ThatthisexplanationistrueforsomemindsinsomemoodsIwouldnotdeny。StillIthinkthatwhenamanseriouslyasks`whyheshoulddo’anything,hecommonlyassumesinhimselfadeterminationtopursuewhateverconductmaybeshownbyargumenttobereasonable,eventhoughitbeverydifferentfromthattowhichhisnon-rationalinclinationsmayprompt。Andwearegenerallyagreedthatreasonableconductinanycasehastobedeterminedonprinciples,inapplyingwhichtheagent’sinclination——asitexistsapartfromsuchdetermination——isonlyoneelementamongseveralthathavetobeconsidered,andcommonlynotthemostimportantelement。Butwhenweaskwhattheseprinciplesare,thediversityofanswerswhichwefindmanifestlydeclaredinthesystemsandfundamentalformulaeofprofessedmoralistsseemstobereallypresentinthecommonpracticalreasoningofmengenerally;withthisdifference,thatwhereasthephilosopherseeksunityofprinciple,andconsistencyofmethodattheriskofparadox,theunphilosophicmanisapttoholddifferentprinciplesatonce,andtoapplydifferentmethodsinmoreorlessconfusedcombination。Ifthisbeso,wecanofferanotherexplanationofthepersistentunsatisfieddemandforanultimatereason,abovenoticed。
Foriftherearedifferentviewsoftheultimatereasonablenessofconduct,implicitinthethoughtofordinarymen,thoughnotbroughtintoclearrelationtoeachother,-itiseasytoseethatanysingleanswertothequestion’why’willnotbecompletelysatisfactory,asitwillbegivenonlyfromoneofthesepointsofview,andwillalwaysleaveroomtoaskthequestionfromsomeother。
Iammyselfconvincedthatthisisthemainexplanationofthephenomenon:anditisonthisconvictionthattheplanofthepresenttreatiseisbased。Wecannot,ofcourse,regardasvalidreasoningsthatleadtoconflictingconclusions;andIthereforeassumeasafundamentalpostulateofEthics,thatsofarastwomethodsconflict,oneorotherofthemmustbemodifiedorrejected。ButIthinkitfundamentallyimportanttorecognise,attheoutsetofEthicalinquiry,thatthereisadiversityofmethodsappliedinordinarypracticalthought。
Whatthenarethesedifferentmethods?whatarethedifferentpracticalprincipleswhichthecommonsenseofmankindisprimafaciepreparedtoacceptasultimate?Somecareisneededinansweringthisquestion:becausewefrequentlyprescribethatthisorthat`ought’tobedoneoraimedatwithoutanyexpressreferencetoanulteriorend,whileyetsuchanendistacitlypresupposed。Itisobviousthatsuchprescriptionsaremerely,whatKantcallsthem,HypotheticalImperatives;theyarenotaddressedtoanyonewhohasnotfirstacceptedtheend。
Forinstance:ateacherofanyartassumesthathispupilwantstoproducetheproductoftheart,ortoproduceitexcellentinquality:betellshimthatbeoughttoholdtheawl,thehammer,thebrushdifferently。Aphysicianassumesthathispatientwantshealth: