Chapter5。
Applications。
THEPRINCIPLESassertedinthesepagesmustbemoregenerallyadmittedasthebasisfordiscussionofdetails,beforeaconsistentapplicationofthemtoallthevariousdepartmentsofgovernmentandmoralscanbeattemptedwithanyprospectofadvantage。ThefewobservationsIproposetomakeonquestionsofdetailaredesignedtoillustratetheprinciples,ratherthantofollowthemouttotheirconsequences。Ioffer,notsomuchapplications,asspecimensofapplication;whichmayservetobringintogreaterclearnessthemeaningandlimitsofthetwomaximswhichtogetherformtheentiredoctrineofthisEssay,andtoassistthejudgmentinholdingthebalancebetweenthem,inthecaseswhereitappearsdoubtfulwhichofthemisapplicabletothecase。
Themaximsare,first,thattheindividualisnotaccountabletosocietyforhisactions,insofarastheseconcerntheinterestsofnopersonbuthimself。Advice,instruction,persuasion,andavoidancebyotherpeopleifthoughtnecessarybythemfortheirowngood,aretheonlymeasuresbywhichsocietycanjustifiablyexpressitsdislikeordisapprobationofhisconduct。Secondly,thatforsuchactionsasareprejudicialtotheinterestsofothers,theindividualisaccountable,andmaybesubjectedeithertosocialortolegalpunishment,ifsocietyisofopinionthattheoneortheotherisrequisiteforitsprotection。
Inthefirstplace,itmustbynomeansbesupposed,becausedamage,orprobabilityofdamage,totheinterestsofothers,canalonejustifytheinterferenceofsociety,thatthereforeitalwaysdoesjustifysuchinterference。Inmanycases,anindividual,inpursuingalegitimateobject,necessarilyandthereforelegitimatelycausespainorlosstoothers,orinterceptsagoodwhichtheyhadareasonablehopeofobtaining。Suchoppositionsofinterestbetweenindividualsoftenarisefrombadsocialinstitutions,butareunavoidablewhilethoseinstitutionslast;andsomewouldbeunavoidableunderanyinstitutions。Whoeversucceedsinanovercrowdedprofession,orinacompetitiveexamination;whoeverispreferredtoanotherinanycontestforanobjectwhichbothdesire,reapsbenefitfromthelossofothers,fromtheirwastedexertionandtheirdisappointment。Butitis,bycommonadmission,betterforthegeneralinterestofmankind,thatpersonsshouldpursuetheirobjectsundeterredbythissortofconsequences。Inotherwords,societyadmitsnoright,eitherlegalormoral,inthedisappointedcompetitorstoimmunityfromthiskindofsuffering;andfeelscalledontointerfere,onlywhenmeansofsuccesshavebeenemployedwhichitiscontrarytothegeneralinteresttopermit—namely,fraudortreachery,andforce。