Think——noteitwell。\'
\'But——whatdoesitmean？\'
\'Listen，andyouwillknow。Iquoteherinspiredwordsagain：\"IntheopeningoftheSixthSeal，typicalofsixthousandyearssinceAdam，thereisonedistinctivefeaturewhichhasspecialreferencetothepresentage。Thus：
\'\"Revelationxii。1。Andthereappearedagreatwonderinheaven——awomanclothedwiththesun，andthemoonunderherfeet，anduponherheadacrownoftwelvestars。\"
\'ThatisourHead，ourChief，ourDiscovererofChristianScience——
nothingcanbeplainer，nothingsurer。Andnotethis：
\'\"Revelationxii。6。Andthewomanfledintothewilderness，whereshehadaplacepreparedofGod。\"
\'ThatisBoston。\'
\'Irecogniseit，madam。Thesearesublimethingsandimpressive；Ineverunderstoodthesepassagesbefore；pleasegoonwiththe——withthe——
proofs。\'
\'Verywell。Listen：
\'\"AndIsawanothermightyangelcomedownfromheaven，clothedwithacloud；andarainbowwasuponhishead，andhisfacewasasitwerethesun，andhisfeetaspillarsoffire。Andhehadinhishandalittlebook。\"
\'Alittlebook，merelyalittlebook——couldwordsbemodester？Yethowstupendousitsimportance！Doyouknowwhatbookthatwas？\'
\'Wasit——\'
\'Iholditinmyhand——\"ChristianScience\"！\'
\'Love，Livers，Lights，Bones，Truth，Kidneys，oneofaseries，aloneandwithoutequal——itisbeyondimaginationandwonder！\'
\'HearourFounder\'seloquentwords：\"Thenwillavoicefromharmonycry，\'Goandtakethelittlebook；takeitandeatitup，anditshallmakethybellybitter；butitshallbeinthymouthsweetashoney。\'Mortal，obeytheheavenlyevangel。TakeupDivineScience。Readitfrombeginningtoend。Studyit，ponderit。Itwillbeindeedsweetatitsfirsttaste，whenithealsyou；butmurmurnotoverTruth，ifyoufinditsdigestionbitter。\"YounowknowthehistoryofourdearandholyScience，sir，andthatitsoriginisnotofthisearth，butonlyitsdiscovery。Iwillleavethebookwithyouandwillgo，now，butgiveyourselfnouneasiness——IwillgiveyouabsenttreatmentfromnowtillI
gotobed。\'
III
Underthepowerfulinfluenceoftheneartreatmentandtheabsenttreatmenttogether，mybonesweregraduallyretreatinginwardanddisappearingfromview。Thegoodwordtookabriskstart，now，andwentonquiteswiftly。Mybodywasdiligentlystrainingandstretching，thiswayandthat，toaccommodatetheprocessesofrestoration，andeveryminuteortwoIheardadullclickinsideandknewthatthetwoendsofafracturehadbeensuccessfullyjoined。Thismuffledclickingandgrittingandgrindingandraspingcontinuedduringthenextthreehours，andthenstopped——theconnectionshadallbeenmade。Allexceptdislocations；therewereonlysevenofthese：hips，shoulders，knees，neck；sothatwassoonover；oneafteranothertheyslippedintotheirsocketswithasoundlikepullingadistantcork，andIjumpedupasgoodasnew，astoframework，andsentforthehorse-doctor。
IwasobligedtodothisbecauseIhadastomach-acheandacoldinthehead，andIwasnotwillingtotrustthesethingsanylongerinthehandsofawomanwhomIdidnotknow，andinwhoseabilitytosuccessfullytreatmerediseaseIhadlostallconfidence。Mypositionwasjustifiedbythefactthatthecoldandtheachehadbeeninherchargefromthefirst，alongwiththefractures，buthadexperiencednotashadeofrelief；andindeedtheachewasevengrowingworseandworse，andmoreandmorebitter，now，probablyonaccountoftheprotractedabstentionfromfoodanddrink。
Thehorse-doctorcame，apleasantmanandfullofhopeandprofessionalinterestinthecase。Inthematterofsmellhewasprettyaromatic，infactquitehorsey，andItriedtoarrangewithhimforabsenttreatment，butitwasnotinhisline，sooutofdelicacyIdidnotpressit。Helookedatmyteethandexaminedmyhock，andsaidmyageandgeneralconditionwerefavourabletoenergeticmeasures；thereforehewouldgivemesomethingtoturnthestomach-acheintothebottsandthecoldintheheadintotheblindstaggers；thenheshouldbeonhisownbeatandwouldknowwhattodo。Hemadeupabucketofbran-mash，andsaidadipperfulofiteverytwohours，alternatedwithadrenchwithturpentineandaxle-greaseinit，wouldeitherknockmyailmentsoutofmeintwenty-fourhoursorsointerestmeinotherwaysastomakemeforgettheywereonthepremises。Headministeredmyfirstdosehimself，thentookhisleave，sayingIwasfreetoeatanddrinkanythingIpleasedandinanyquantityIliked。ButIwasnothungryanymore，anddidnotcareforfood。
Itookupthe\'ChristianScientist\'bookandreadhalfofit，thentookadipperfulofdrenchandreadtheotherhalf。Theresultingexperienceswerefullofinterestandadventure。AllthroughtherumblingsandgrindingsandquakingsandeffervescingsaccompanyingtheevolutionoftheacheintothebottsandthecoldintotheblindstaggersIcouldnotethegenerousstruggleformasterygoingonbetweenthemashandthedrenchandtheliterature；andoftenIcouldtellwhichwasahead，andcouldeasilydistinguishtheliteraturefromtheotherswhentheotherswereseparate，thoughnotwhentheyweremixed；forwhenabran-mashandaneclecticdrencharemixedtogethertheylookjustliketheApodicticalPrincipleoutonalark，andnoonecantellitfromthat。Thefinishwasreachedatlast，theevolutionswerecompleteandafinesuccess；butIthinkthatthisresultcouldhavebeenachievedwithfewermaterials。
Ibelievethemashwasnecessarytotheconversionofthestomach-acheintotheboots，butIthinkonecoulddeveloptheblindstaggersoutoftheliteraturebyitself；also，thatblindstaggersproducedinthiswaywouldbeofabetterqualityandmorelastingthananyproducedbytheartificialprocessesofahorse-doctor。
Forofallthestrange，andfrantic，andincomprehensible，anduninterpretablebookswhichtheimaginationofmanhascreated，surelythisoneistheprizesample。Itiswrittenwithalimitlessconfidenceandcomplacency，andwithadashandstirandearnestnesswhichoftencompeltheeffectsofeloquence，evenwhenthewordsdonotseemtohaveanytraceablemeaning。Thereareplentyofpeoplewhoimaginetheyunderstandthebook；Iknowthis，forIhavetalkedwiththem；butinallcasestheywerepeoplewhoalsoimaginedthattherewerenosuchthingsaspain，sickness，anddeath，andnorealitiesintheworld；nothingactuallyexistentbutMind。Itseemstometomodifythevalueoftheirtestimony。WhenthesepeopletalkaboutChristianSciencetheydoasMrs。Fullerdid；theydonotusetheirownlanguage，butthebook\'s；theypouroutthebook\'sshowyincoherences，andleaveyoutofindoutlaterthattheywerenotoriginating，butmerelyquoting；theyseemtoknowthevolumebyheart，andtorevereitastheywouldaBible——anotherBible，perhapsIoughttosay。PlainlythebookwaswrittenunderthementaldesolationsoftheThirdDegree，andIfeelsurethatnonebutthemembershipofthatDegreecandiscovermeaningsinit。Whenyoureadityouseemtobelisteningtoalivelyandaggressiveandoracularspeechdeliveredinanunknowntongue，aspeechwhosespirityougetbutnottheparticulars；or，tochangethefigure，youseemtobelisteningtoavigorousinstrumentwhichismakinganoiseitthinksisatune，butwhichtopersonsnotmembersofthebandisonlythemartialtootingofatrombone，andmerelystirsthesoulthroughthenoisebutdoesnotconveyameaning。
Thebook\'sserenitiesofself-satisfactiondoalmostseemtosmackofaheavenlyorigin——theyhavenoblood-kinintheearth。Itismorethanhumantobesoplacidlycertainaboutthings，andsofinelysuperior，andsoairilycontentwithone\'sperformance。WithouteverpresentinganythingwhichmayrightfullybecalledbythestrongnameofEvidence，andsometimeswithoutevenmentioningareasonforadeductionatall，itthundersoutthestartlingwords，\'IhaveProved\'soandso！IttakesthePopeandallthegreatgunsofhischurchinbatteryassembledtoauthoritativelysettleandestablishthemeaningofasoleandsingleunclarifiedpassageofScripture，andthisatvastcostoftimeandstudyandreflection，buttheauthorofthisworkissuperiortoallthat：shefindsthewholeBibleinanunclarifiedcondition，andatsmallexpenseoftimeandnoexpenseofmentaleffortsheclarifiesitfromlidtolid，reorganisesandimprovesthemeanings，thenauthoritativelysettlesandestablishesthemwithformulaewhichyoucannottellfrom\'Lettherebelight！\'and\'Hereyouhaveit！\'Itisthefirsttimesincethedawn-daysofCreationthataVoicehasgonecrashingthroughspacewithsuchplacidandcomplacentconfidenceandcommand。
