第3章
加入书架 A- A+
点击下载App,搜索"The Spirit of Laws",免费读到尾

  Ihavefirstofallconsideredmankind;andtheresultofmythoughtshasbeen,thatamidstsuchaninfinitediversityoflawsandmanners,theywerenotsolelyconductedbythecapriceoffancy。

  Ihavelaiddownthefirstprinciples,andhavefoundthattheparticularcasesfollownaturallyfromthem;thatthehistoriesofallnationsareonlyconsequencesofthem;andthateveryparticularlawisconnectedwithanotherlaw,ordependsonsomeotherofamoregeneralextent。

  WhenIhavebeenobligedtolookbackintoantiquity,Ihaveendeavouredtoassumethespiritoftheancients,lestIshouldconsiderthosethingsasalikewhicharereallydifferent;andlestIshouldmissthedifferenceofthosewhichappeartobealike。

  Ihavenotdrawnmyprinciplesfrommyprejudices,butfromthenatureofthings。

  Hereagreatmanytruthswillnotappeartillwehaveseenthechainwhichconnectsthemwithothers。Themoreweenterintoparticulars,themoreweshallperceivethecertaintyoftheprinciplesonwhichtheyarefounded。Ihavenotevengivenalltheseparticulars,forwhocouldmentionthemallwithoutamostinsupportablefatigue?

  Thereaderwillnotheremeetwithanyofthoseboldflightswhichseemtocharacterisetheworksofthepresentage。Whenthingsareexaminedwithneversosmalladegreeofextent,thesalliesofimaginationmustvanish;thesegenerallyarisefromthemind’scollectingallitspowerstoviewonlyonesideofthesubject,whileitleavestheotherunobserved。

  Iwritenottocensureanythingestablishedinanycountrywhatsoever。

  Everynationwillherefindthereasonsonwhichitsmaximsarefounded;

  andthiswillbethenaturalinference,thattoproposealterationsbelongsonlytothosewhoaresohappyastobebornwithageniuscapableofpenetratingtheentireconstitutionofastate。

  Itisnotamatterofindifferencethatthemindsofthepeoplebeenlightened。Theprejudicesofmagistrateshavearisenfromnationalprejudice。Inatimeofignorancetheyhavecommittedeventhegreatestevilswithouttheleastscruple;butinanenlightenedagetheyeventremblewhileconferringthegreatestblessings。Theyperceivetheancientabuses;theyseehowtheymustbereformed;buttheyaresensiblealsooftheabusesofareformation。Theylettheevilcontinue,iftheyfearaworse;theyarecontentwithalessergood,iftheydoubtagreater。Theyexamineintotheparts,tojudgeoftheminconnection;andtheyexamineallthecauses,todiscovertheirdifferenteffects。

  CouldIbutsucceedsoastoaffordnewreasonstoeverymantolovehisprince,hiscountry,hislaws;newreasonstorenderhimmoresensibleineverynationandgovernmentoftheblessingsheenjoys,Ishouldthinkmyselfthemosthappyofmortals。

  CouldIbutsucceedsoastopersuadethosewhocommand,toincreasetheirknowledgeinwhattheyoughttoprescribe;andthosewhoobey,tofindanewpleasureresultingfromobedience——Ishouldthinkmyselfthemosthappyofmortals。

  ThemosthappyofmortalsshouldIthinkmyselfcouldIcontributetomakemankindrecoverfromtheirprejudices。ByprejudicesIheremean,notthatwhichrendersmenignorantofsomeparticularthings,butwhateverrendersthemignorantofthemselves。

  Itisinendeavouringtoinstructmankindthatwearebestabletopractisethatgeneralvirtuewhichcomprehendstheloveofall。Man,thatflexiblebeing,conforminginsocietytothethoughtsandimpressionsofothers,isequallycapableofknowinghisownnature,wheneveritislaidopentohisview;andoflosingtheverysenseofit,whenthisideaisbanishedfromhismind。

  OftenhaveIbegun,andasoftenhaveIlaidaside,thisundertaking。I

  haveathousandtimesgiventheleavesIhadwrittentothewinds:I,everyday,feltmypaternalhandsfall。Ihavefollowedmyobjectwithoutanyfixedplan:Ihaveknownneitherrulesnorexceptions;I

  havefoundthetruth,onlytoloseitagain。ButwhenIoncediscoveredmyfirstprinciples,everythingIsoughtforappeared;andinthecourseoftwentyyears,Ihaveseenmyworkbegun,growingup,advancingtomaturity,andfinished。

  Ifthisworkmeetswithsuccess,Ishalloweitchieflytothegrandeurandmajestyofthesubject。However,IdonotthinkthatIhavebeentotallydeficientinpointofgenius。WhenIhaveseenwhatsomanygreatmenbothinFrance,England,andGermanyhavesaidbeforeme,I

  havebeenlostinadmiration;butIhavenotlostmycourage:IhavesaidwithCorreggio,\"AndIalsoamapainter。\"

  ADVERTISEMENT

  1。Forthebetterunderstandingofthefirstfourbooksofthiswork,itistobeobservedthatwhatIdistinguishbythenameofvirtue,inarepublic,istheloveofone’scountry,thatis,theloveofequality。

  Itisnotamoral,noraChristian,butapoliticalvirtue;anditisthespringwhichsetstherepublicangovernmentinmotion,ashonouristhespringwhichgivesmotiontomonarchy。HenceitisthatIhavedistinguishedtheloveofone’scountry,andofequality,bytheappellationofpoliticalvirtue。Myideasarenew,andthereforeIhavebeenobligedtofindnewwords,ortogivenewacceptationstooldterms,inordertoconveymymeaning。They,whoareunacquaintedwiththisparticular,havemademesaymoststrangeabsurdities,suchaswouldbeshockinginanypartoftheworld,becauseinallcountriesandgovernmentsmoralityisrequisite。

  2。Thereaderisalsotonoticethatthereisavastdifferencebetweensayingthatacertainquality,modificationofthemind,orvirtue,isnotthespringbywhichgovernmentisactuated,andaffirmingthatitisnottobefoundinthatgovernment。WereItosaysuchawheelorsuchapinionisnotthespringwhichsetsthewatchgoing,canyouinferthencethattheyarenottobefoundinthewatch?SofarisitfrombeingtruethatthemoralandChristianvirtuesareexcludedfrommonarchy,thatevenpoliticalvirtueisnotexcluded。Inaword,honourisfoundinarepublic,thoughitsspringbepoliticalvirtue;andpoliticalvirtueisfoundinamonarchicalgovernment,thoughitbeactuatedbyhonour。

  Toconclude,thehonestmanofwhomwetreatinthethirdbook,chapter5,isnottheChristian,butthepoliticalhonestman,whoispossessedofthepoliticalvirtuetherementioned。Heisthemanwholovesthelawsofhiscountry,andwhoisactuatedbytheloveofthoselaws。I

  havesetthesemattersinaclearerlightinthepresentedition,bygivingamoreprecisemeaningtomyexpression:andinmostplaceswhereIhavemadeuseofthewordvirtueIhavetakencaretoaddthetermpolitical。

  BookI。OfLawsinGeneral1。OftheRelationofLawstodifferentBeings。Laws,intheirmostgeneralsignification,arethenecessaryrelationsarisingfromthenatureofthings。Inthissenseallbeingshavetheirlaws:theDeity[1]

  Hislaws,thematerialworlditslaws,theintelligencessuperiortomantheirlaws,thebeaststheirlaws,manhislaws。

  Theywhoassertthatablindfatalityproducedthevariouseffectswebeholdinthisworldtalkveryabsurdly;forcananythingbemoreunreasonablethantopretendthatablindfatalitycouldbeproductiveofintelligentbeings?

