanguagehadnotyettakenregularconsistence。Francoisl。abolishedtheancientcustomofpleading,judging,contractinginLatin。customwhichborewitnesstothebarbarismofalanguagewhichonedidnotdareuseinpublicdocuments,aperniciouscustomforcitizenswhoselotwasregulatedinalanguagetheydidnotunderstand。OnewasobligedthentocultivateFrench。butthelanguagewasneithernoblenorregular。Thesyntaxwaslefttocaprice。Thegeniusforconversationbeingturnedtopleasantries,thelanguagebecameveryfertileinburlesqueandnaiveexpressions,andverysterileinnobleandharmoniousterms:fromthisitcomesthatinrhymingdictionariesonefindstwentytermssuitableforcomicpoetry,foroneformoreexalteduse。anditis,further,areasonwhyMarotneversucceededinaseriousstyle,andwhyAmyotcouldrenderPlutarch’seleganceonlywithnaivete。
FrenchacquiredvigourbeneaththepenofMontaigne。butitstillhadneithernobilitynorharmony。RonsardspoiledthelanguagebybringingintoFrenchpoetrytheGreekcompoundswhichthedoctorsandphilosophersused。MalherberepairedRonsard’smischiefsomewhat。ThelanguagebecamemorenobleandmoreharmoniouswiththeestablishmentoftheAcademieFrancaise,andacquiredfinally,inthereignofLouisXIV。,theperfectionwherebyitmightbecarriedintoallformsofcomposition。
Thegeniusofthislanguageisorderandclarity。foreachlanguagehasitsgenius,andthisgeniusconsistsinthefacilitywhichthelanguagegivesforexpressingoneselfmoreorlesshappily,forusingorrejectingthefamiliartwistsofotherlanguages。Frenchhavingnodeclensions,andbeingalwayssubjecttothearticle,cannotadoptGreekandLatininversions。
itobligeswordstoarrangethemselvesinthenaturalorderofideas。OnlyinonewaycanonesayPlancusaprissoindesaffairesdeCesar。
Thatistheonlyarrangementonecangivetothesewords。ExpressthisphraseinLatin-ResCaesarisPlancusdiligentercuravit:onecanarrangethesewordsinahundredandtwentyways,withoutinjuringthesenseandwithouttroublingthelanguage。Theauxiliaryverbswhichekeoutandenervatethephrasesinmodernlanguages,stillrendertheFrenchtonguelittlesuitedtotheconciselapidarystyle。Theauxiliaryverbs,itspronouns,itsarticles,itslackofdeclinableparticiples,andfinallyitsuniformgait,areinjurioustothegreatenthusiasmofpoetry,inwhichithaslessresourcesthanItalianandEnglish。butthisconstraintandthisbondagerenderitmoresuitablefortragedyandcomedythananylanguageinEurope。Thenaturalorderinwhichoneisobligedtoexpressone’sthoughtsandconstructone’sphrases,diffusesinthislanguageasweetnessandeasinessthatispleasingtoallpeoples。andthegeniusofthenationminglingwiththegeniusofthelanguagehasproducedmoreagreeablywrittenbooksthancanbeseenamonganyotherpeople。
ThepleasureandlibertyofsocietyhavingbeenlongknownonlyinFrance,thelanguagehasreceivedtherefromadelicacyofexpressionandafinessefullofsimplicitybarelytobefoundelsewhere。Thisfinessehassometimesbeenexaggerated,butpeopleoftastehavealwaysknownhowtoreduceitwithinjustlimits。
ManypersonshavethoughtthattheFrenchlanguagehasbecomeimpoverishedsincethetimeofAmyotandMontaigne:onedoesindeedfindinmanyauthorsexpressionswhicharenolongeradmissible。buttheyareforthemostpartfamiliarexpressionsforwhichequivalentshavebeensubstituted。Thelanguagehasbeenenrichedwithaquantityofnobleandenergeticexpressions。andwithoutspeakinghereoftheeloquenceofthings,ithasacquiredtheeloquenceofwords。ItisinthereignofLouisXIV。,ashasbeensaid,thatthiseloquencehaditsgreatestsplendour,andthatthelanguagewasfixed。
Whateverchangestimeandcapriceprepareforit,thegoodauthorsoftheseventeenthandeighteenthcenturieswillalwaysserveasmodels。PhilosophicalDictionary:FriendshipFRIENDSHIPFRIENDSHIPisthemarriageofthesoul。andthismarriageissubjecttodivorce。Itisatacitcontractbetweentwosensitiveandvirtuouspersons。
Isaysensitive,becauseamonk,areclusecanbenotwickedandlivewithoutknowingwhatfriendshipis。Isayvirtuous,becausethewickedhaveonlyaccomplices。voluptuarieshavecompanionsindebauch,self-seekershavepartners,politiciansgetpartisans。thegeneralityofidlemenhaveattachments。princeshavecourtiers。virtuousmenalonehavefriends。CetheguswastheaccompliceofCatilina,andMaecenasthecourtierofOctavius。
butCicerowasthefriendofAtticus。PhilosophicalDictionary:GodGODDURINGthereignofArcadius,Logomacos,lecturerintheologyofConstantinople,wenttoScythiaandhaltedatthefootoftheCaucasus,inthefertileplainsofZephirim,onthefrontierofColchis。ThatgoodoldmanDondindacwasinhisgreatlowerhall,betweenhissheepfoldandhisvastbarn。hewaskneelingwithhiswife,hisfivesonsandfivedaughters,hiskindredandhisservants,andafteralightmealtheywereallsingingGod’spraises。
Whatdoyouthere,idolator?saidLogomacostohim。
Iamnotanidolator,answeredDondindac。
Youmustbeanidolator,saidLogomacos,seeingthatyouarenotGreek。Tellme,whatwasthatyouweresinginginyourbarbarousScythianjargon?
AlltonguesareequalintheearsofGod,answeredtheScythian。
WeweresingingHispraises。
That’sveryextraordinary,returnedthetheologian。AScythianfamilywhoprayGodwithouthavingbeentaughtbyus!HesoonengagedDondindactheScythianinconversation,forheknewalittleScythian,andtheotheralittleGreek。ThefollowingconversationwasfoundinamanuscriptpreservedinthelibraryofConstantinople。LOGOMACOS:
Letusseeifyouknowyourcatechism。WhydoyouprayCod?DONDINDAC:
BecauseitisrighttoworshiptheSupremeBeingfromwhomweholdeverything。LOGOMACOS:
Notbadforabarbarian!Andwhatdoyouaskofhim?DONDINDAC:
IthankHimforthebenefitsIenjoy,andevenfortheillswithwhichhetriesme。butItakegoodcarenottoaskHimforanything。Heknowsbetterthanuswhatweneed,andbesides,IamafraidtoaskHimforgoodweatherwhenmyneighbourisaskingforrain。LOCOMACOS:
Ah!Ithoughthewasgoingtosaysomethingsilly。Letusstartagainfartherback。Barbarian,whohastoldyouthereisaGod?DONDINDAC:
Thewholeofnature。LOGOMACOS:
Thatdoesnotsuffice。WhatideahaveyouofGod?DONDINDAC:
Theideaofmycreator,ofmymaster,whowillrewardmeifIdogood,andwhowillpunishmeifIdoill。LOGOMACOS:
Trash,nonsenseallthat!Letuscometoessentials。IsGodinfinitesecundumquid,orinessence?DONDINDAC:
Idon’tunderstandyou。LOGOMACOS:
Brutishfool!IsGodinoneplace,beyondallplaces,orinallplaces?DONDINDAC:
Ihavenoidea……justasyouplease。LOGOMACOS:
Dolt!Isitpossibleforwhathasbeennottohavebeen,andcanasticknothavetwoends?DoesHeseethefutureasfutureoraspresent?
howdoesHedrawthebeingoutofnon-existence,andhowannihilatethebeing?DONDINDAC:
Ihaveneverexaminedthesethings。LOGOMACOS:
Whatablockhead!Come,onemusthumbleoneself,seethingsinproportion。
Tellme,myfriend,doyouthinkthatmattercanbeeternal?DONDINDAC:
Whatdoesitmattertomewhetheritexistsfromalleternityornot?
Idonotexistfromalleternity。Godisalwaysmymaster。Hehasgivenmethenotionofjustice,Imustfollowit。Idonotwanttobeaphilosopher,Iwanttobeaman。LOGOMACOS:
Theseblockheadsaretroublesome。Letusgostepbystep。WhatisGod?DONDINDAC:
Mysovereign,myjudge,myfather。LOGOMACOS:
That’snotwhatI’maskingyou。WhatisHisnature?DONDINDAC:
Tobepotentandgood。LOGOMACOS:
But,isHecorporealorspiritual?DONDINDAC:
HowshouldIknow?LOGOMACOS:
What!youdon’tknowwhataspiritis?DONDINDAC:
Notintheleast:ofwhatusewoulditbetome?shouldIbemorelust?
shouldIbeabetterhusband,abetterfather,abettermaster,abettercitizen?LOGOMACOS:
Itisabsolutelyessentialyoushouldlearnwhataspiritis。Itis,itis,itis……Iwilltellyouanothertime。DONDINDAC:
I’mverymuchafraidthatyoumaytellmelesswhatitisthanwhatitisnot。Allowmetoputaquestiontoyouinmyturn。Ioncesawoneofyourtemples。whydoyoudepictGodwithalongbeard?LOGOMACOS:
That’saverydifficultquestionwhichneedspreliminaryinstruction。DONDINDAC:
Beforereceivingyourinstruction,Imusttellyouwhathappenedtomeoneday。Ihadjustbuiltaclosetattheendofmygarden。Iheardamolearguingwithacockchafer。That’safinebuilding,Saidthemole。
Itmusthavebeenaverypowerfulmolewhodidthatpieceofwork。
You’rejoking,saidthecockchafer。Itwasacock-chaferbubblingoverwithgeniuswhoisthearchitectofthisbuilding。FromthattimeIresolvednevertoargue。PhilosophicalDictionary:HelvetiaHELVETIAHAPPYHelvetia!towhatcharterdoyouoweyourliberty?toyourcourage,toyourresolution,toyourmountains。
ButIamyouremperor。
ButIdonotwantyouanylonger。
Butyourfathersweremyfather’sslaves。
Itisforthatveryreasonthattheirchildrendonotwishtoserveyou。
ButIhadtherightbelongingtomyrank。
Andwehavetherightofnature。
Whyislibertysorare?Becauseitisthechiefestgood。PhilosophicalDictionary:HistoryHISTORYDEFINITION
HISTORYistherecitaloffactsgivenastrue,incontra-distinctiontothefable,whichistherecitaloffactsgivenasfalse。
Thereisthehistoryofopinionswhichishardlyanythingbutacollectionofhumanerrors。
Thehistoryoftheartscanbethemostusefulofallwhenitjoinstotheknowledgeoftheinventionandtheprogressoftheartsthedescriptionoftheirmechanism。
Naturalhistory,improperlycalledhistory,isanessentialpartofnaturalphilosophy。Thehistoryofeventshasbeendividedintosacredhistoryandprofanehistory。sacredhistoryisaseriesofdivineandmiraculousoperationswherebyitpleasedGodonceonatimetoleadtheJewishnation,andto-daytoexerciseourfaith。FIRSTFOUNDATIONSOFHISTORY
Thefirstfoundationsofallhistoryaretherecitalsofthefatherstothechildren,transmittedafterwardfromonegenerationtoanother。
attheirorigintheyareattheverymostprobable,whentheydonotshockcommonsense,andtheyloseonedegreeofprobabilityineachgenerationWithtimethefablegrowsandthetruthgrowsless。fromthisitcomesthatalltheoriginsofpeoplesareabsurd。ThustheEgyptianshadbeengovernedbythegodsformanycenturies。thentheyhadbeengovernedbydemi-gods。finallytheyhadhadkingsforeleventhousandthreehundredandfortyyears。andinthatspaceoftimethesunhadchangedfourtimesfromeasttowest。
ThePhoeniciansofAlexander’stimeclaimedtohavebeenestablishedintheircountryforthirty,thousandyears。andthesethirtythousandyearswerefilledwithasmanyprodigiesastheEgyptianchronology。I
avowthatphysicallyitisverypossiblethatPhoeniciahasexistednotmerelythirtythousandyears,butthirtythousandmilliardsofcenturies,andthatitexperiencedliketherestoftheworldthirtymillionrevolutions。
Butwehavenoknowledgeofit。OneknowswhataridiculouslymarvellousstateofaffairsruledintheancienthistoryoftheGreeks。
TheRomans,forallthattheywereserious,didnotanythelessenvelopthehistoryoftheirearlycenturiesinfables。Thisnation,sorecentcomparedwiththeAsiaticpeoples,wasfivehundredyearswithouthistorians。
Itisnotsurprising,therefore,thatRomuluswasthesonofMars,thatashe-wolfwashisfostermother,thathemarchedwithathousandmenofhisvillageofRomeagainsttwenty-fivethousandcombatantsofthevillageoftheSabines:thatlaterhebecameagod。thatTarquin,theancient,cutastonewitharazor,andthatavestaldrewashiptolandwithhergirdle,etc。
Theearlyannalsofallourmodernnationsarenolessfabulous。theprodigiousandimprobablethingsmustsometimesbereported,butasproofsofhumancredulity:theyenterthehistoryofopinionsandfoolishnesses。
butthefieldistoovast。OFRECORDS
Inordertoknowwithalittlecertaintysomethingofancienthistory,thereisonlyonemeans,itistoseeifanyincontestablerecordsremain。
Wehaveonlythreeinwriting:thefirstisthecollectionofastronomicalobservationsmadefornineteenhundredconsecutiveyearsatBabylon,sentbyAlexandertoGreece。Thisseriesofobservations,whichgoesbacktotwothousandtwohundredandthirty-fouryearsbeforeourera,provesinvinciblythattheBayloniansexistedasabodyofpeopleseveralcenturiesbefore。
fortheartsareonlytheworkoftime,andmen’snaturallazinessleavesthemforsomethousandofyearswithoutotherknowledgeandwithoutothertalentsthanthoseoffeedingthemselves,ofdefendingthemselvesagainsttheinjuriesoftheair,andofslaughteringeachother。LetusjudgebytheGermansandbytheEnglishinCaesar’stime,bytheTartarsto-day,bythetwo-thirdsofAfrica,andbyallthepeopleswehavefoundinAmerica,exceptinginsomerespectsthekingdomsofPeruandofMexico,andtherepublicofTlascala。Letusrememberthatinthewholeofthisnewworldnobodyknewhowtoreadorwrite。
Thesecondrecordisthecentraleclipseofthesun,calculatedinChinatwothousandonehundredandfifty-fiveyearsbeforeourera,andrecognizedtruebyourastronomers。OftheChinesethesamethingmustbesaidasofthepeoplesofBabylon。theyalreadycomprisedavastcivilizedempirewithoutadoubt。ButwhatputstheChineseaboveallthepeoplesoftheearthisthatneithertheirlaws,northeircustoms,northelanguagespokenamongthembytheirletteredmandarinshaschangedforaboutfourthousandyears。Nevertheless,thisnationandthenationofIndia,themostancientofallthosethatexistto-day,whichpossessthevastestandthemostbeautifulcountry,whichinventedalmostalltheartsbeforewehadlearnedanyofthem,havealwaysbeenomittedrighttoourdaysinallso-calleduniversalhistories。AndwhenaSpaniardandaFrenchmantookacensusofthenations,neitheronenortheotherfailedtocallhiscountrythefirstmonarchyintheworld,andhiskingthegreatestkingintheworld,flatteringhimselfthathiskingwouldgivehimapensionassoonashehadreadhisbook。
Thethirdrecord,veryinferiortothetwoothers,existsintheArundelmarbles:thechronicleofAthensisgravedtheretwohundredandsixty-threeyearsbeforeourera。butitgoesbackonlytoCecrops,thirteenhundredandnineteenyearsbeyondthetimewhenitwasengraved。Inthehistoryofantiquitythosearethesoleincontestableepochsthatwehave。
LetusgiveseriousattentiontothesemarblesbroughtbackfromGreecebyLordArundel。Theirchroniclebeginsfifteenhundredandeighty-twoyearsbeforeourera。Thatisto-day1771anantiquityof3,353years,andyoudonotseethereasinglefacttouchingonthemiraculous,ontheprodigious。ItisthesamewiththeOlympiads。itisnottherethatoneshouldsayGraeciamendax,lieingGreece。TheGreeksknewverywellhowtodistinguishbetweenhistoryandfable,betweenrealfactsandthetalesofHerodotus:justasintheirseriousaffairstheiroratorsborrowednothingfromthespeechesofthesophistsorfromtheimagesofthepoets。
ThedateofthetakingofTroyisspecifiedinthesemarbles。butnomentionismadeofApollo’sarrows,orofthesacrificeofIphigenia,oroftheridiculouscombatsofthegods。ThedateoftheinventionsofTriptolemyandCeresisfoundthere。butCeresisnotcalledgoddess。MentionismadeofapoemontheabductionofProsperpine。itisnotsaidthatsheisthedaughterofJupiterandagoddess,andthatsheiswifeofthegodoftheinfernalregions。
HerculesisinitiatedintothemysteriesofEleusis。butnotawordonhistwelvelabours,noronhispassageintoAfricainhiscup,noronhisdivinity,noronthebigfishbywhichhewasswallowed,andwhichkepthiminitsbellythreedaysandthreenights,accordingtoLycophron。
Amongus,onthecontrary,astandardisbroughtfromheavenbyanangeltothemonksofSaint-Denis。apigeonbringsabottleofoiltoachurchinRheims。twoarmiesofsnakesgivethemselvesovertoapitchedbattleinGermany。anarchbishopofMayenceisbesiegedandeatenbyrats。and,tocrowneverything,greatcarehasbeentakentomarktheyearoftheseadventures。
Allhistoryisrecent。Itisnotastonishingthatwehavenoancientprofanehistorybeyondaboutfourthousandyears。Therevolutionsofthisglobe,thelonganduniversalignoranceofthatartwhichtransmitsfactsbywritingarethecauseofit。Thisartwascommononlyamongaverysmallnumberofcivilizednations。andwasinveryfewhandseven。NothingrareramongtheFrenchandtheGermansthantoknowhowtowrite。uptothefourteenthcenturyofoureranearlyalldeedswereonlyattestedbywitnesses。Itwas,inFrance,onlyunderCharlesVII。,in1454,thatonestartedtodraftinwritingsomeofthecustomsofFrance。TheartofwritingwasstillrareramongtheSpanish,andfromthatitresultsthattheirhistoryissodryandsouncertain,uptothetimeofFerdinandandIsabella。Oneseesbythattowhatextenttheverysmallnumberofmenwhoknewhowtowritecoulddeceive,andhoweasyitwastomakeusbelievethemostenormousabsurdities。
Therearenationswhichhavesubjugatedapartoftheworldwithouthavingtheusageofcharacters。WeknowthatGengis-khanconqueredapartofAsiaatthebeginningofthethirteenthcentury,butitisnotthrougheitherhimortheTartarsthatweknowit。Theirhistory,writtenbytheChineseandtranslatedbyFatherGaubil,statesthattheseTartarshadnotatthattimetheartofwriting。
ThisartcannothavebeenlessunknowntotheScythianOguskan,namedMadiesbythePersiansandtheGreeks,whoconqueredapartofEuropeandAsiasolongbeforethereignofCyrus。Itisalmostcertainthatatthattimeofahundrednationstherewerehardlytwoorthreewhousedcharacters。
Itispossiblethatinanancientworlddestroyed,menknewwritingandtheotherarts。butinourstheyareallveryrecent。
Thereremainrecordsofanotherkind,whichservetoestablishmerelytheremoteantiquityofcertainpeoples,andwhichprecedealltheknownepochs,andallthebooks。thesearetheprodigiesofarchitecture,likethepyramidsandthepalacesofEgypt,whichhaveresistedtime。Herodotus,wholivedtwothousandtwohundredyearsago,andwhohadseenthem,wasnotabletolearnfromtheEgyptianpriestsatwhattimetheyhadbeenerected。
Itisdifficulttogivetothemostancientofthepyramidslessthanfourthousandyearsofantiquity。butonemustconsiderthattheseeffortsoftheostentationofthekingscouldonlyhavebeencommencedlongaftertheestablishmentofthetowns。Buttobuildtownsinalandinundatedeveryyear,letusalwaysremarkthatitwasfirstnecessarytoraisethelandofthetownsonpilesinthislandofmud,andtorendertheminaccessibletotheflood。itwasessential,beforetakingthisnecessarycourse,andbeforebeinginastatetoattemptthesegreatworks,forthepeopletohavepractisedretreatingduringtherisingoftheNile,amidtherockswhichformtwochainsrightandleftofthisriver。Itwasnecessaryforthesemusteredpeoplestohavetheinstrumentsfortilling,thoseofarchitecture,aknowledgeofsurveying,withlawsandapolice。Allthisnecessarilyrequiresaprodigiousspaceoftime。Weseebythelongdetailswhichfaceeverydaythemostnecessaryandthesmallestofourundertakings,howdifficultitistodogreatthings,anditneedsnotonlyindefatigablestubbornness,butseveralgenerationsanimatedwiththisstubbornness。
However,whetheritbeMenes,ThautorCheops,orRameseswhoerectedoneortwooftheseprodigiousmasses,weshallnotbethemoreinstructedofthehistoryofancientEgypt:thelanguageofthispeopleislost。Wethereforeknownothingbutthatbeforethemostancienthistorianstherewasmatterformakinganancienthistory。PhilosophicalDictionary:TheImpiousTHEIMPIOUSWHOaretheimpious?thosewhogiveawhitebeard,feetandhandstotheBeingofbeings,tothegreatDemiourgos,totheeternalintelligencebywhichnatureisgoverned。Buttheyareonlyexcusablyimpious,poorimpiouspeopleagainstwhomonemustnotgrowwroth。
IfeventheypaintthegreatincomprehensibleBeingbornonacloudwhichcanbearnothing。iftheyarefoolishenoughtoputGodinamist,intherain,oronamountain,andtosurroundhimwithlittlechubby,flushedfacesaccompaniedbytwowings。IlaughandIpardonthemwithallmyheart。
TheimpiouspersonswhoattributetotheBeingofbeingspreposterouspredictionsandinjusticeswouldangermeifthisgreatBeinghadnotgivenmeareasonwhichquellsmywrath。Thesillyfanaticrepeatstome,afterothers,thatitisnotforustojudgewhatisreasonableandjustinthegreatBeing,thatHisreasonisnotlikeourreason,thatHisjusticeisnotlikeourjustice。Eh!how,youmaddemoniac,doyouwantmetojudgejusticeandreasonotherwisethanbythenotionsIhaveofthem?doyouwantmetowalkotherwisethanwithmyfeet,andtospeakotherwisethanwithmymouth?
TheimpiousmanwhosupposesthegreatBeingjealous,arrogant,malignant,vindictive,ismoredangerous。Iwouldnotwanttosleepunderthesameroofasthisman。
Buthowwouldyoutreattheimpiousmanwhosaystoyou:Seeonlythroughmyeyes,donotthink。IannouncetoyouatyrannicalGodwhohasmademetobeyourtyrant。Iamhiswell-beloved。duringalleternityhewilltorturemillionsofhiscreatureswhomhedetestsinordertogladdenme。
Ishallbeyourmasterinthisworld,andIshalllaughatyourtormentsintheother?
Doyounotfeelanitchingtothrashthiscruel,impiousfellow?Ifyouareborngentle,willyounotrunwithallyourmighttothewestwhenthisbarbarianuttershisatrociousreveriesintheeast?PhilosophicalDictionary:JoanofArcJOANOFARCITismeetthatthereadershouldbeacquaintedwiththetruehistoryofJoanofArcsurnamedtheMaid。Thedetailsofheradventureareverylittleknownandmaygivereaderspleasure。heretheyare。
PaulJovesaysthatthecourageoftheFrenchwasstimulatedbythisgirl,andtakesgoodcarenottobelieveherinspired。NeitherRobert,Gaguin,PaulEmile,PolydoreVergile,Genebrard,PhilipofBergamo,PapyreMasson,norevenMariana,saythatshewassentbyGod。andeventhoughMarianatheJesuithadsaidit,thatwouldnotdeceiveme。
Mezerairelatesthattheprinceofthecelestialmilitiaappearedtoher。IamsorryforMezerai,andIaskpardonoftheprinceofthecelestialmilitia。
Mostofourhistorians,whocopyeachother,supposethattheMaidutteredprophecies,andthatherprophecieswereaccomplished。SheismadetosaythatshewilldrivetheEnglishoutofthekingdom,andtheywerestilltherefiveyearsafterherdeath。SheissaidtohavewrittenalonglettertotheKingofEngland,andassuredlyshecouldneitherreadnorwrite。
suchaneducaticnwasnotgiventoaninnservantintheBarois。andtheinformationlaidagainstherstatesthatshecouldnotsignhername。
But,itissaid,shefoundarustedsword,thebladeofwhichwasengravedwithfivegoldenfleurs-de-lis。andthisswordwashiddeninthechurchofSainteCatherinedeFierboisatTours。There,certainlyisagreatmiracle!