IV
Aworduponaquestionofauthorship。Notthatquite；but，rather，aquestionofemendationandrevision。WeknowthattheBible-AnnexwasnotwrittenbyMrs。Eddy，butwashandeddowntohereighteenhundredyearsagobytheAngeloftheApocalypse；butdidshetranslateitalone，ordidshehavehelp？Thereseemstobeevidencethatshehadhelp。Fortherearefourseveralcopyrightsonit——1875，1885，1890，1894。ItdidnotcomedowninEnglish，forinthatlanguageitcouldnothaveacquiredcopyright——therewerenocopyrightlawseighteencenturiesago，andinmyopinionnoEnglishlanguage——atleastupthere。ThismakesitsubstantiallycertainthattheAnnexisatranslation。Then，wasnotthefirsttranslationcomplete？Ifitwas，onwhatgroundswerethelatercopyrightsgranted？
Isurmisethatthefirsttranslationwaspoor；andthatafriendorfriendsofMrs。EddymendeditsEnglishthreetimes，andfinallygotitintoitspresentshape，wherethegrammarisplentygoodenough，andthesentencesaresmoothandplausiblethoughtheydonotmeananything。I
thinkIamrightinthissurmise，forMrs。EddycannotwriteEnglishto-day，andthisisargumentthatshenevercould。Iamnotabletoguesswhodidthemending，butIthinkitwasnotdonebyanymemberoftheEddyTrust，norbytheeditorsofthe\'ChristianScienceJournal，\'
fortheirEnglishisnotmuchbetterthanMrs。Eddy\'s。
However，astothemainpoint：itiscertainthatMrs。EddydidnotdoctortheAnnex\'sEnglishherself。Heroriginal，spontaneous，undoctoredEnglishfurnishesampleproofofthis。Herearesamplesfromrecentarticlesfromherunappeasablepen；doublecolumnedwiththemareacoupleofpassagesfromtheAnnex。Itwillbeseenthattheythrowlight。Theitalicsaremine：
1。\'Whatplaguespot，\'Thereforetheefficientorbacilliweresicgnawingremedyistodestroythesicattheheartofthispatient\'sunfortunatebelief，metropolis……andbringingbybothsilentlyandaudiblyitonbendedknee？arguingtheoppositefactsinWhy，itwasaninstitutethatregardtoharmoniousbeinghadentereditsvitalssicrepresentingmanasthat，amongotherthings，healthfulinsteadofdiseased，taughtgames，\'etcetera。P。andshowingthatitis670，\'C。S。Journal，\'articleimpossibleformattertosuffer，entitled\'ANarrative-bytofeelpainorheat，tobeMaryBakerG。Eddy。\'thirstyorsick。\'P。375，Annex。
2。\'Parkssprangupsic……
electricstreetcarsrun\'Manisneversick；forsicmerrilythroughseveralMindisnotsick，andmatterstreets，concretesidewalkscannotbe。Afalsebeliefandmacadamisedroadsdottedisboththetempterandthesictheplace，\'etcetera。tempted，thesinandtheIbid。sinner，thediseaseandits3。\'Shornsicofitscause。Itiswelltobecalmsuburbsithadindeedlittleinsickness；tobehopefulislefttoadmire，savetosicstillbetter；buttosuchasfancyaskeletonunderstandthatsicknessisnotabovegroundbreathingsicreal，andthatTruthcanslowlythroughabarrensicdestroyit，isbestofall，forbreast。\'Ibid。itistheuniversalandperfectremedy。\'Chapterxii。，Annex。
Younoticethecontrastbetweenthesmooth，plausible，elegant，addledEnglishofthedoctoredAnnexandthelumbering，ragged，ignorantoutputofthetranslator\'snatural，spontaneous，andunmedicatedpenwork。TheEnglishoftheAnnexhasbeenslickedupbyaveryindustriousandpainstakinghand——butitwasnotMrs。Eddy\'s。
IfMrs。EddyreallywroteortranslatedtheAnnex，heroriginaldraftwasexactlyinharmonywiththeEnglishofherplague-spotorbacilliwhichweregnawingattheinsidesofthemetropolisandbringingitsheartonbendedknee，thusexposingtotheeyetherestoftheskeletonbreathingslowlythroughabarrenbreast。Anditborelittleornoresemblancetothebookaswehaveitnow——nowthatthesalariedpolisherhasholystonedallofthegenuineEddytiesoutofit。
Willtheplague-spotarticlegointoavolumejustasitstands？Ithinknot。Ithinkthepolisherwilltakeoffhiscoatandvestandcravatand\'demonstrateover\'itacoupleofweeksandsweatitintoashapesomethinglikethefollowing——andthenMrs。Eddywillpublishitandleavepeopletobelievethatshedidthepolishingherself：
1。Whatinjuriousinfluencewasitthatwasaffectingthecity\'smorals？
Itwasasocialclubwhichpropagatedaninterestinidleamusements，disseminatedaknowledgeofgames，etcetera。
2。Bythemagicofthenewandnoblerinfluencesthesterilespacesweretransformedintowoodedparks，themerryelectriccarreplacedthemelancholy\'bus，smoothconcretethetempestuousplanksidewalk，themacadamisedroadtheprimitivecorduroy，etcetera。
3。Itspleasantsuburbsgone，therewaslittlelefttoadmiresavethewreckedgraveyardwithitsuncannyexposures。
TheAnnexcontainsonesoleandsolitaryhumorousremark。ThereisamostelaborateandvoluminousIndex，anditisprecededbythisnote：
\'ThisIndexwillenablethestudenttofindanythoughtorideacontainedinthebook。\'
V
Noonedoubts——certainlynotI——thatthemindexercisesapowerfulinfluenceoverthebody。Fromthebeginningoftime，thesorcerer，theinterpreterofdreams，thefortune-teller，thecharlatan，thequack，thewildmedicine-man，theeducatedphysician，themesmerist，andthehypnotisthavemadeuseoftheclient\'simaginationtohelpthemintheirwork。Theyhaveallrecognisedthepotencyandavailabilityofthatforce。Physicianscuremanypatientswithabreadpill；theyknowthatwherethediseaseisonlyafancy，thepatient\'sconfidenceinthedoctorwillmakethebreadpilleffective。
Faithinthedoctor。Perhapsthatistheentirething。Itseemstolooklikeit。InoldtimestheKingcuredtheking\'sevilbythetouchoftheroyalhand。Hefrequentlymadeextraordinarycures。Couldhisfootmanhavedoneit？No——notinhisownclothes。DisguisedastheKing，couldhehavedoneit？Ithinkwemaynotdoubtit。IthinkwemayfeelsurethatitwasnottheKing\'stouchthatmadethecureinanyinstance，butthepatient\'sfaithintheefficacyofaKing\'stouch。Genuineandremarkablecureshavebeenachievedthroughcontactwiththerelicsofasaint。Isitnotlikelythatanyotherboneswouldhavedoneaswellifthesubstitutionhadbeenconcealedfromthepatient？WhenIwasaboy，afarmer\'swifewholivedfivemilesfromourvillage，hadgreatfameasafaith-doctor——thatwaswhatshecalledherself。Suffererscametoherfromallaround，andshelaidherhanduponthemandsaid，\'Havefaith——
itisallthatisnecessary，\'andtheywentawaywelloftheirailments。
Shewasnotareligiouswoman，andpretendedtonooccultpowers。Shesaidthatthepatient\'sfaithinherdidthework。SeveraltimesIsawhermakeimmediatecuresofseveretoothaches。Mymotherwasthepatient。InAustriathereisapeasantwhodrivesagreattradeinthissortofindustryandhasboththehighandthelowforpatients。Hegetsintoprisoneverynowandthenforpractisingwithoutadiploma，buthisbusinessisasbriskaseverwhenhegetsout，forhisworkisunquestionablysuccessfulandkeepshisreputationhigh。InBavariathereisamanwhoperformedsomanygreatcuresthathehadtoretirefromhisprofessionofstage-carpenteringinordertomeetthedemandofhisconstantlyincreasingbodyofcustomers。Hegoesonfromyeartoyeardoinghismiracles，andhasbecomeveryrich。Hepretendstonoreligioushelps，nosupernaturalaids，butthinksthereissomethinginhismake-upwhichinspirestheconfidenceofhispatients，andthatitisthisconfidencewhichdoestheworkandnotsomemysteriouspowerissuingfromhimself。
Withinthelastquarterofacentury，inAmerica，severalsectsofcurershaveappearedundervariousnamesandhavedonenotablethingsinthewayofhealingailmentswithouttheuseofmedicines。TherearetheMindCure，theFaithCure，thePrayerCure，theMental-ScienceCure，andtheChristian-ScienceCure；andapparentlytheyalldotheirmiracleswiththesameoldpowerfulinstrument——thepatient\'simagination。Differingnames，butnodifferenceintheprocess。Buttheydonotgivethatinstrumentthecredit；eachsectclaimsthatitswaydiffersfromthewaysoftheothers。
