RayarguedthegoodnessandwisdomofGodfromtheadaptationoftheanimalsnotonlytoman’susesbuttotheirownlivesandsurroundings。
InthefirstyearsoftheeighteenthcenturyDr。NehemiahGrew,oftheRoyalSociety,publishedhisCosmologiaSacratorefuteanti-scripturalopinionsbyproducingevidencesofcreativedesign。Discussing“theendsofProvidence。”hesays,“Acrane,whichisscurvymeat,laysbuttwoeggsintheyear,butapheasantandpartridge,bothexcellentmeat,layandhatchfifteenortwenty。”Hepointstothefactthat“thoseofvaluewhichlayfewatatimesittheoftener,asthewoodcockandthedove。”HebreaksdecidedlyfromthedoctrinethatnoxiousthingsinNaturearecausedbysin,andshowsthatthey,too,areuseful;that,“ifnettlessting,itistosecureanexcellentmedicineforchildrenandcattle“;that,“ifthebramblehurtsman,itmakesallthebetterhedge“;andthat,“ifitchancestopricktheowner,ittearsthethief。”“Weasels,kites,andotherhurtfulanimalsinduceustowatchfulness;thistlesandmoles,togoodhusbandry;liceobligeustocleanlinessinourbodies,spidersinourhouses,andthemothinourclothes。”Thisveryoptimisticview,triumphingoverthetheologicaltheoryofnoxiousanimalsandplantsaseffectsofsin,whichprevailedwithsomuchforcefromSt。AugustinetoWesley,wasdevelopedintonoblerformduringthecenturybyvariousthinkers,andespeciallybyArchdeaconPaley,whoseNaturalTheologyexercisedapowerfulinfluencedowntorecenttimes。Thesametendencyappearedinothercountries,thoughvariousphilosophersshowedweakpointsintheargument,andGoethemadesportofitinanotedverse,praisingtheforethoughtoftheCreatorinforeordainingthecorktreetofurnishstoppersforwine-bottles。
ShortlybeforethemiddleofthenineteenthcenturythemainmovementculminatedintheBridgewaterTreatises。PursuanttothewilloftheeighthEarlofBridgewater,thePresidentoftheRoyalSocietyselectedeightpersons,eachtoreceiveathousandpoundssterlingforwritingandpublishingatreatiseonthe“power,wisdom,andgoodnessofGod,asmanifestedinthecreation。”Ofthese,theleadingessaysinregardtoanimatedNaturewerethoseofThomasChalmers,onTheAdaptationofExternalNaturetotheMoralandIntellectualConditionofMan;
ofSirCharlesBell,onTheHandasevincingDesign;ofRoget,onAnimalandVegetablePhysiologywithreferencetoNaturalTheology;andofKirby,onTheHabitsandInstinctsofAnimalswithreferencetoNaturalTheology。
BesidesthesethereweretreatisesbyWhewell,Buckland,Kidd,andProut。Theworkwaswelldone。Itwasamarkedadvanceonallthathadappearedbefore,inmatter,method,andspirit。