PoorJoanofArchavingbeencapturedbytheEnglish,despiteherpropheciesandhermiracles,maintainedfirstofallinhercross-examinationthatSt。CatherineandSt。Margueritehadhonouredherwithmanyrevelations。
Iamastonishedthatsheneversaidanythingofhertalkswiththeprinceofthecelestialmilitia。ThesetwosaintsapparentlylikedtalkingbetterthanSt。Michael:Herjudgesthoughtherasorceress,shethoughtherselfinspired。
OnegreatproofthatCharlesVII。’scaptainsmadeuseofthemarvellousinordertoencouragethesoldiers,inthedeplorablestatetowhichFrancewasreduced,isthatSaintrailleshadhisshepherd,astheComtedeDunoishadhisshepherdess。Theshepherdmadepropheciesononeside,whiletheshepherdessmadethemontheother。
ButunfortunatelytheComtedeDunois’prophetesswascapturedatthesiegeofCompiegnebyabastardofVendome,andSaintrailles’prophetwascapturedbyTalbot。ThegallantTalbotwasfarfromhavingtheshepherdburned。ThisTalbotwasoneofthosetrueEnglishmenwhoscornsuperstition,andwhohavenotthefanaticismforpunishingfanatics。
This,itseemstome,iswhatthehistoriansshouldhaveobserved,andwhattheyhaveneglected。
TheMaidwastakentoJeandeLuxembourg,ComtedeLigny。ShewasshutupinthefortressofBeaulieu,theninthatofBeaurevoir,andfromthereinthatofCrotoyinPicardy。
FirstofallPierreCauchon,BishopofBeauvais,whowasoftheKingofEngland’spartyagainsthisownlegitimateking,claimstheMaidasasorceressarrestedonthelimitsofhisdiocese。Hewishestojudgeherasasorceress。Hesupportedtherightheclaimedbyadown-rightlie。
JoanhadbeencapturedontheterritoryofthebishopricofNoyon:andneithertheBishopofBeauvais,northeBishopofNoyonassuredlyhadtherightofcondemninganybody,andstilllessofcommittingtodeathasubjectoftheDukeofLorraine,andawarriorinthepayoftheKingofFrance。
Therewasatthattimewhowouldbelieveit?avicar-generaloftheInquisitioninFrance,bynameBrotherMartin。Itwasoneofthemosthorribleeffectsofthetotalsubversionofthatunfortunatecountry。BrotherMartinclaimedtheprisonerassmellingofheresyodorantemhaeresim。HecalledupontheDukeofBurgundyandtheComtedeLigny,bytherightofhisoffice,andoftheauthoritygiventohimbytheHolySee,todeliverJoantotheHolyInquisition。
TheSorbonnehastenedtosupportBrotherMartin,andwrotetotheDukeofBurgundyandtoJeandeLuxembourg-YouhaveusedyournoblepowertoapprehendthiswomanwhocallsherselftheMaid,bymeansofwhomthehonourofGodhasbeenimmeasurablyoffended,thefaithexceedinglyhurt,andtheChurchtoogreatlydishonoured。forbyreasonofher,idolatry,errors,baddoctrine,andotherinestimableevilshaveensuedinthiskingdom……butwhatthiswomanhasdonewouldbeofsmallaccount,ifdidnotensuewhatismeetforsatisfyingtheoffenceperpetratedbyheragainstourgentleCreatorandHisfaith,andtheHolyChurchwithherotherinnumerablemisdeeds……anditwouldbeintolerableoffenceagainstthedivinemajestyifithappenedthatthiswomanwerefreed。
Finally,theMaidwasawardedtoJeanCauchonwhompeoplecalledtheunworthybishop,theunworthyFrenchman,andtheunworthyman。JeandeLuxembourgsoldtheMaidtoCauchonandtheEnglishfortenthousandlivres,andtheDukeofBedfordpaidthem。TheSorbonne,thebishopandBrotherMartin,thenpresentedanewpetitiontothisDukeofBedford,regentofFrance,inhonourofourLordandSaviourJesusChrist,forthatthesaidJoanmaybebrieflyputintothehandsoftheChurch。JoanwasledtoRouen。Thearchbishopricwasvacantatthattime,andthechapterpermittedtheBishopofBeauvaistoworkinthetown。Besogneristhetermwhichwasused。HechoseasassessorsninedoctorsoftheSorbonnewiththirty-fiveotherassisiants,abbotsormonks。ThevicaroftheInquisition,Martin,presidedwithCauchon。andasliewasonlyavicar,hehadbutsecondplace。
Joanunderwentfourteenexaminations。theyaresingular。ShesaidthatshesawSt。CatherineandSt。MargueriteatPoitiers。DoctorBeaupereasksherhowsherecognizedthesaints。Sheanswersthatitwasbytheirwayofbowing。Beaupereasksheriftheyaregreatchatterboxes。Golookontheregister,shesays。Beaupereasksherif,whenshesawSt。Michael,hewasnaked。Sheanswers:DoyouthinkourLordhadnothingtoclothehimwith?
ThecuriouswillcarefullyobserveherethatJoanhadlongbeendirectedwithotherreligiouswomenofthepopulacebyaroguenamedRichard,whoperformedmiracles,andwhotaughtthesegirlstoperformthem。OnedayhegavecommunionthreetimesinsuccessiontoJoan,inhonouroftheTrinity。
Itwasthenthecustominmattersofimportanceandintimesofgreatperil。
Theknightshadthreemassessaid,andcommunicatedthreetimeswhentheywenttoseekfortuneortofightinaduel。ItiswhathasbeenobservedonthepartoftheChevalierBayard。
Theworkersofmiracles,Joan’scompanions,whoweresubmissivetoRichard,werenamedPierroneandCatherine。PierroneaffirmedthatshehadseenthatGodappearedtoherinhumanformasafriendtoafriend。
Godwascladinalongwhiterobe,etc。’’
Uptothepresenttheridiculous。herenowisthehorrible。
OneofJoan’sjudges,doctoroftheologyandpriest,bynameNicholastheBird-Catcher,comestoconfessherinprison。HeabusesthesacramenttothepointofhidingbehindapieceofsergetwopriestswhotranscribedJoanofArc’sconfession。Thusdidthejudgesusesacrilegeinordertobemurderers。Andanunfortunateidiot,whohadhadenoughcouragetorenderverygreatservicestothekingandthecountry,wascondemnedtobeburnedbyfortyfourFrenchpriestswhoimmolatedherfortheEnglishfaction。
Itissufficientlywell-knownhowsomeonehadthecunningandmeannesstoputaman’ssuitbesidehertotempthertowearthissuitagain,andwithwhatabsurdbarbarismthistransgressionwasclaimedasapretextforcondemninghertotheflames,asifinawarriorgirlitwasacrimeworthyofthefire,toputonbreechesinsteadofaskirt。Allthiswringstheheart,andmakescommonsenseshudder。Onecannotconceivehowwedare,afterthecountlesshorrorsofwhichwehavebeenguilty,callanynationbythenameofbarbarian。
Mostofourhistorians,loversoftheso-calledembellishmentsofhistoryratherthanoftruth,saythatJoanwentfearlesslytothetorture。
butasthechroniclesofthetimesbearwitness,andasthehistorianVillaretadmits,shereceivedhersentencewithcriesandtears。aweaknesspardonableinhersex,andperhapsinours,andverycompatiblewiththecouragewhichthisgirlhaddisplayedamidthedangersofwar。foronecanbefearlessinbattle,andsensitiveonthescaffold。
ImustaddthatmanypersonshavebelievedwithoutanyexaminationthattheMaidofOrleanswasnotburnedatRouenatall,althoughwehavetheofficialreportofherexecution。TheyhavebeendeceivedbytheaccountwestillhaveofanadventuresswhotookthenameoftheMaid,deceivedJoanofArc’sbrothers,andundercoverofthisimposture,marriedinLorraineanoblemanofthehouseofArmoise。ThereweretwootherrogueswhoalsopassedthemselvesoffastheMaidofOrleans。AllthreeclaimedthatJoanwasnotburnedatall,andthatanotherwomanhadbeensubstitutedforher。Suchstoriescanbeadmittedonlybythosewhowanttobedeceived。PhilosophicalDictionary:KissingKISSINGIASKpardonoftheboysandthegirls。butmaybetheywillnotfindherewhattheywillseek。Thisarticleisonlyforscholarsandseriouspersonsforwhomitisbarelysuitable。
ThereisbuttoomuchquestionofkissinginthecomediesofMoliere’stime。Champagne,inthecomedyofLaMereCoquettebyQuinault,askskissesofLaurette。Shesaystohim-Youarenotcontent,then。reallyitisshameful。Ihavekissedyoutwice。Champagneanswersher-What!
youkeepaccountofyourkisses?ActI。Sc。I。。
Thevaletsalwaysusedtoaskkissesofthesoubrettes。peoplekissedeachotheronthestage。Usuallyitwasverydullandveryintolerable,particularlyinthecaseofuglyactors,whowerenauseating。
Ifthereaderwantskisses,lethimlookfortheminthePastorFido。thereisoneentirechoruswherenothingbutkissesismentioned。andthepieceisfoundedsolelyonakissthatMirtillogaveonedaytoAmarilli,inagameofblindman’sbuff,unbaciomoltosaporito。
Everyoneknowsthechapteronkisses。inwhichJeandelaCasa,ArchbishopofBenevento,saysthatpeoplecankisseachotherfromheadtofoot。Hepitiesthepeoplewithbignoseswhocanonlyapproacheachotherwithdifficulty。andhecounselsladieswithlongnosestohaveflat-nosedlovers。
Thekisswasaveryordinaryformofsalutationthroughoutancienttimes。
Plutarchrecallsthattheconspirators,beforekiiiingCaesar,kissedhisface,handandbreast。TacitussaysthatwhenAgricola,hisfather-in-law,returnedfromRome,Domitianreceivedhimwithacoldkiss,saidnothingtohim,andlefthimconfoundedinthecrowd。TheinferiorwhocouldnotsucceedingreetinghisSuperiorbykissinghim,puthismouthtohisownhand,andsenthimakissthattheotherreturnedinthesamewayifhesowished。
Thissignwasusedevenforworshippingthegods。Job,inhisparableChap。xxxi。,whichisperhapstheoldestofknownbooks,saysthathehasnotworshippedthesunandthemoonliketheotherArabs,thathehasnotcarriedhishandtohismouthashelookedatthestars。
InourOccidentnothingremainsofthisancientcustombutthepuerileandgenteelcivilitythatisstilltaughttochildreninsomesmalltowns,ofkissingtheirrighthandswhensomeonehasgiventhemsomesweets。
Itwasahorriblethingtobetraywithakiss。itwasthatthatmadeCaesar’sassassinationstillmorehateful。WeknowallaboutJudas’kisses。
theyhavebecomeproverbial。
Joab,oneofDavid’scaptains,beingveryjealousofAmasa,anothercaptain,saystohim2Sam。xx。9:Artthouinhealth,mybrother?
AndhetookAmasabythebeardwiththerighthandtokisshim,andwithhisotherhanddrewhisswordandsmotehimtherewithinthefifthrib,andshedouthisbowelsontheground。
NootherkissistobefoundintheotherfairlyfrequentassassinationswhichwerecommittedamongtheJews,unlessitbeperhapsthekisseswhichJudithgavetothecaptainHolophernes,beforecuttingoffhisheadwhilehewasinbedasleep。butnomentionismadeofthem,andthethingismerelyprobable。
InoneofShakespeare’stragediescalledOthello,thisOthello,whoisablack,givestwokissestohiswifebeforestranglingher。Thatseemsabominabletohonourablepeople。butShakespeare’spartisanssayitisbeautifullynatural,particularlyinablack。
WhenGiovanniGaleasSforzawasassassinatedinMilanCathedral,onSt。Stephen’sday,thetwoMediciintheRepahtachurch。AdmiralColigny,thePrinceofOrange,theMarechald’Ancre,thebrothersWitt,andsomanyothers。atleasttheywerenotkissed。
TherewasamongtheancientsIknownotwhatofsymbolicandsacredattachedtothekiss,sinceonekissedthestatuesofthegodsandtheirbeards,whenthesculptorshadshownthemwithabeard。InitiateskissedeachotheratthemysteriesofCeres,asasignofconcord。
TheearlyChristians,menandwomen,kissedeachotheronthemouthattheiragapae。Thiswordsignifiedlovefeast。Theygaveeachothertheholykiss,thekissofpeace,thekissofbrotherandsister。
Thiscustomlastedformorethanfourcenturies,andwasabolishedatlastonaccountofitsconsequences。Itwasthesekissesofpeace,theseagapaeoflove,thesenamesofbrotherand’’sister,thatlongdrewtothelittle-knownChristians,thoseimputationsofdebaucherywithwhichthepriestsofJupiterandthepriestessesofVestachargedthem。YouseeinPetronius,andinotherprofaneauthors,thatthelibertinescalledthemselvesbrotherandsister。ItwasthoughtthatamongtheChristiansthesamenamessignifiedthesameinfamies。TheywereinnocentaccomplicesinspreadingtheseaccusationsovertheRomanempire。
TherewereinthebeginningseventeendifferentChristiansocieties,justastherewerenineamongtheJews,includingthetwokindsofSamaritans。
Thesocietieswhichflatteredthemselvesatbeingthemostorthodoxaccusedtheothersofthemostinconceivableobscenities。Thetermofgnostic,
whichwasatfirstsohonourable,signifyinglearned,enlightened,
pure,becameatermofhorrorandscorn,areproachofheresy。SaintEpiphanius,inthethirdcentury,claimedthattheyusedfirsttotickleeachother,themenandthewomen。thatthentheygaveeachotherveryimmodestkisses,andthattheyjudgedthedegreeoftheirfaithbythevoluptuousnessofthesekisses。thatthehusbandsaidtohiswife,inpresentingayounginitiatetoher:Haveanagapewithmybrother,andthattheyhadanagapa。
Wedonotdarerepeathere,inthechasteFrenchtongue,whatSaintEpiphaniusaddsinGreekEpiphanius,contrahaeres,lib。I。,vol。
ii。Wewillsaymerelythatperhapsthissaintwassomewhatimposedupon。
thatheallowed,himselftobetoocarriedawaybyzeal,andthatallhereticsarenothideousdebauchees。
ThesectofPietists,wishingtoimitatetheearlyChristians,to-daygiveeachotherkissesofpeaceonleavingtheassembly,callingeachothermybrother,mysister。itiswhat,twentyyearsago,averyprettyandveryhumanPietistladyavowedtome。Theancientcustomwastokissonthemouth。thePietistshavecarefullypreservedit。
TherewasnoothermannerofgreetingdamesinFrance,Germany,Italy,England。itwastherightofcardinalstokissqueensonthemouthandinSpaineven。WhatissingularisthattheyhadnotthesameprerogativeinFrance,whereladiesalwayshadmorelibertythananywhereelse,buteverycountryhasitsceremonies,andthereisnousagesogeneralthatchanceandcustomhavenotprovidedexceptions。Itwouldhavebeenanincivility,anaffront,foranhonourablewoman,whenshereceivedalord’sfirstvisit,nottohavekissedhim,despitehismoustaches。Itisadispleasingcustom,
saysMontaigneBookIII。,chap。v。,andoffensivetoladies,tohavetolendtheirlipstowhoeverhasthreeserving-meninhissuite,disagreeablethoughhebe。Thiscustomwas,nevertheless,theoldestintheworld。
Ifitisdisagreeableforayoungandprettymouthtostickitselfoutofcourtesytoanoldanduglymouth,therewasagreatdangerbetweenfresh,redmouthsoftwentytotwenty-fiveyearsold。andthatiswhatfinallybroughtabouttheabolitionoftheceremonyofkissinginthemysteriesandtheagapae。ItiswhatcausedwomentobeconfinedamongtheOrientals,sothattheymightkissonlytheirfathersandtheirbrothers。customlongsinceintroducedintoSpainbytheArabs。
Beholdthedanger:thereisonenerveofthefifthpairwhichgoesfromthemouthtotheheart,andthencelowerdown,withsuchdelicateindustryhasnaturepreparedeverything!Thelittleglandsofthelips,theirspongytissue,theirvelvetypaps,thefineskin,ticklish,givesthemanexquisiteandvoluptuoussensation,whichisnotwithoutanalogywithastillmorehiddenandstillmoresensitivepart。ModestymaysufferfromalengthilysavouredkissbetweentwoPietistsofeighteen。
ItistoberemarkedthatthehumanSpecies,theturtledovesandthepigeonsaloneareacquaintedwithkisses。thencecameamongtheLatinsthewordcolumbatim,whichourlanguagehasnotbeenabletorender。Thereisnothingofwhichabusehasnotbeenmade。Thekiss,designedbynatureforthemouth,hasoftenbeenprostitutedtomembraneswhichdonotseemmadeforthisusage。Oneknowsofwhatthetemplarswereaccused。
Wecannothonestlytreatthisinterestingsubjectatgreaterlength,althoughMontaignesays:Oneshouldspeakthereofshamelessly:brazenlydoweutter’killing,’’wounding,’’betraying,’butofthatwedarenotspeakbutwithbatedbreath。PhilosophicalDictionary:LanguagesLANGUAGESTHEREisnocompletelanguage,nolanguagewhichcanexpressallourideasandalloursensations。theirshadesaretoonumerous,tooimperceptible。