Theyallachievesomecures，thereisnoquestionaboutit；andtheFaithCureandthePrayerCureprobablydonoharmwhentheydonogood，sincetheydonotforbidthepatienttohelpoutthecurewithmedicinesifhewantsto；buttheothersbarmedicines，andclaimabilitytocureeveryconceivablehumanailmentthroughtheapplicationoftheirmentalforcesalone。Theyclaimabilitytocuremalignantcancer，andotheraffectionswhichhaveneverbeencuredinthehistoryoftherace。Therewouldseemtobeanelementofdangerhere。Ithasthelookofclaimingtoomuch，I
think。Publicconfidencewouldprobablybeincreasediflesswereclaimed。
Ibelieveitmightbeshownthatallthe\'mind\'sectsexceptChristianSciencehavelucidintervals；intervalsinwhichtheybetraysomediffidence，andineffectconfessthattheyarenottheequalsoftheDeity；butiftheChristianScientistevenstopswithbeingmerelytheequaloftheDeity，itisnotclearlyprovablebyhisChristian-ScienceAmendedBible。IntheusualBibletheDeityrecognisespain，disease，anddeathasfacts，buttheChristianScientistknowsbetter。Knowsbetter，andisnotdiffidentaboutsayingso。
TheChristianScientistwasnotabletocuremystomach-acheandmycold；
butthehorse-doctordidit。ThisconvincesmethatChristianScienceclaimstoomuch。Inmyopinionitoughttoletdiseasesaloneandconfineitselftosurgery。Thereitwouldhaveeverythingitsownway。
Thehorse-doctorchargedmethirtykreutzers，andIpaidhim；infactI
doubleditandgavehimashilling。Mrs。Fullerbroughtinanitemisedbillforacrateofbrokenbonesmendedintwohundredandthirty-fourplaces——onedollarperfracture。
\'NothingexistsbutMind？\'
\'Nothing，\'sheanswered。\'Allelseissubstanceless，allelseisimaginary。\'
Igaveheranimaginarycheque，andnowsheissuingmeforsubstantialdollars。Itlooksinconsistent。
VI
Letusconsiderthatweareallpartiallyinsane。Itwillexplainustoeachother，itwillunriddlemanyriddles，itwillmakeclearandsimplemanythingswhichareinvolvedinhauntingandharassingdifficultiesandobscuritiesnow。
Thoseofuswhoarenotintheasylum，andnotdemonstrablyduethere，areneverthelessnodoubtinsaneinoneortwoparticulars——Ithinkwemustadmitthis；butIthinkthatweareotherwisehealthy-minded。I
thinkthatwhenweallseeonethingalike，itisevidencethatasregardsthatonething，ourmindsareperfectlysound。Nowtherearereallyseveralthingswhichwedoallseealike；thingswhichweallaccept，andaboutwhichwedonotdispute。Forinstance，wewhoareoutsideoftheasylumallagreethatwaterseeksitslevel；thatthesungiveslightandheat；thatfireconsumes；thatfogisdamp；that6times6arethirty-six；that2from10leaveeight；that8and7arefifteen。
Theseareperhapstheonlythingsweareagreedabout；butalthoughtheyaresofew，theyareofinestimablevalue，becausetheymakeaninfalliblestandardofsanity。Whosoeveracceptsthemweknowtobesubstantiallysane；sufficientlysane；intheworkingessentials，sane。
Whoeverdisputesasingleoneofthemweknowtobewhollyinsane，andqualifiedfortheasylum。
Verywell，themanwhodisputesnoneofthemweconcedetobeentitledtogoatlarge——butthatisconcessionenough；wecannotgoanyfurtherthanthat；forweknowthatinallmattersofmereopinionthatsamemanisinsane——justasinsaneasweare；justasinsaneasShakespearewas，justasinsaneasthePopeis。Weknowexactlywheretoputourfingeruponhisinsanity；itiswherehisopiniondiffersfromours。
Thatisasimplerule，andeasytoremember。WhenI，athoughtfulandunbiasedPresbyterian，examinetheKoran，IknowthatbeyondanyquestioneveryMohammedanisinsane；notinallthings，butinreligiousmatters。
WhenathoughtfulandunbiasedMohammedanexaminestheWestminsterCatechism，heknowsthatbeyondanyquestionIamspirituallyinsane。I
cannotprovetohimthatheisinsane，becauseyounevercanproveanythingtoalunatic——forthatisapartofhisinsanityandtheevidenceofit。HecannotprovetomethatIaminsane，formymindhasthesamedefectthatafflictshis。Alldemocratsareinsane，butnotoneofthemknowsit；nonebuttherepublicansandmugwumpsknowit。Alltherepublicansareinsane，butonlythedemocratsandmugwumpscanperceiveit。Theruleisperfect；inallmattersofopinionouradversariesareinsane。WhenIlookaroundmeIamoftentroubledtoseehowmanypeoplearemad。Tomentiononlyafew：
TheAtheist，TheShakers，TheInfidel，TheMillerites，TheAgnostic，TheMormons，TheBaptist，TheLaurenceOliphantTheMethodist，Harrisites，TheCatholic，andtheotherTheGrandLama\'speople，115Christiansects，theTheMonarchists，Presbyterianexcepted，TheImperialists，The72Mohammedansects，TheDemocrats，TheBuddhist，TheRepublicansbutnotTheBlavatsky-Buddhist，theMugwumps，TheNationalist，TheMind-Curists，TheConfucian，TheFaith-Curists，TheSpiritualist，TheMentalScientists，The2，000EastIndianTheAllopaths，sects，TheHomeopaths，ThePeculiarPeople，TheElectropaths，TheSwedenborgians，The——butthere\'snoendtothelist；therearemillionsofthem！Andallinsane；eachinhisownway；insaneastohispetfadoropinion，butotherwisesaneandrational。
Thisshouldmoveustobecharitabletowardoneanother\'slunacies。I
recognisethatinhisspecialbelieftheChristianScientistisinsane，becausehedoesnotbelieveasIdo；butIhailhimasmymateandfellowbecauseIamasinsaneashe——insanefromhispointofview，andhispointofviewisasauthoritativeasmineandworthasmuch。Thatistosay，worthabrassfarthing。Uponagreatreligiousorpoliticalquestiontheopinionofthedullestheadintheworldisworththesameastheopinionofthebrightestheadintheworld——abrassfarthing。Howdowearriveatthis？Itissimple：Theaffirmativeopinionofastupidmanisneutralisedbythenegativeopinionofhisstupidneighbour——nodecisionisreached；theaffirmativeopinionoftheintellectualgiantGladstoneisneutralisedbythenegativeopinionoftheintellectualgiantCardinalNewman——nodecisionisreached。Opinionsthatprovenothingare，ofcourse，withoutvalue——anybutadeadpersonknowsthatmuch。Thisobligesustoadmitthetruthoftheunpalatablepropositionjustmentionedabove——thatindisputedmatterspoliticalandreligiousoneman\'sopinionisworthnomorethanhispeer\'s，andhenceitfollowsthatnoman\'sopinionpossessesanyrealvalue。Itisahumblingthought，butthereisnowaytogetaroundit：allopinionsuponthesegreatsubjectsarebrass-farthingopinions。
Itisamereplainsimplefact——asclearandascertainasthat8and7
makefifteen。Andbyitwerecognisethatweareallinsane，asconcernsthosematters。Ifweweresaneweshouldallseeapoliticalorreligiousdoctrinealike，therewouldbenodispute：itwouldbeacaseof8and7——justasitisinheaven，whereallaresaneandnoneinsane。
Therethereisbutonereligion，onebelief，theharmonyisperfect，thereisneveradiscordantnote。
UnderprotectionofthesepreliminariesIsupposeImaynowrepeatwithoutoffencethattheChristianScientistisinsane。Imeanhimnodiscourtesy，andIamnotcharging——norevenimagining——thatheisinsanerthantherestofthehumanrace。Ithinkheismorepicturesquelyinsanethatsomeofus。Atthesametime，Iamquitesurethatinoneimportantandsplendidparticularheissanerthanisthevastbulkoftherace。
Whyisheinsane？Itoldyoubefore：itisbecausehisopinionsarenotours。Iknowofnootherreason，andIdonotneedanyother；itistheonlywaywehaveofdiscoveringinsanitywhenitisnotviolent。Itismerelythepicturesquenessofhisinsanitythatmakesitmoreinterestingthanmykindoryours。Forinstance，considerhis\'littlebook\'——theonedescribedinthepreviousarticle；the\'littlebook\'exposedintheskyeighteencenturiesagobytheflamingangeloftheApocalypseandhandeddowninourdaytoMrs。MaryBakerG。EddyofNewHampshireandtranslatedbyher，wordforword，intoEnglishwithhelpofapolisher，andnowpublishedanddistributedinhundredsofeditionsbyherataclearprofitpervolume，abovecost，of700percent。！——aprofitwhichdistinctlybelongstotheangeloftheApocalypse，andlethimcollectitifhecan；a\'littlebook\'whichtheC。S。veryfrequentlycallsbyjustthatname，andalwaysinclosedinquotation-markstokeepitshighoriginexultantlyinmind；a\'littlebook\'which\'explains\'andreconstructsandnew-paintsanddecoratestheBibleandputsamansardroofonitandalightning-rodandalltheothermodernimprovements；alittlebookwhichforthepresentaffectstotravelinyokewiththeBibleandbefriendlytoit，andwithinhalfacenturywillhitchitintherear，andthenceforthtraveltandem，itselfinthelead，inthecominggreatmarchofChristianScientismthroughtheProtestantdominionsoftheplanet。
