byinsectsorwind,thereisNOCASEofLAND—animalsbeinghermaphroditewithouttheconcourseoftwoindividuals。\"
AlettertoDr。AsaGray(September5th,1857)givesthesubstanceofthepaperinthe\"Gardeners’Chronicle\":——
\"LatelyIwasledtoexaminebudsofkidneybeanwiththepollenshed;butIwasledtobelievethatthepollencouldHARDLYgetonthestigmabywindorotherwise,exceptbybeesvisiting[theflower]andmovingthewingpetals:henceIincludedasmallbunchofflowersintwobottlesineverywaytreatedthesame:theflowersinoneIdailyjustmomentarilymoved,asifbyabee;thesesetthreefinepods,theotherNOTONE。Ofcoursethislittleexperimentmustbetriedagain,andthisyearinEnglanditistoolate,astheflowersseemnowseldomtoset。Ifbeesarenecessarytothisflower’sself—fertilisation,beesmustalmostcrossthem,astheirdustedright—sideofheadandrightlegsconstantlytouchthestigma。
\"Ihave,also,latelybeenre—observingdailyLobeliafulgens——thisinmygardenisnevervisitedbyinsects,andneversetsseeds,withoutpollenbeputonthestigma(whereasthesmallblueLobeliaisvisitedbybeesanddoessetseed);Imentionthisbecausetherearesuchbeautifulcontrivancestopreventthestigmaevergettingitsownpollen;whichseemsonlyexplicableonthedoctrineoftheadvantageofcrosses。\"
Thepaperwassupplementedbyasecondin1858。(\"Gardeners’Chronicle\",1858,page828。In1861anotherpaperonFertilisationappearedinthe\"Gardeners’Chronicle\",page552,inwhichheexplainedtheactionofinsectsonVincamajor。Hewasattractedtotheperiwinklebythefactthatitisnotvisitedbyinsectsandneversetseeds。)Thechiefobjectofthesepublicationsseemstohavebeentoobtaininformationastothepossibilityofgrowingvarietiesofleguminousplantsneareachother,andyetkeepingthemtrue。ItiscuriousthatthePapilionaceaeshouldnotonlyhavebeenthefirstflowerswhichattractedhisattentionbytheirobviousadaptationtothevisitsofinsects,butshouldalsohaveconstitutedoneofhissorestpuzzles。Thecommonpeaandthesweetpeagavehimmuchdifficulty,because,althoughtheyareasobviouslyfittedforinsect—visitsastherestoftheorder,yettheirvarietieskeeptrue。