Nobodycanmakeknowntheprecisedegreeofsensationheexperiences。Oneisobliged,forexample,todesignatebythegeneralnamesofloveandhateathousandlovesandathousandhatesalldifferentfromeachother。
itisthesamewithourpleasuresandourpains。Thusalllanguagesare,likeus,imperfect。
Theyhaveallbeenmadesuccessivelyandbydegreesaccordingtoourneeds。Itistheinstinctcommontoallmenwhichmadethefirstgrammarswithoutperceivingit。TheLapps,theNegroes,aswellastheGreeks,neededtoexpressthepast,thepresentandthefuture。andtheydidit:butastherehasneverbeenanassemblyoflogicianswhoformedalanguage,nolanguagehasbeenabletoattainaperfectlyregularplan。
Allwords,inallpossiblelanguages,arenecessarilytheimagesofsensations。Menhaveneverbeenabletoexpressanythingbutwhattheyfelt。Thuseverythinghasbecomemetaphor。everywherethesoulisenlightened,theheartburns,themindwanders。Amongallpeoplestheinfinitehasbeenthenegationofthefinite。immensitythenegationofmeasure。Itisevidentthatourfivesenseshaveproducedalllanguages,aswellasallourideas。
Theleastimperfectarelikethelaws:thoseinwhichthereistheleastthatisarbitraryarethebest。Themostcompletearenecessarilythoseofthepeopleswhohavecultivatedtheartsandsociety。ThustheHebraiclanguageshouldbeoneofthepoorestlanguages,likethepeoplewhousedtospeakit。HowshouldtheHebrewshavehadmaritimeterms,theywhobeforeSolomonhadnotaboat?howthetermsofphilosophy,theywhowereplungedinsuchprofoundignoranceuptothetimewhentheystartedtolearnsomethingintheirmigrationtoBabylon?ThelanguageofthePhoenicians,fromwhichtheHebrewsdrewtheirjargon,shouldbeverysuperior,becauseitwastheidiomofanindustrious,commercial,richpeople,distributedallovertheearth。
Themostancientknownlanguageshouldbethatofthenationmostancientlygatheredtogetherasabodyofpeople。Itshouldbe,further,thatofthepeoplewhichhasbeenleastsubjugated,orwhich,havingbeensubjugated,hascivilizeditsconquerors。Andinthisrespect,itisconstantthatChineseandArabicarethemostancientofallthosethatarespokento-day。
Thereisnomother-tongue。Allneighbouringnationshaveborrowedfromeachother:butonehasgiventhenameofmother-tonguetothosefromwhichsomeknownidiomsarederived。Forexample,LatinisthemothertongueinrespectofItalian,SpanishandFrench:butitwasitselfderivedfromTuscan。andTuscanwasderivedfromCelticandGreek。
Themostbeautifulofalllanguagesmustbethatwhichisatonce,themostcomplete,themostsonorous,themostvariedinitstwistsandthemostregularinitsprogress,thatwhichhasmostcompoundwords,thatwhichbyitsprosodybestexpressesthesoul’ssloworimpetuousmovements,thatwhichmostresemblesmusic。
Greekhasalltheseadvantages:ithasnottheroughnessofLatin,inwhichsomanywordsendinum,ur,us。IthasallthepompofSpanish’,andallthesweetnessofItalian。Ithasaboveallthelivinglanguagesoftheworldtheexpressionofmusic,bylongandshortsyllables,andbythenumberandvarietyofitsaccents。Thusalldisfiguredasitisto-dayinGreece,itcanstillberegardedasthemostbeautifullanguageintheuniverse。
Themostbeautifullanguagecannotbethemostwidelydistributed,whenthepeoplewhichspeaksitisoppressed,notnumerous,withoutcommercewithothernations,andwhentheseothernationshavecultivatedtheirownlanguages。ThusGreekshouldbelessdiffusedthanArabic,andevenTurkish。
OfallEuropeanlanguagesFrenchshouldbethemostgeneral,becauseitisthemostsuitedtoconversation:ithastakenitscharacterfromthatofthepeoplewhichspeaksit。
TheFrenchhavebeen,fornearlyahundredandfiftyyears,thepeoplewhichhasbestknownsociety,whichthefirstdiscardedallembarrassment,andthefirstamongwhomwomenwerefreeandevensovereign,whenelsewheretheywereonlyslaves。Thealwaysuniformsyntaxofthislanguage,whichadmitsnoinversions,isafurtherfacilitybarelypossessedbyothertongues。
itismorecurrentcointhanothers,eventhoughitlacksweight。Theprodigiousquantityofagreeablyfrivolousbookswhichthisnationhasproducedisafurtherreasonforthefavourwhichitslanguagehasobtainedamongallnations。
Profoundbookswillnotgivevoguetoalanguage:theywillbetranslated。
peoplewilllearnNewton’sphilosophy。buttheywillnotlearnEnglishinordertounderstandit。
WhatmakesFrenchstillmorecommonistheperfectiontowhichthedramahasbeencarriedinthistongue。ItistoCinna,Phedre,theMisanthrope’’thatitowesitsvogue,andnottotheconquestsofLouisXIV。
ItisnotsocopiousandsoflexibleasItalian,orsomajesticasSpanish,orsoenergeticasEnglish。andyetithashadmoresuccessthanthesethreelanguagesfromthesolefactthatitismoresuitedtointercourse,andthattherearemoreagreeablebooksinitthanelsewhere。IthassucceededlikethecooksofFrance,becauseithasmoreflatteredgeneraltaste。
ThesamespiritwhichhasledthenationstoimitatetheFrenchintheirfurniture,inthearrangementofrooms,ingardens,indancing,inallthatgivescharm,hasledthemalsotospeaktheirlanguage。ThegreatartofgoodFrenchwritersispreciselythatofthewomenofthisnation,whodressbetterthantheotherwomenofEurope,andwho,withoutbeingmorebeautiful,appeartobesobytheartwithwhichtheyadornthemselves,bythenobleandsimplecharmtheygivethemselvessonaturally。
Itisbydintofgoodbreedingthatthislanguagehasmanagedtomakethetracesofitsformerbarbarismdisappear。Everythingwouldbearwitnesstothisbarbarismtowhosoevershouldlookclosely。Onewouldseethatthenumbervingtcomesfromviginti,andthatformerlythisgandthistwerepronouncedwitharoughnesscharacteristicofallthenorthernnations。ofthemonthofAugustushasbeenmadethemonthofaout。NotsolongagoaGermanprincethinkingthatinFranceoneneverpronouncedthetermAugusteotherwise,calledKingAugusteofPolandKingAout。Alltheletterswhichhavebeensuppressedinpronunciation,butretainedinwriting,areourformerbarbarousclothes。
Itwaswhenmannersweresoftenedthatthelanguagealsowassoftened:
beforeFrancoisIsummonedwomentohiscourt,itwasasclownishaswewere。ItwouldhavebeenasgoodtospeakoldCelticastheFrenchofthetimeofCharlesVIII。andLouisXII。:Germanwasnotmoreharsh。
Ithastakencenturiestoremovethisrust。Theimperfectionswhichremainwouldstillbeintolerable,wereitnotforthecontinualcareonetakestoavoidthem,asaskilfulhorsemanavoidsstonesintheroad。Goodwritersarecarefultocombatthefaultyexpressionswhichpopularignorancefirstbringsintovogue,andwhich,adoptedbybadauthors,thenpassintothegazettesandthepamphlets。RoastbeefsignifiesinEnglishroastedox,andourwaiterstalktousnowadaysofaroastbeefofmutton。Ridingcoatmeansacoatforgoingonhorseback。ofitpeoplehavemaderedingote,andthepopulacethinksitanancientwordofthelanguage。Ithasbeennecessarytoadoptthisexpressionwiththepeoplebecauseitsignifiesanarticleofcommonuse。
Inmattersofartsandcraftsandnecessarythings,thecommonpeoplesubjugatedthecourt,ifonedaresayso。justasinmattersofreligionthosewhomostdespisethecommonrunofpeopleareobligedtospeakandtoappeartothinklikethem。
Tocallthingsbythenameswhichthecommonpeoplehasimposedonthemisnottospeakbadly。butonerecognizesapeoplenaturallymoreingeniousthananotherbythepropernameswhichitgivestoeachthing。
Itisonlythroughlackofimaginationthatapeopleadaptsthesameexpressiontoahundreddifferentideas。Itisaridiculoussterilitynottohaveknownhowtoexpressotherwiseanarmofthesea,ascalearm,anarmofachair。thereispovertyofthoughtinsayingequallytheheadofanail,theheadofanarmy。
Ignorancehasintroducedanothercustomintoallmodernlanguages。A
thousandtermsnolongersignifywhattheyshouldsignify。Idiotmeantsolitary,to-dayitmeansfoolish。epiphanysignifiedappearance,to-dayitisthefestivalofthreekings。baptizeistodipinwater,wesaybaptizewiththenameofJohnorJames。
Tothesedefectsinalmostalllanguagesareaddedbarbarousirregularities。Venusisacharmingname,venerealisabominable。Anotherresultoftheirregularityoftheselanguagescomposedathazardinuncouthtimesisthequantityofcompoundwordsofwhichthesimpleformdoesnotexistanymore。Theyarechildrenwhohavelosttheirfather。Wehavearchitectsandnotects。therearethingswhichareineffableandnonewhichareeffable。Oneisintrepid,oneisnottrepid。
Thereareimpudentfellows,insolentfellows,butneitherpudentfellowsnorsolentfellows。Alllanguagesmoreorlessretainsomeofthesedefects。theyareallirregularlandsfromwhichthehandoftheadroitartistknowshowtoderiveadvantage。
Otherdefectswhichmakeanation’scharacterevidentalwaysslipintolanguages。InFrancetherearefashionsinexpressionsasinwaysofdoingthehair。AfashionableinvalidordoctorwilltakeitintohisheadtosaythathehashadasoupconoffevertoSignifythathehashadaslightattack。soonthewholenationhassoupconsofcolics,soupconsofhatred,love,ridicule。PreachersinthepulpittellyouthatyoumusthaveatleastasoupconofGod’slove。Afterafewmonthsthisfashiongivesplacetoanother。
Whatdoesmostharmtothenobilityofthelanguageisnotthispassingfashionwithwhichpeoplearesoondisgusted,notthesolecismsoffashionablepeopleintowhichgoodauthorsdonotfall,buttheaffectationofmediocreauthorsinspeakingofseriousthingsinaconversationalstyle。Everythingconspirestocorruptalanguagethatisratherwidelydiffused。authorswhospoilthestylebyaffectation。thosewhowritetoforeigncountries,andwhoalmostalwaysmingleforeignexpressionswiththeirnaturaltongue。
merchantswhointroduceintoconversationtheirbusinessterms。
Alllanguagesbeingimperfect,itdoesnotfollowthatoneshouldchangethem。Onemustadhereabsolutelytothemannerinwhichthegoodauthorshavespokenthem。andwhenonehasasufficientnumberofapprovedauthors,alanguageisfixed。ThusonecannolongerchangeanythinginItalian,Spanish,English,French’,withoutcorruptingthem。thereasonisclear:
itisthatonewouldsoonrenderunintelligiblethebookswhichprovidetheinstructionandthepleasureofthenations。PhilosophicalDictionary:LawsLAWSSHEEPliveveryplacidlyincommunity,theyareconsideredveryeasy-going,becausewedonotseetheprodigiousquantityofanimalstheydevour。Itiseventobebelievedthattheyeattheminnocentlyandwithoutknowingit,likeUswhenweeataSassenagecheese。Therepublicofthesheepisafaithfulrepresentationofthegoldenage。
Achicken-runisvisiblythemostperfectmonarchicstate。Thereisnokingcomparabletoacock。Ifhemarchesproudlyinthemidstofhispeople,itisnotoutofvanity。Iftheenemyapproaches,hedoesnotgiveorderstohissubjectstogotokillthemselvesforhimbyvirtueofhiscertainknowledgeandplenarypower。hegoestobattlehimself,rangeshischickensbehindhimandfightstothedeath。Ifheisthevictor,hehimselfsingstheTeDeum。Incivillifethereisnoonesogallant,sohonest,sodisinterested。Hehasallthevirtues。Hasheinhisroyalbeakagrainofcorn,agrub,hegivesittothefirstladyamonghissubjectswhopresentsherself。Solomoninhisharemdidnotcomenearapoultry-yardcock。
Ifitbetruethatthebeesaregovernedbyaqueentowhomallhersubjectsmakelove,thatisastillmoreperfectgovernment。
Theantsareconsideredtobeanexcellentdemocracy。DemocracyisabovealltheotherStates,becausethereeveryoneisequal,andeachindividualworksforthegoodofall。
Therepublicofthebeaversisstillsuperiortothatoftheants,atleastifwejudgebytheirmasonrywork。
Themonkeysresemblestrollingplayersratherthanacivilizedpeople。
andtheydonotappeartobegatheredtogetherunderfixed,fundamentallaws,liketheprecedingspecies。
Weresemblethemonkeysmorethananyotheranimalbythegiftofimitation,thefrivolityofourideas,andbyourinconstancywhichhasneverallowedustohaveuniformanddurablelaws。
Whennatureformedourspeciesandgaveusinstincts,self-esteemforourpreservation,benevolenceforthepreservationofothers,lovewhichiscommontoallthespecies,andtheinexplicablegiftofcombiningmoreideasthanalltheanimalstogether。whenshehadthusgivenusourportion,shesaidtous:Doasyoucan。
Thereisnogoodcodeinanycountry。Thereasonforthisisevident。
thelawshavebeenmadeaccordingtothetimes,theplaceandtheneed,etc。
Whentheneedshavechanged,thelawswhichhaveremained,havebecomeridiculous。ThusthelawwhichforbadetheeatingofpigandthedrinkingofwinewasveryreasonableinArabia,wherepigandwineareinjurious。
itisabsurdatConstantinople。
Thelawwhichgivesthewholefeetotheeldestsonisverygoodintimesofanarchyandpillage。Thentheeldestsonisthecaptainofthecastlewhichthebrigandswillattacksoonerorlater。theyoungersonswillbehischiefofficers,thehusbandmenhissoldiers。AllthatistobefearedisthattheyoungersonmayassassinateorpoisontheSalianlordhiselderbrother,inordertobecomeinhisturnthemasterofthehovel。butthesecasesarerare,becausenaturehassocombinedourinstinctsandourpassionsthatwehavemorehorrorofassassinatingourelderbrotherthanwehaveofbeingenviousofhisposition。Butthislaw,suitablefortheownersofdungeonsinChilperic’stimeisdetestablewhenthereisquestionofsharingstocksinacity。
Totheshameofmankind,oneknowsthatthelawsofgamesaretheonlyoneswhicheverywherearejust,clear,inviolableandexecuted。WhyistheIndianwhogaveustherulesofthegameofchesswillinglyobeyedallovertheworld,andwhyarethepopes’decretals,forexample,to-dayanobjectofhorrorandscorn?thereasonisthattheinventorofchesscombinedeverythingwithprecisionforthesatisfactionoftheplayers,andthatthepopes,intheirdecretals,hadnothinginviewbuttheirowninterest。TheIndianwishedtoexercisemen’smindsequally,andgivethempleasure。thepopeswishedtobesotmen’sminds。Also,theessenceofthegameofchesshasremainedthesameforfivethousandyears,itiscommontoalltheinhabitantsoftheearth。andthedecretalsareknownonlyatSpoletto,Orvieto,Loretto,wheretheshallowestlawyersecretlyhatesanddespisesthem。
ButIdelightinthinkingthatthereisanaturallawindependentofallhumanconventions:thefruitofmyworkmustbelongtome。Imusthonourmyfatherandmymother。Ihavenorightovermyfellow’slife,andmyfellowhasnoneovermine,etc。ButwhenIthinkthatfromChedorlaomertoMentzel,colonelofhussars,everyoneloyallykillsandpillageshisfellowwithalicenceinhispocket,Iamveryafflicted。
Iamtoldthattherearelawsamongthieves,andalsolawsofwar。I
askwhataretheselawsofwar。Ilearnthattheymeanhangingabraveofficerwhohasheldfastinabadpostwithoutcannonagainstaroyalarmy。thattheymeanhavingaprisonerhanged,iftheenemyhashangedoneofyours。thattheymeanputtingtothefireandtheswordvillageswhichhavenotbroughttheirsustenanceontheappointedday,accordingtotheordersofthegracioussovereignofthedistrict。Good,sayI,thatisthe’SpiritoftheLaws。’
Itseemstomethatmostmenhavereceivedfromnatureenoughcommonsensetomakelaws,butthateveryoneisnotjustenoughtomakegoodlaws。PhilosophicalDictionary:LibertyLIBERTYEITHERIamverymuchmistaken,orLockethedefinerhasverywelldefinedlibertyaspower。Iammistakenagain,orCollins,celebratedLondonmagistrate,istheonlyphilosopherwhohasreallysiftedthisidea,andClark’sanswertohimwasmerelythatofatheologian。ButofallthathasbeenwritteninFranceonliberty,thefollowinglittledialogueseemstomethemostclear。
A:Thereisabatteryofgunsfiringinyourears,haveyouthelibertytohearthemornottohearthem?
B:Withoutdoubt,Icannotstopmyselfhearingthem。
A:Doyouwantthisguntocarryoffyourheadandtheheadsofyourwifeanddaughter,whoarewalkingwithyou?