PerhapsIamputtingthetandemarrangementtoofaraway；perhapsfiveyearsmightbenearerthemarkthanfifty；foraVienneseladytoldmelastnightthatintheChristianScienceMosqueinBostonshenoticedsomethingswhichseemtometopromiseashorteningoftheinterval；ononesidetherewasadisplayoftextsfromtheNewTestament，signedwiththeSaviour\'sinitials，\'J。C。；\'andontheoppositesideadisplayoftextsfromthe\'littlebook\'signed——withtheauthor\'smereinitials？
No——signedwithMrs。MaryBakerG。Eddy\'snameinfull。PerhapstheAngeloftheApocalypselikesthiskindofpiracy。ImadethisremarklightlytoaChristianScientistthismorning，buthedidnotreceiveitlightly，butsaiditwasjestinguponholythings；hesaidtherewasnopiracy，fortheangeldidnotcomposethebook，heonlybroughtit——\'Godcomposedit。\'Icouldhaveretortedthatitwasacaseofpiracyjustthesame；thatthedisplayedtextsshouldbesignedwiththeAuthor\'sinitials，andthattosignthemwiththetranslator\'strainofnameswasanothercaseof\'jestinguponholythings。\'However，Ididnotsaythesethings，forthisScientistwasalargeperson，andalthoughbyhisowndoctrinewehavenosubstance，butarefictionsandunrealities，Iknewhecouldhitmeanimaginaryblowwhichwouldfurnishmeanimaginarypainwhichcouldlastmeaweek。TheladysaidthatinthatMosquethereweretwopulpits；inoneofthemwasamanwiththeFormerBible，intheotherawomanwithMrs。Eddy\'sapocalypticAnnex；andfromthesebooksthemanandthewomanwerereadingverseandverseabout：
\'HungryonesthrongtoheartheBiblereadinconnectionwiththetext-bookofChristianScience，\"ScienceandHealth，withKeytotheScriptures，\"byMaryBakerG。Eddy。Theseareouronlypreachers。
TheyarethewordofGod。\'——ChristianScienceJournal，October1898。
Arethesethingspicturesque？TheVienneseladytoldmethatinachapeloftheMosquetherewasapictureorimageofMrs。Eddy，andthatbeforeitburnsanever-extinguishedlight。Isthatpicturesque？HowlongdoyouthinkitwillbebeforetheChristianScientistwillbeworshippingthatimageandprayingtoit？HowlongdoyouthinkitwillbebeforeitisclaimedthatMrs。EddyisaRedeemer，aChrist，orChrist\'sequal？
Alreadyherarmyofdisciplesspeakofherreverentlyas\'OurMother。\'
HowlongwillitbebeforetheyplaceheronthestepsoftheThronebesidetheVirgin——andlaterastephigher？First，MarytheVirginandMarytheMatron；later，withachangeofPrecedence，MarytheMatronandMarytheVirgin。Lettheartistgetreadywithhiscanvasandhisbrushes；thenewRenaissanceisonitsway，andtherewillbemoneyinaltar-canvases——athousandtimesasmuchasthePopesandtheirChurcheverspentontheOldMasters；fortheirricheswereaspovertyascomparedwithwhatisgoingtopourintothetreasure-chestoftheChristian-ScientistPapacyby-and-by，letusnotdoubtit。Wewillexaminethefinancialoutlookpresentlyandseewhatitpromises。A
favouritesubjectofthenewOldMasterwillbethefirstverseofthetwelfthchapterofRevelation——aversewhichMrs。EddysaysinherAnnextotheScriptureshas\'onedistinctivefeaturewhichhasspecialreferencetothepresentage\'——andtoher，asisratherpointedlyindicated：
\'Andthereappearedagreatwonderinheaven——awomanclothedwiththesunandthemoonunderherfeet，\'etc。
ThewomanclothedwiththesunwillbeaportraitofMrs。Eddy。
IsitinsanitytobelievethatChristianScientismisdestinedtomakethemostformidableshowthatanynewreligionhasmadeintheworldsincethebirthandspreadofMohammedanism，andthatwithinacenturyfromnowitmaystandsecondtoRomeonly，innumbersandpowerinChristendom？
Ifthisisawilddreamitwillnotbeeasytoproveitissojustyet，I
think。Thereseemsargumentthatitmaycometrue。TheChristian-Science\'boom\'isnotyetfiveyearsold；yetalreadyithas500churchesand1，000，000membersinAmerica。
Ithasitsstart，yousee，anditisaphenomenallygoodone。Moreover，itislatterlyspreadingwithaconstantlyacceleratingswiftness。Ithasabetterchancetogrowandprosperandachievepermanencythananyotherexisting\'ism；\'forithasmoretoofferthananyother。Thepastteachesusthat，inordertosucceed，amovementlikethismustnotbeamerephilosophy，itmustbeareligion；also，thatitmustnotclaimentireoriginality，butcontentitselfwithpassingforanimprovementonanexistingreligion，andshowitshandlater，whenstrongandprosperous——likeMohammedanism。
Next，theremustbemoney——andplentyofit。
Next，thepowerandauthorityandcapitalmustbeconcentratedinthegripofasmallandirresponsibleclique，withnobodyoutsideprivilegedtoaskquestionsorfindfault。
Next，asbeforeremarked，itmustbaititshookwithsomenewandattractiveadvantagesoverthebaitsofferedbytheotherreligions。
Anewmovementequippedwithsomeoftheseendowments——likespiritualism，forinstance——maycountuponaconsiderablesuccess；anewmovementequippedwiththebulkofthem——likeMohammedanism，forinstance——maycountuponawidelyextendedconquest。Mormonismhadalltherequisitesbutone——ithadnothingnewandnothingvaluabletobaitwith；and，besides，itappealedtothestupidandtheignorantonly。Spiritualismlackedtheimportantdetailofconcentrationofmoneyandauthorityinthehandsofanirresponsibleclique。
Theaboveequipmentisexcellent，admirable，powerful，butnotperfect。
Thereisyetanotherdetailwhichisworththewholeofitputtogether——
andmore；adetailwhichhasneverbeenjoinedinthebeginningofareligiousmovementtoasupremelygoodworkingequipmentsincetheworldbegan，untilnow：anewpersonagetoworship。ChristianityhadtheSaviour，butatfirstandforgenerationsitlackedmoneyandconcentratedpower。InMrs。Eddy，ChristianSciencepossessesthenewpersonageforworship，andinaddition——hereintheverybeginning——aworkingequipmentthathasnotaflawinit。Inthebeginning，Mohammedanismhadnomoney；andithasneverhadanythingtoofferitsclientbutheaven——nothingherebelowthatwasvaluable。Inadditiontoheavenhereafter，ChristianSciencehaspresenthealthandacheerfulspirittooffer——forcash——andincomparisonwiththisbribeallotherthis-worldbribesarepoorandcheap。Yourecognisethatthisestimateisadmissible，doyounot？
TowhomdoesBellamy\'s\'Nationalism\'appeal？Necessarilytothefew：
peoplewhoreadanddream，andarecompassionate，andtroubledforthepoorandthehard-driven。TowhomdoesSpiritualismappeal？Necessarilytothefew；its\'boom\'haslastedforhalfacenturyandIbelieveitclaimsshortoffourmillionsofadherentsinAmerica。WhoareattractedbySwedenborgianismandsomeoftheotherfineanddelicate\'isms？\'Thefewagain：Educatedpeople，sensitivelyorganised，withsuperiormentalendowments，whoseekloftyplanesofthoughtandfindtheircontentmentthere。AndwhoareattractedbyChristianScience？Thereisnolimit；
itsfieldishorizonless；itsappealisasuniversalasistheappealofChristianityitself。Itappealstotherich，thepoor，thehigh，thelow，thecultured，theignorant，thegifted，thestupid，themodest，thevain，thewise，thesilly，thesoldier，thecivilian，thehero，thecoward，theidler，theworker，thegodly，thegodless，thefreeman，theslave，theadult，thechild；theywhoareailing，theywhohavefriendsthatareailing。Tomassitinaphrase，itsclienteleistheHumanRace？Willitmarch？Ithinkso。
VII
Rememberitsprincipalgreatoffer：toridtheRaceofpainanddisease。
Canitdoit？Inlargemeasure，yes。Howmuchofthepainanddiseaseintheworldiscreatedbytheimaginationsofthesufferers，andthenkeptalivebythosesameimaginations？Four-fifths？NotanythingshortofthatIshouldthink。CanChristianSciencebanishthatfour-fifths？
Ithinkso。Cananyotherorganisedforcedoit？NonethatIknowof。
Wouldthisbeanewworldwhenthatwasaccomplished？Andapleasanterone——foruswellpeople，aswellasforthosefussyandfrettingsickones？Woulditseemasiftherewasnotasmuchgloomyweatherasthereusedtobe？Ithinkso。
InthemeantimewouldtheScientistkilloffagoodmanypatients？I
