SurelyifdisusecanbecreditedwiththevastpowersinvolvedinMr。Darwin’sstatementthatithasprobably\"beenthemainagentinrenderingorgansrudimentary,\"nolimitsareassignabletotheaccumulatedeffectsofhabit,providedtheeffectsofhabit,oruseanddisuse,aresupposed,asMr。Darwinsupposedthem,tobeinheritableatall。DarwinianshaveatlengthwokeuptothedilemmainwhichtheyareplacedbythemannerinwhichMr。Darwintriedtositonthetwostoolsofuseanddisuse,andnaturalselectionofaccidentalvariations,atthesametime。TheknellofCharles-DarwinismisrunginMr。Wallace’spresentbook,andinthegeneralperceptiononthepartofbiologiststhatwemusteitherassigntouseanddisusesuchapredominantshareinmodificationastomakeitthefeaturemostpropertobeinsistedon,ordenythatthemodifications,whetherofmindorbody,acquiredduringasinglelifetime,areevertransmittedatall。Iftheycanbeinheritedatall,theycanbeaccumulated。Iftheycanbeaccumulatedatall,theycanbeso,foranythingthatappearstothecontrary,totheextentofthespecificandgenericdifferenceswithwhichwearesurrounded。Theonlythingtodoistopluckthemoutrootandbranch:theyareasacancerwhich,ifthesmallestfibrebeleftunexcised,willgrowagain,andkillanysystemontowhichitisallowedtofasten。Mr。Wallace,therefore,maywellbeexcusedifhecastslongingeyestowardsWeismannism。
AndwhatwasMr。Darwin’ssystem?Whocanmakeheadortailoftheinextricablemuddleinwhichheleftit?The\"OriginofSpecies\"initslatestshapeisthereductionofhedgingtoanabsurdity。HowdidMr。Darwinhimselfleaveitinthelastchapterofthelasteditionofthe\"OriginofSpecies\"?Hewrote:-
\"Ihavenowrecapitulatedthefactsandconsiderationswhichhavethoroughlyconvincedmethatspecieshavebeenmodifiedduringalongcourseofdescent。Thishasbeeneffectedchieflythroughthenaturalselectionofnumerous,successive,slight,favourablevariations;aidedinanimportantmannerbytheinheritedeffectsoftheuseanddisuseofparts,andinanunimportantmanner——thatis,inrelationtoadaptivestructureswhetherpastorpresent——bythedirectactionofexternalconditions,andbyvariationswhichseemtousinourignorancetoarisespontaneously。ItappearsthatI
formerlyunderratedthefrequencyandvalueoftheselatterformsofvariation,asleadingtopermanentmodificationsofstructureindependentlyofnaturalselection。\"
The\"numerous,successive,slight,favourablevariations\"abovereferredtoareintendedtobefortuitous,accidental,spontaneous。