B:Whatareyoutalkingabout?aslongasIamofsoundmind,Icannotwantsuchathing。itisimpossible。
A:Good。youhearthisgunnecessarily,andyouwishnecessarilythatneitheryounoryourfamilyshalldiefromacannonshotwhileyouareoutforawalk。youhavenotthepowereitherofnothearingorofwishingtoremainhere?
B:Clearly。
A:Youhaveconsequentlytakensomethirtystepsinordertobeshelteredfromthegun,youhavehadthepowertowalkthesefewstepswithme?
B:Againveryclearly。
A:Andifyouhadbeenaparalytic,youcouldnothaveavoidedbeingexposedtothisbattery,youwouldnecessarilyhaveheardandreceivedagunshot。andyouwouldbedeadnecessarily?
B:Nothingismoretrue。
A:Inwhatthendoesyourlibertyconsist,unlessitbeinthepowerthatyourselfhasexercisedinperformingwhatyourwillrequiredofabsolutenecessity?
B:Youembarrassme。libertythenisnothingbutthepowerofdoingwhatIwanttodo?
A:Thinkaboutit,andseeiflibertycanbeunderstoodotherwise。
B:InthatcasemyhuntingdogisasfreeasIam。hehasnecessarilythewilltorunwhenheseesahare,andthepowerofrunningifhehasnotapaininhislegs。Ihavethennothingabovemydog。youreducemetothestateofthebeasts。
A:Whatpoorsophistryfromthepoorsophistswhohavetaughtyou。Indeedyouareinabadwaytobefreelikeyourdog!Doyounoteat,sleep,propagatelikehim,evenalmosttotheattitude?Doyouwantthesenseofsmellotherthanthroughyournose?Whydoyouwanttohavelibertyotherwisethanyourdoghas?
B:ButIhaveasoulwhichreasonsmuch,andmydogreasonshardlyatall。Hehasalmostonlysimpleideas,andIhaveathousandmetaphysicalideas。
A:Well,youareathousandtimesfreerthanheis。thatis,youhaveathousandtimesmorepowerofthinkingthanhehas。butyoudonotthinkotherwisethanhedoes。
B:What!IamnotfreetowishwhatIwish?
A:Whatdoyoumeanbythat?
B:Imeanwhateveryonemeans。Doesn’tonesayeveryday,wishesarefree?
A:Aproverbisnotareason。explainyourselfmoreclearly。
B:ImeanthatIamfreetowishasIplease。
A:Withyourpermission,thathasnoSense。doyounotseethatitisridiculoustosay,Iwishtowish?Youwishnecessarily,asaresultoftheideasthathaveofferedthemselvestoyou。Doyouwishtobemarried。
yesorno?
B:ButifItellyouthatIwantneithertheonenortheother?
A:Youwillbeansweringlikesomeonewhosays:SomebelieveCardinalMazarintobedead,othersbelievehimtobealive,andasformeIbelieveneithertheonenortheother。
B:Well,Iwanttobemarried。
A:Ah!thatisananswer。Whydoyouwanttobemarried?
B:BecauseIaminlovewithabeautiful,sweet,well-bredyounggirl,whoisfairlyrichandsingsverywell,whoseparentsareveryhonestpeople,andbecauseIflattermyselfIamlovedbyher,andverywelcometoherfamily。
A:Thatisareason。Youseethatyoucannotwishwithoutreason。I
declaretoyouthatyouarefreetomarry。thatis,thatyouhavethepowertosignthecontract,haveyournuptials,andsleepwithyourwife。
B:Hownow!Icannotwishwithoutreason?Andwhatwillbecomeofthatotherproverb:Sitprorationevoluntas。mywillismyreason,IwishbecauseIwish?
A:Thatisabsurd,mydearfellow。therewouldbeinyouaneffectwithoutacause。
B:What!WhenIplayatoddsandevens,Ihaveareasonforchoosingevensratherthanodds?
A:Yes,undoubtedly。
B:Andwhatisthatreason,ifyouplease?
A:Thereasonisthattheideaofevenratherthantheoppositeideapresentsitselftoyourmind。Itwouldbecomicthattherewerecaseswhereyouwishedbecausetherewasacauseofwishing,andthattherewerecaseswhereyouwishedwithoutanycause。Whenyouwishtobemarried,youevidentlyfeelthedominatingreason。youdonotfeelitwhenyouareplayingatoddsandevens。andyettherecertainlymustbeone。
B:But,Irepeat,Iamnotfreethen?
A:Yourwillisnotfree,butyouractionsare。Youarefreetoact,whenyouhavethepowertoact。
B:ButallthebooksIhavereadonthelibertyofindifference……
A:Whatdoyoumeanbythelibertyofindifference?
B:Imeanthelibertyofspittingontherightorontheleft,ofsleepingonmyrightsideoronmyleft,oftakingawalkoffourturnsorfive。
A:Reallythelibertyyouwouldhavetherewouldbeacomicliberty!
Godwouldhavegivenyouafinegift!Itwouldreallybesomethingtoboastof!Ofwhatusetoyouwouldbeapowerwhichwasexercisedonlyonsuchfutileoccasions?Butthefactisthatitisridiculoustosupposethewilltowishtospitontheright。Notonlyisthiswilltowishabsurd,butitiscertainthatseveraltriflingcircumstancesdetermineyouintheseactsthatyoucallindifferent。Youarenomorefreeintheseactsthanintheothers。But,Irepeat,youarefreeatalltimes,inallplaces,assoonasyoudowhatyouwishtodo。
B:Isuspectyouareright。Iwillthinkaboutit。PhilosophicalDictionary:LibraryLIBRARYABIGlibraryhasthisinitofgood,thatitdismaysthosewholookatit。Twohundredthousandvolumesdiscourageamantemptedtoprint。
butunfortunatelyheatoncesaystohimself:Peopledonotreadallthosebooks,andtheymayreadmine。Hecompareshimselftoadropofwaterwhocomplainsofbeinglostintheoceanandignored:ageniushadpityonit。hecausedittobeswallowedbyanoyster。itbecamethemostbeautifulpearlintheOrient,andwasthechiefornamentinthethroneoftheGreatMogul。Thosewhoareonlycompilers,imitators,commentators,splittersofphrases,usuriouscritics,inshort,thoseonwhomageniushasnopity,willalwaysremaindropsofwater。
Ourmanworksinhisgarret,therefore,inthehopeofbecomingapearl。
Itistruethatinthisimmensecollectionofbooksthereareaboutahundredandninety-ninethousandwhichwillneverberead,fromcovertocoveratleast。butonemayneedtoconsultsomeofthemonceinalifetime。
Itisagreatadvantageforwhoeverwishestolearntofindathishandintheking’spalacethevolumeandpageheseeks,withoutbeingkeptwaitingamoment。Itisoneofthemostnobleinstitutions。Noexpenseismoremagnificentandmoreuseful。
ThepubliclibraryoftheKingofFranceisthefinestinthewholeworld,lessonaccountofthenumberandrarityofthevolumesthanoftheeaseandcourtesywithwhichthelibrarianslendthemtoallscholars。
ThislibraryisincontestablythemostpreciousmonumentthereisinFrance。
Thisastoundingmultitudeofbooksshouldnotscare。WehavealreadyremarkedthatPariscontainsaboutsevenhundredthousandmen,thatonecannotlivewiththemall,andthatonechoosesthreeorfourfriends。
Thusmustonenomorecomplainofthemultitudeofbooksthanofthemultitudeofcitizens。
Amanwhowishestolearnalittleabouthisexistence,andwhohasnotimetowaste,isquiteembarrassed。HewishestoreadsimultaneouslyHobbes,Spinosa,Baylewhowroteagainstthem,LeibnitzwhodisputedwithBayle,ClarkewhodisputedwithLeibnitz,Malebranchewhodifferedfromthemall,LockewhopassedashavingconfoundedMalebranche,StillingfleetwhothoughthehadvanquishedLocke,Cudworthwhothinkshimselfabovethembecauseheisunderstoodbynoone。Onewoulddieofoldagebeforehavingthumbedthehundredthpartofthemetaphysicalromances。
Oneisverycontenttohavethemostancientbooks,asoneinquiresintothemostancientmedals。Itisthatwhichmakesthehonourofalibrary。
TheoldestbooksintheworldaretheKingsoftheChinese,theShastabad,,oftheBrahmins,ofwhichMr。Holwellhasbroughttoourknowledgeadmirablepassages,whatremainsoftheancientZarathustra,thefragmentsofSanchoniathonwhichEusebiushaspreservedforusandwhichbearsthecharacteristicsofthemostremoteantiquity。IdonotspeakofthePentateuchwhichisaboveallonecouldsayofit。