thinkso。Morethangetkilledoffnowbythelegalisedmethods？Iwilltakeupthatquestionpresently。
AtpresentIwishtoaskyoutoexaminesomeoftheScientist\'sperformances，asregisteredinhismagazine，\'TheChristianScienceJournal\'——Octobernumber，1898。First，aBaptistclergymangivesusthistruepictureof\'theaverageorthodoxChristian\'——andhecouldhaveaddedthatitisatruepictureoftheaveragecivilisedhumanbeing：
\'Heisaworriedandfrettedandfearfulman；afraidofhimselfandhispropensities，afraidofcoldsandfevers，afraidoftreadingonserpentsordrinkingdeadlythings。\'
Thenhegivesusthiscontrast：
\'TheaverageChristianScientisthasputallanxietyandfrettingunderhisfeet。HedoeshaveavictoryoverfearandcarethatisnotachievedbytheaverageorthodoxChristian。\'
Hehasputallanxietyandfrettingunderhisfeet。Whatproportionofyourearningsorincomewouldyoubewillingtopayforthatframeofmind，yearinyearout？Itreallyoutvaluesanypricethatcanbeputuponit。Wherecanyoupurchaseit，atanyoutlayofanysort，inanyChurchoroutofit，excepttheScientist\'s？
Well，itistheanxietyandfrettingaboutcolds，andfevers，anddraughts，andgettingourfeetwet，andaboutforbiddenfoodeateninterrorofindigestion，thatbringsonthecoldandthefeverandtheindigestionandthemostofourotherailments；andso，iftheSciencecanbanishthatanxietyfromtheworldIthinkitcanreducetheworld\'sdiseaseandpainaboutfour-fifths。
InthisOctobernumbermanyoftheredeemedtestifyandgivethanks；andnotcoldlybutwithpassionategratitude。Asaruletheyseemdrunkwithhealth，andwiththesurpriseofit，thewonderofit，theunspeakablegloryandsplendourofit，afteralongsoberspellspentininventingimaginarydiseasesandconcretingthemwithdoctor-stuff。Thefirstwitnesstestifiesthatwhen\'thismostbeautifulTruthfirstdawnedonhim\'hehad\'nearlyalltheillsthatfleshisheirto；\'thatthosehedidnothavehethoughthehad——andthusmadethetaleaboutcomplete。
Whatwasthenaturalresult？Why，hewasadump-pit\'forallthedoctors，druggists，andpatentmedicinesofthecountry。\'ChristianSciencecametohishelp，and\'theoldsickconditionspassedaway，\'andalongwiththemthe\'dismalforebodings\'whichhehadbeenaccustomedtoemployinconjuringupailments。Andsohewasahealthyandcheerfulman，now，andastonished。
ButIamnotastonished，forfromothersourcesIknowwhatmusthavebeenhismethodofapplyingChristianScience。IfIamintheright，hewatchfullyanddiligentlydivertedhismindfromunhealthychannelsandcompelledittotravelinhealthyones。Nothingcontrivablebyhumaninventioncouldbemoreformidablyeffectivethanthat，inbanishingimaginaryailmentsandinclosingtheentrancesagainstsubsequentapplicantsoftheirbreed。Ithinkhismethodwastokeepsaying，\'Iamwell！Iamsound！——soundandwell！wellandsound！Perfectlysound，perfectlywell！Ihavenopain；there\'snosuchthingaspain！Ihavenodisease；there\'snosuchthingasdisease！NothingisrealbutMind；allisMind，All-Good，Good-Good，Life，Soul，Liver，Bones，oneofaseries，anteandpassthebuck！\'
Idonotmeanthatthatwasexactlytheformulaused，butthatitdoubtlesscontainsthespiritofit。TheScientistwouldattachvaluetotheexactformula，nodoubt，andtothereligiousspiritinwhichitwasused。Ishouldthinkthatanyformulathatwoulddivertthemindfromunwholesomechannelsandforceitintohealthyoneswouldanswereverypurposewithsomepeople，thoughnotwithall。Ithinkitmostlikelythataveryreligiousmanwouldfindtheadditionofthereligiousspiritapowerfulreinforcementinhiscase。
ThesecondwitnesstestifiesthattheSciencebanished\'anoldorganictrouble\'whichthedoctorandthesurgeonhadbeennursingwithdrugsandtheknifeforsevenyears。
Hecallsithis\'claim。\'Asurface-minerwouldthinkitwasnothisclaimatall，butthepropertyofthedoctorandhispalthesurgeon——forhewouldbemisledbythatword，whichisChristian-Scienceslangfor\'ailment。\'TheChristianScientisthasnoailment；tohimthereisnosuchthing，andhewillnotusethelyingword。Allthathappenstohimis，thatuponhisattentionanimaginarydisturbancesometimesobtrudesitselfwhichclaimstobeanailment，butisn\'t。
ThiswitnessofferstestimonyforaclergymanseventyyearsoldwhohadpreachedfortyyearsinaChristianchurch，andhasnotgoneovertothenewsect。Hewas\'almostblindanddeaf。\'HewastreatedbytheC。S。
method，and\'whenheheardthevoiceofTruthhesawspiritually。\'Sawspiritually。Itisalittleindefinite；theyhadbettertreathimagain。
Indefinitetestimoniesmightproperlybewaste-basketed，sincethereisevidentlynolackofdefiniteonesprocurable，butthisC。S。magazineispoorlyedited，andsomistakesofthiskindmustbeexpected。
ThenextwitnessisasoldieroftheCivilWar。WhenChristianSciencefoundhim，hehadinstockthefollowingclaims：
Indigestion，Rheumatism，Catarrh，ChalkydepositsinShoulderjoints，Armjoints，Handjoints，AtrophyofthemusclesofArms，Shoulders，Stiffnessofallthosejoints，Insomnia，Excruciatingpainsmostofthetime。
Theseclaimshaveaverysubstantialsound。Theycameofexposureinthecampaigns。Thedoctorsdidalltheycould，butitwaslittle。Prayersweretried，but\'Ineverrealisedanyphysicalrelieffromthatsource。\'
AfterthirtyyearsoftorturehewenttoaChristianScientistandtookanhour\'streatmentandwenthomepainless。Twodayslaterhe\'begantoeatlikeawellman。\'Then\'theclaimsvanished——someatonce，othersmoregradually；\'finally，\'theyhavealmostentirelydisappeared。\'And——
athingwhichisofstillgreatervalue——heisnow\'contentedandhappy。\'
Thatisadetailwhich，asearlierremarked，isaScientist-Churchspecialty。Withthirty-oneyears\'efforttheMethodistChurchhadnotsucceededinfurnishingittothisharassedsoldier。
Andsothetalegoeson。Witnessafterwitnessbulletinshisclaims，declarestheirpromptabolishment，andgivesMrs。Eddy\'sDiscoverythepraise。Milk-legiscured；nervousprostrationiscured；consumptioniscured；andSt。Vitus\'sdancemadeapastime。AndnowandthenaninterestingnewadditiontotheScienceslangappearsonthepage。Wehave\'demonstrationsover\'chilblainsandsuchthings。Itseemstobeacurtailedwayofsaying\'demonstrationsofthepowerofChristian-ScienceTruthoverthefictionwhichmasqueradesunderthenameofChilblains。\'
Thechildrenaswellastheadults，shareintheblessingsoftheScience。\'Throughthestudyofthe\"littlebook\"theyarelearninghowtobehealthful，peaceful，andwise。\'Sometimestheyarecuredoftheirlittleclaimsbytheprofessionalhealer，andsometimesmoreadvancedchildrensayovertheformulaandcurethemselves。
AlittleFar-Westerngirlofnine，equippedwithanadultvocabulary，statesherageandsays，\'IthoughtIwouldwriteademonstrationtoyou。\'Shehadaclaimderivedfromgettingflungoverapony\'sheadandlandedonarock-pile。Shesavedherselffromdisasterbyremembertosay\'GodisAll\'whileshewasintheair。Icouldn\'thavedoneit。I
shouldn\'thaveeventhoughtofit。Ishouldhavebeentooexcited。
NothingbutChristianSciencecouldhaveenabledthatchildtodothatcalmandthoughtfulandjudiciousthinginthosecircumstances。Shecamedownonherhead，andbyalltherulessheshouldhavebrokenit；buttheinterventionoftheformulapreventedthat，sotheonlyclaimresultingwasablackenedeye。Mondaymorningitwasstillswollenandshut。Atschool\'ithurtprettybad——thatis，itseemedto。\'So\'Iwasexcused，andwentdowninthebasementandsaid，\"NowIamdependingonmammainsteadofGod，andIwilldependonGodinsteadofmamma。\"\'Nodoubtthiswouldhaveanswered；but，tomakesure，sheaddedMrs。Eddytotheteamandrecited\'theScientificStatementofBeing，\'whichisoneoftheprincipalincantations，Ijudge。Then\'Ifeltmyeyeopening。\'Why，itwouldhaveopenedanoyster。Ithinkitisoneofthetouchingestthingsinchild-history，thatpiouslittleratdowncellarpumpingawayattheScientificStatementofBeing。
Thereisapageaboutanothergoodchild——littleGordon。LittleGordon\'cameintotheworldwithouttheassistanceofsurgeryoranaesthetics。\'
Hewasa\'demonstration。\'Apainlessone；thereforehiscomingevoked\'joyandthankfulnesstoGodandtheDiscovererofChristianScience。\'
Itisanoticeablefeatureofthisliterature——thesofrequentlinkingtogetheroftheTwoBeingsinanequalbond；alsoofTheirTwoBibles。
WhenlittleGordonwastwoyearsold，\'hewasplayinghorseonthebed，whereIhadleftmy\"littlebook。\"Inoticedhimstopinhisplay，takethebookcarefullyinhislittlehands，kissitsoftly，thenlookaboutforthehighestplaceofsafetyhisarmscouldreach，andputitthere。\'
Thispiousactfilledthemother\'withsuchatrainofthoughtasIhadneverexperiencedbefore。Ithoughtofthesweetmotheroflongagowhokeptthingsinherheart，\'etc。Itisaboldcomparison；however，unconsciousprofanationsareaboutascommoninthemouthsofthelaymembershipofthenewChurchasarefrankandopenonesinthemouthsofitsconsecratedchiefs。
Somedayslater，thefamilylibrary——ChristianSciencebooks——waslyinginadeep-seatedwindow。Itwasanotherchancefortheholychildtoshowoff。HelefthisplayandwentthereandpushedallthebookstoonesideexcepttheAnnex。\'Ithetookinbothhands，slowlyraisedittohislips，thenremoveditcarefully，andseatedhimselfinthewindow。\'Ithadseemedtothemothertoowonderfultobetrue，thatfirsttime；butnowshewasconvincedthat\'neitherimaginationnoraccidenthadanythingtodowithit。\'Later，littleGordonlettheauthorofhisbeingseehimdoit。Afterthathediditfrequently；
probablyeverytimeanybodywaslooking。Iwouldratherhavethatchildthanachromo。Ifthistalehasanyobject，itistointimatethattheinspiredbookwassupernaturallyabletoconveyasenseofitssacredandawfulcharactertothisinnocentlittlecreaturewithouttheinterventionofoutsideaids。Themagazineisnoteditedwithhigh-priceddiscretion。
Theeditorhasaclaim，andheoughttogetittreated。
Amongotherwitnesses，thereisonewhohada\'jumpingtoothache，\'whichseveraltimestemptedherto\'believethattherewassensationinmatter，buteachtimeitwasovercomebythepowerofTruth。\'Shewouldnotallowthedentisttousecocaine，butsatthereandlethimpunchanddrillandsplitandcrushthetool，andtearandslashitsulcerations，andpulloutthenerve，anddigoutfragmentsofbone；andshewouldn\'tonceconfessthatithurt。Andtothisdayshethinksitdidn\'t，andI
havenotadoubtthatsheisnine-tenthsright，andthatherChristianSciencefaithdidherbetterservicethanshecouldhavegottenoutofcocaine。
Thereisanaccountofaboywhogotbrokenallupintosmallbitsbyanaccident，butsaidovertheScientificStatementofBeing，orsomeoftheotherincantations，andgotwellandsoundwithouthavingsufferedanyrealpainandwithouttheintrusionofasurgeon。Icanbelievethis，becausemyowncasewassomewhatsimilar，aspermyformerarticle。
Alsothereisanaccountoftherestorationtoperfecthealth，inasinglenight，ofafatallyinjuredhorse，bytheapplicationofChristianScience。Icanstandagooddeal，butIrecognisethattheiceisgettingthinhere。Thathorsehadasmanyasfiftyclaims：howcouldhedemonstrateoverthem？CouldhedotheAll-Good，Good-Good，Good-Gracious，Liver，Bones，Truth，AlldownbutNine，SetthemupontheOtherAlley？CouldheintonetheScientificStatementofBeing？Now，couldhe？Wouldn\'titgivehimarelapse？Letusdrawthelineathorses。Horsesandfurniture。
Thereisaplentyofothertestimoniesinthemagazine，butthesequotedsampleswillanswer。TheyshowthekindoftradetheScienceisdriving。
Nowwecomebacktothequestion；Doesitkillapatienthereandthereandnowandthen？Wemustconcedeit。Doesitcompensateforthis？I
ampersuadedthatitcanmakeaplausibleshowinginthatdirection。Forinstance：whenitlaysitshandsuponasoldierwhohassufferedthirtyyearsofhelplesstortureandmakeshimwholeinbodyandmind，whatistheactualsumofthatachievement？This，Ithink：thatithasrestoredtolifeasubjectwhohadessentiallydiedtendeathsayearforthirtyyears，andeachofthemalongandpainfulone。Butforitsinterferencethatmanwouldhaveessentiallydiedthirtytimesmore，inthethreeyearswhichhavesinceelapsed。Therearethousandofyoungpeopleinthelandwhoarenowreadytoenteruponalife-longdeathsimilartothatman\'s。EverytimetheSciencecapturesoneoftheseandsecurestohimlife-longimmunityfromimagination-manufactureddisease，itmayplausiblyclaimthatinhispersonithassaved300lives。Meantimeitwillkillamaneverynowandthen；butnomatter，itwillstillbeaheadonthecreditside。
VIII
\'Weconsciouslydeclarethat\"ScienceandHealthwithKeytotheScriptures，\"wasforetoldaswellasitsauthor，MaryBakerEddy，inRevelationx。Sheisthe\"mightyangel，\"orGod\'shighestthoughttothisageverse1，givingusthespiritualinterpretationoftheBibleinthe\"littlebookopen\"verse2。ThusweprovethatChristianScienceisthesecondcomingofChrist——Truth——Spirit。\'——
LecturebyDr。GeorgeTomkins，D。D。，C。S。
Thereyouhaveitinplainspeech。Sheisthemightyangel；sheisthedivinelyandofficiallysentbearerofGod\'shighestthought。Forthepresent，shebringstheSecondAdvent。WemustexpectthatbeforeshehasbeeninhergravefiftyyearsshewillberegardedbyherfollowingashavingbeenherselftheSecondAdvent。Sheisalreadyworshipped，andwemustexpectthisfeelingtospreadterritorially，andalsotodeepeninintensity[1]。
Particularlyafterherdeath；forthen，asanyonecanforesee，Eddy-worshipwillbetaughtintheSunday-schoolsandpulpitsofthecult。Alreadywhateversheputshertrade-markon，thoughtitbeonlyamemorialspoon，isholyandiseagerlyandpassionatelyandgratefullyboughtbythedisciple，andbecomesafetishinhishouse。Isaybought，fortheBostonChristian-ScienceTrustgivesnothingaway；everythingithasforsale。Andthetermsarecash；andnotcashonlybutcashinadvance。ItsgodisMrs。Eddyfirst，thentheDollar。NotaspiritualDollar，butarealone。FromendtoendoftheChristian-Scienceliteraturenotasinglematerialthingintheworldisconcededtobereal，excepttheDollar。Butallthroughandthroughitsadvertisementsthatrealityiseagerlyandpersistentlyrecognised。ThehungeroftheTrustfortheDollar，itsadorationoftheDollar，itslustaftertheDollar，itsecstasyinthemerethoughtoftheDollar——therehasbeennothinglikeitintheworldinanyageorcountry，nothingsocoarse，nothingsolubricous，nothingsobestial，exceptaFrenchnovel\'sattitudetowardsadultery。
TheDollarishunteddowninallsortsofways；theChristian-ScienceMother-ChurchandBargain-CounterinBostonpeddlesallkindsofspiritualwarestothefaithful，alwaysatextravagantprices，andalwaysontheonecondition——cash，cashinadvance。TheAngeloftheApocalypsecouldnotgothereandgetacopyofhisownpiratedbookoncredit。
Many，manypreciousChristian-Sciencethingsaretobehadthere——forcash：BibleLessons；ChurchManual；C。S。Hymnal；HistoryofthebuildingoftheMother-Church；lotofSermons；CommunionHymn，\'SawYeMySaviour，\'byMrs。Eddy，halfadollaracopy，\'wordsusedbyspecialpermissionofMrs。Eddy。\'AlsowehaveMrs。Eddy\'sandtheAngel\'slittleBible-Annexineightstylesofbindingateightkindsofwar-
prices：amongtheseasweetthingin\'levant，divinitycircuit，leatherlinedtoedge，roundcorners，goldedge，silksewed，each，prepaid，$6，\'
andifyoutakeamillionyougetthemashillingcheaper——thatistosay，\'prepaid，$5。75。\'AlsowehaveMrs。Eddy\'s\'MiscellaneousWritings，\'atnoblebigprices，thedivinity-circuitstyleheadingtheextortions，shillingdiscountwhereyoutakeanedition。Nextcomes\'ChristandChristmas，\'bythefertileMrs。eddy——apoem——IwouldGodI
couldseeit——price$3，cashinadvance。ThenfollowfivemorebooksbyMrs。Eddyathighwaymen\'srates，asusual，someofthemin\'leatherettecovers，\'someofthemin\'pebbledcloth，\'withdivinitycircuit，compensationbalance，twinscrew，andtheothermodernimprovements：andatthesamebargaincountercanbehadthe\'ChristianScienceJournal。\'
Iwishitwereinrefinedtastetoapplyarudelyandruggedlydescriptiveepithettothatliteraryslush-bucket，soastogiveoneanaccurateideaofwhatitislike。Iammovedtodoit，butImustnot：
itisbettertoberefinedthanaccuratewhenoneistalkingaboutaproductionlikethat。
Christian-ScienceliteraryoleomargarineisamonopolyoftheMotherChurchHeadquartersFactoryinBoston；nonegenuinewithoutthetrade-markoftheTrust。Youmustapplythere，andnotelsewhere；andyoupayyourmoneybeforeyougetyoursoap-fat。
TheTrusthasstillothersourcesofincome。Mrs。Eddyispresidentandperhapsproprietor？oftheTrust\'sMetaphysicalCollegeinBoston，wherethestudentwhohaspractisedC。S。healingduringthreeyearsthebestheknewhowperfectshimselfinthegamebyatwoweeks\'course，andpaysonehundreddollarsforit！AndIhaveacaseamongmystatisticswherethestudenthadathreeweeks\'courseandpaidthreehundredforit。
TheTrustdoeslovetheDollarwhenitisn\'taspiritualone。
InordertoforcethesaleofMrs。Eddy\'sBible-Annex，nohealer，MetaphysicalCollege-bredorother，isallowedtopractisethegameunlesshepossessacopyofthatholynightmare。ThatmeansalargeandconstantlyaugmentingincomefortheTrust。NoC。S。familywouldconsideritselfloyalorpiousorpain-proofwithoutanAnnexortwointhehouse。ThatmeansanincomefortheTrust——inthenearfuture——ofmillions：notthousands——millionsayear。
Nomember，youngorold，ofaChristian-Scientistchurchcanretainthatmembershipunlesshepay\'capitationtax\'totheBostonTrusteveryyear。
ThatmeansanincomefortheTrust——inthenearfuture——ofmillionsmoreperyear。
ItisareasonablysafeguessthatinAmericain1910therewillbe10，000，000ChristianScientists，and3，000，000inGreatBritain；thatthesefigureswillbetrebledby1920；thatinAmericain1910theChristianScientistswillbeapoliticalforce，in1920politicallyformidable——toremainthat，permanently。AndIthinkitareasonableguessthattheTrustwhichisalreadyinourdayprettybrusqueinitswayswillthenbethemostinsolentandunscrupulousandtyrannicalpolitico-religiousmasterthathasdominatedapeoplesincethepalmydaysoftheInquisition。Andastrongermasterthanthestrongestofbygonetimes，becausethisonewillhaveafinancialstrengthnotdreamedofbyanypredecessor；aseffectiveaconcentrationofirresponsiblepowerasanypredecessorhad；intherailway，thetelegraph，andthesubsidisednewspaper，betterfacilitiesforwatchingandmanaginghisempirethananypredecessorhashad；andafteragenerationortwohewillprobablydivideChristendomwiththeCatholicChurch。
TheRomanChurchhasaperfectorganisation，andithasaneffectivecentralisationofpower——butnotofitscash。ItsmultitudeofBishopsarerich，buttheirrichesremaininlargemeasureintheirownhands。
Theycollectfrom200，000，000ofpeople，buttheykeepthebulkoftheresultathome。TheBostonPopeofby-and-bywilldrawhisdollar-a-headcapitation-taxfrom300，000，000ofthehumanrace，andtheAnnexandtherestofhisbook-shopwillfetchindoubleasmuchmore；andhisMetaphysicalColleges，theannualpilgrimagetoMrs。Eddy\'stomb，fromallovertheworld——admission，theChristian-ScienceDollarpayableinadvance——purchasesofconsecratedglassbeads，candles，memorialspoons，aureoledchromo-portraitsandbogusautographsofMrs。Eddy，cashofferingsathershrine——nocrutchesofcuredcripplesreceived，andnoimitationsofmiraculouslyrestoredbrokenlegsandnecksallowedtobehungupexceptwhenmadeoutoftheHolyMetalandprovedbyfire-assay；
cashformiraclesworkedatthetomb：thesemoney-sources，withathousandtobeyetinventedandambusheduponthedevotee，willbringtheannualincrementwellupaboveabillion。AndnobodybuttheTrustwillhavethehandlingofit。NoBishopsappointedunlesstheyagreetohandin90percent。ofthecatch。InthatdaytheTrustwillmonopolisethemanufactureandsaleoftheOldandNewTestamentsaswellastheAnnex，andraisetheirpricetoAnnexrates，andcompelthedevoteetobuyforevento-dayahealerhastohavetheAnnexandtheScripturesorheisnotallowedtoworkthegame，andthatwillbringseveralhundredmilliondollarsmore。InthosedaystheTrustwillhaveanincomeapproaching$5，000，000aday，andnoexpensestobetakenoutofit；notaxestopay，andnocharitiestosupport。Thatlastdetailshouldnotbelightlypassedoverbytheread；itiswellentitledtoattention。
Nocharitiestosupport。No，noreventocontributeto。OnesearchesinvaintheTrust\'sadvertisementsandtheutterancesofitspulpitforanysuggestionthatitspendsapennyonorphans，widows，dischargedprisoners，hospitals，raggedschools，nightmissions，citymissions，foreignmissions，libraries，oldpeople\'shomes，oranyotherobjectthatappealstoahumanbeing\'spursethroughhisheart。[2]
Ihavehunted，hunted，andhunted，bycorrespondenceandotherwise，andhavenotyetgotuponthetrackofafarthingthattheTrusthasspentuponanyworthyobject。NothingmakesaScientistsouncomfortableastoaskhimifheknowsofacasewhereChristianSciencehasspentmoneyonabenevolence，eitheramongitsownadherentsorelsewhere。Heisobligedtosayno。Andthenonediscoversthatthepersonquestionedhasbeenaskedthequestionmanytimesbefore，andthatitisgettingtobeasoresubjectwithhim。Whyasoresubject？Becausehehaswrittenhischiefsandaskedwithhighconfidenceforananswerthatwillconfoundthesequestioners——andthechiefsdidnotreply。Hehaswrittenagain——
andthenagain——notwithconfidence，buthumbly，now，andhasbeggedfordefensiveammunitioninthevoiceofsupplication。Areplydoesatlastcome——tothiseffect：\'WemusthavefaithinOurMother，andrestcontentintheconvictionthatwhateverShe[3]doeswiththemoneyitisinaccordancewithordersfromHeaven，forShedoesnoactofanykindwithoutfirst\"demonstratingover\"it。\'
Thatsettlesit——asfarasthediscipleisconcerned。HisMindisentirelysatisfiedwiththatanswer；hegetsdownhisAnnexanddoesanincantationortwo，andthatmesmeriseshisspiritandputsthattosleep——bringsitpeace。Peaceandcomfortandjoy，untilsomeinquirerpuncturestheoldsoreagain。
ThroughfriendsinAmericaIaskedsomequestions，andinsomecasesgotdefiniteandinforminganswers；inothercasestheanswerswerenotdefiniteandnotvaluable。FromthedefiniteanswersIgatherthanthe\'capitation-tax\'iscompulsory，andthatthesumisonedollar。Tothequestion，\'Doesanyofthemoneygotocharities？\'theanswerfromanauthoritativesourcewas：\'No，*notinthesenseusuallyconveyedbythisword*。\'Theitalicsaremine。Thatansweriscautious。Butdefinite，Ithink——utterlyandunassailablydefinite——althoughquiteChristian-scientificallyfoggyinitsphrasing。ChristianScienceisgenerallyfoggy，generallydiffuse，generallygarrulous。ThewriterwasawarethatthefirstwordinhisphraseansweredthequestionwhichIwasasking，buthecouldnothelpaddingninedarkwords。Meaninglessones，unlessexplainedbyhim。Itisquitelikely——asintimatedbyhim——thatChristianSciencehasinventedanewclassofobjectstoapplythewordcharityto，butwithoutanexplanationwecannotknowwhattheyare。Wequiteeasilyandnaturallyandconfidentlyguessthattheyareinallcasesobjectswhichwillreturnfivehundredpercent。ontheTrust\'sinvestmentinthem，butguessingisnotknowledge；itismerely，inthiscase，asortofnine-tenthscertaintydeduciblefromwhatwethinkweknowoftheTrust\'stradeprinciplesanditsslyandfurtiveandshiftyways。
Sly？Deep？Judicious？TheTrustunderstandsbusiness。TheTrustdoesnotgiveitselfaway。Itdefeatsalltheattemptsofusimpertinentstogetatitstradesecrets。Tothisday，afterallourdiligence，wehavenotbeenabletogetittoconfesswhatitdoeswiththemoney。Itdoesnotevenletitsowndisciplesfindout。Allitsaysis，thatthematterhasbeen\'demonstratedover。\'NowandthenalayScientistsays，withagratefulexultation，thatMrs。Eddyisenormouslyrich，buthestopsthere；astowhetheranyofthemoneygoestoothercharitiesornot，heisobligedtoadmitthathedoesnotknow。However，theTrustiscomposedofhumanbeings；andthisjustifiestheconjecturethatifithadacharityonitslistwhichitdidnotneedtoblushfor，weshouldsoonhearofit。
\'Withoutmoneyandwithoutprice。\'Thoseusedtobetheterms。Mrs。
Eddy\'sAnnexcancelsthem。ThemottoofChristianScienceis\'Thelabourerisworthyofhishire。\'Andnowthatithasbeen\'demonstratedover，\'wefinditsspiritualmeaningtobe，\'Doanythingandeverythingyourhandmayfindtodo；andchargecashforit，andcollectthemoneyinadvance。\'TheScientisthasonhistongue\'sendacut-and-dried，Boston-suppliedsetofratherleanargumentswhosefunctionistoshowthatitisaHeaven-commandeddutytodothis，andthatthecroupiersofthegamehavenochoicebytoobey。
TheTrustseemstobeareincarnation。Exodusxxxii。4。
IhavenoreverenceforMrs。EddyandtherestoftheTrust——ifthereisarest——butIamnotlackinginreverenceforthesinceritiesofthelaymembershipofthenewChurch。Thereiseveryevidencethatthelaymembersareentirelysincereintheirfaith，andIthinksincerityisalwaysentitledtohonourandrespect，lettheinspirationofthesinceritybewhatitmay。Zealandsinceritycancarryanewreligionfurtherthananyothermissionaryexceptfireandsword，andIbelievethatthenewreligionwillconquerthehalfofChristendominahundredyears。Iamnotintendingthisasacomplimenttothehumanrace，Iammerelystatinganopinion。AndyetIthinkthatperhapsitisacomplimenttotherace。Ikeepinmindthatsayingofanorthodoxpreacher——quotedfurtherback。HeconcededthatthisnewChristianityfreesitspossessor\'slifefromfrets，fears，vexations，bitterness，andallsortsofimagination-propagatedmaladiesandpains，andfillshisworldwithsunshineandhisheartwithgladness。IfChristianScience，withthisstupendousequipment——andfinalsalvationadded——cannotwinhalftheChristianglobe，Imustbebadlymistakeninthemake-upofthehumanrace。
IthinktheTrustwillbehandeddownliketheotherpapacy，andwillalwaysknowhowtohandleitslimitlesscash。Itwillpressthebutton；
thezeal，theenergy，thesincerity，theenthusiasmofitscountlessvassalswilldotherest。
IX
Thepowerwhichaman\'simaginationhasoverhisbodytohealitormakeitsickisaforcewhichnoneofusisbornwithout。Thefirstmanhadit，thelastonewillpossessit。Iflefttohimselfamanismostlikelytouseonlythemischievoushalfoftheforce——thehalfwhichinventsimaginaryailmentsforhimandcultivatesthem：andifheisoneoftheseverywisepeopleheisquitelikelytoscoffatthebeneficenthalfoftheforceanddenyitsexistence。Andso，tohealorhelpthatman，twoimaginationsarerequired：hisownandsomeoutsider\'s。Theoutsider，B，mustimaginethathisincantationsarethehealingpowerthatiscuringA，andAmustimaginethatthisisso。Itisnotso，atall；butnomatter，thecureiseffected，andthatisthemainthing。
Theoutsider\'sworkisunquestionablyvaluable；sovaluablethatitmayfairlybelikenedtotheessentialworkperformedbytheengineerwhenhehandlesthethrottleandturnsonthesteam：theactualpowerislodgedexclusivelyintheengine，butiftheenginewereleftaloneitwouldneverstartofitself。WhethertheengineerbenamedJim，orBob，orTom，itisallone——hisservicesarenecessary，andheisentitledtosuchwageashecangetyoutopay。WhetherhebenamedChristianScientist，orMentalScientist，orMindCurist，orLourdesMiracle-
Worker，orKing\'s-EvilExpert，itisallone，——heismerelytheEngineer，hesimplyturnsonthesameoldsteamandtheenginedoesthewholework。
Inthecaseofthecure-engineitisadistinctadvantagetoclothetheengineerinreligiousoverallsandgivehimapiousname。Itgreatlyenlargesthebusiness，anddoesnooneanyharm。
TheChristian-Scientistengineerdrivesexactlythesametradeastheotherengineers，yetheout-prospersthewholeofthemputtogether。Isitbecausehehascapturedthetakingestname？Ithinkthatthatisonlyasmallpartofit。Ithinkthatthesecretofhishighprosperitylieselsewhere：
TheChristianScientisthasorganisedthebusiness。Nowthatwascertainlyagiganticidea。ThereismoreintellectinitthanwouldbeneededintheinventionofacoupleofmillionsofEddyScience-and-
HealthBibleAnnexes。Electricity，inlimitlessvolume，hasexistedintheairandtherocksandtheearthandeverywheresincetimebegan——andwasgoingtowasteallthewhile。Inourtimewehaveorganisedthatscatteredandwanderingforceandsetittowork，andbackedthebusinesswithcapital，andconcentrateditinfewandcompetenthands，andtheresultsareaswesee。
TheChristianScientisthastakenaforcewhichhasbeenlyingidleineverymemberofthehumanracesincetimebegan，andhasorganisedit，andbackedthebusinesswithcapital，andconcentrateditatBostonheadquartersinthehandsofasmallandverycompetentTrust，andthereareresults。
Thereinliesthepromisethatthismonopolyisgoingtoextenditscommercewideintheearth。Ithinkthatifthebusinesswereconductedinthelooseanddisconnectedfashioncustomarywithsuchthings，itwouldachievebutlittlemorethanthemodestprosperityusuallysecuredbyunorganisedgreatmoralandcommercialventures；butIbelievethatsolongasthisoneremainscompactlyorganisedandcloselyconcentratedinaTrust，thespreadofitsdominionwillcontinue。
VIENNA：May1，1899。
[1]Afterraisingadeadchildtolife，thedisciplewhodiditwritesanaccountofherperformance，toMrs。Eddy，andclosesitthus：\'Myprayerdailyistobemorespiritual，thatImaydomoreasyouwouldhavemedo……andmayweallloveyoumoreandsoliveitthattheworldmayknowthattheChristiscome。\'——PrintedintheConcord，N。H。，IndependentStatesman，March9，1899。Ifthisisnoworship，itisagoodimitationofit。
[2]InthepasttwoyearsthemembershipoftheEstablishedChurchofEnglandhavegivenvoluntarycontributionsamountingto$73，000，000totheChurch\'sbenevolententerprises。Churchesthatgivehavenothingtohide。
[3]ImaybeintroducingthecapitalSalittleearly——stillitisonitsway。
ISHELIVINGORISHEDEAD？
IwasspendingthemonthofMarch1892atMentone，intheRiviera。Atthisretiredspotonehasalltheadvantages，privately，whicharetobehadpubliclyatMonteCarloandNice，afewmilesfartheralong。Thatistosay，onehasthefloodingsunshine，thebalmyairandthebrilliantbluesea，withoutthemarringadditionsofhumanpow-wowandfussandfeathersanddisplay。Mentoneisquiet，simple，restful，unpretentious；
therichandthegaudydonotcomethere。Asarule，Imean，therichdonotcomethere。Nowandthenarichmancomes，andIpresentlygotacquaintedwithoneofthese。PartiallytodisguisehimIwillcallhimSmith。Oneday，intheHoteldesAnglais，atthesecondbreakfast，heexclaimed：
\'Quick！Castyoureyeonthemangoingoutatthedoor。Takeineverydetailofhim。\'
\'Why？\'
\'Doyouknowwhoheis？\'
\'Yes。Hespentseveraldaysherebeforeyoucame。Heisanold，retired，andveryrichsilkmanufacturerfromLyons，theysay，andI
guessheisaloneintheworld，forhealwayslookssadanddreamy，anddoesn\'ttalkwithanybody。HisnameisTheophileMagnan。\'
IsupposedthatSmithwouldnowproceedtojustifythelargeinterestwhichhehadshowninMonsieurMagnan，but，instead，hedroppedintoabrownstudy，andwasapparentlylosttomeandtotherestoftheworldduringsomeminutes。Nowandthenhepassedhisfingersthroughhisflossywhitehair，toassisthisthinking，andmeantimeheallowedhisbreakfasttogooncooling。Atlasthesaid：
\'No，it\'sgone；Ican\'tcallitback。\'
\'Can\'tcallwhatback？\'
\'It\'soneofHansAndersen\'sbeautifullittlestories。Butit\'sgonefrome。Partofitislikethis：Achildhasacagedbird，whichitlovesbutthoughtlesslyneglects。Thebirdpoursoutitssongunheardandunheeded；but，intime，hungerandthirstassailthecreature，anditssonggrowsplaintiveandfeebleandfinallyceases——thebirddies。Thechildcomes，andissmittentotheheartwithremorse：then，withbittertearsandlamentations，itcallsitsmates，andtheyburythebirdwithelaboratepompandthetenderestgrief，withoutknowing，poorthings，thatitisn\'tchildrenonlywhostarvepoetstodeathandthenspendenoughontheirfuneralsandmonumentstohavekeptthemaliveandmadethemeasyandcomfortable。Now——\'
Butherewewereinterrupted。AbouttenthateveningIranacrossSmith，andheaskedmeuptohisparlourtohelphimsmokeanddrinkhotScotch。
Itwasacosyplace，withitscomfortablechairs，itscheerfullamps，anditsfriendlyopenfireofseasonedolive-wood。Tomakeeverythingperfect，therewasamuffledboomingofthesurfoutside。AfterthesecondScotchandmuchlazyandcontentedchat，Smithsaid：
\'Nowweareproperlyprimed——Itotellacurioushistoryandyoutolistentoit。Ithasbeenasecretformanyyears——asecretbetweenmeandthreeothers；butIamgoingtobreakthesealnow。Areyoucomfortable？\'
\'Perfectly。Goon。\'