  Thereis,then,aprimereason;andlawsaretherelationssubsistingbetweenitanddifferentbeings,andtherelationsofthesetooneanother。

  Godisrelatedtotheuniverse,asCreatorandPreserver;thelawsbywhichHecreatedallthingsarethosebywhichHepreservesthem。Heactsaccordingtotheserules,becauseHeknowsthem;Heknowsthem,becauseHemadethem;andHemadethem,becausetheyareinrelationtoHiswisdomandpower。

  Sinceweobservethattheworld,thoughformedbythemotionofmatter,andvoidofunderstanding,subsiststhroughsolongasuccessionofages,itsmotionsmustcertainlybedirectedbyinvariablelaws;andcouldweimagineanotherworld,itmustalsohaveconstantrules,oritwouldinevitablyperish。

  Thusthecreation,whichseemsanarbitraryact,supposeslawsasinvariableasthoseofthefatalityoftheAtheists。ItwouldbeabsurdtosaythattheCreatormightgoverntheworldwithoutthoserules,sincewithoutthemitcouldnotsubsist。

  Theserulesareafixedandinvariablerelation。Inbodiesmoved,themotionisreceived,increased,diminished,orlost,accordingtotherelationsofthequantityofmatterandvelocity;eachdiversityisuniformity,eachchangeisconstancy。

  Particularintelligentbeingsmayhavelawsoftheirownmaking,buttheyhavesomelikewisewhichtheynevermade。Beforetherewereintelligentbeings,theywerepossible;theyhadthereforepossiblerelations,andconsequentlypossiblelaws。Beforelawsweremade,therewererelationsofpossiblejustice。Tosaythatthereisnothingjustorunjustbutwhatiscommandedorforbiddenbypositivelaws,isthesameassayingthatbeforethedescribingofacirclealltheradiiwerenotequal。

  Wemustthereforeacknowledgerelationsofjusticeantecedenttothepositivelawbywhichtheyareestablished:as,forinstance,ifhumansocietiesexisted,itwouldberighttoconformtotheirlaws;iftherewereintelligentbeingsthathadreceivedabenefitofanotherbeing,theyoughttoshowtheirgratitude;ifoneintelligentbeinghadcreatedanotherintelligentbeing,thelatteroughttocontinueinitsoriginalstateofdependence;ifoneintelligentbeinginjuresanother,itdeservesaretaliation;andsoon。

  Buttheintelligentworldisfarfrombeingsowellgovernedasthephysical。Forthoughtheformerhasalsoitslaws,whichoftheirownnatureareinvariable,itdoesnotconformtothemsoexactlyasthephysicalworld。Thisisbecause,ontheonehand,particularintelligentbeingsareofafinitenature,andconsequentlyliabletoerror;andontheother,theirnaturerequiresthemtobefreeagents。Hencetheydonotsteadilyconformtotheirprimitivelaws;andeventhoseoftheirowninstitutingtheyfrequentlyinfringe。

  Whetherbrutesbegovernedbythegenerallawsofmotion,orbyaparticularmovement,wecannotdetermine。Bethatasitmay,theyhavenotamoreintimaterelationtoGodthantherestofthematerialworld;

  andsensationisofnootherusetothemthanintherelationtheyhaveeithertootherparticularbeingsortothemselves。

  Bytheallurementofpleasuretheypreservetheindividual,andbythesameallurementtheypreservetheirspecies。Theyhavenaturallaws,becausetheyareunitedbysensation;positivelawstheyhavenone,becausetheyarenotconnectedbyknowledge。Andyettheydonotinvariablyconformtotheirnaturallaws;thesearebetterobservedbyvegetables,thathaveneitherunderstandingnorsense。

  Brutesaredeprivedofthehighadvantageswhichwehave;buttheyhavesomewhichwehavenot。Theyhavenotourhopes,buttheyarewithoutourfears;theyaresubjectlikeustodeath,butwithoutknowingit;

  evenmostofthemaremoreattentivethanwetoself—preservation,anddonotmakesobadauseoftheirpassions。

  Man,asaphysicalbeing,islikeotherbodiesgovernedbyinvariablelaws。Asanintelligentbeing,heincessantlytransgressesthelawsestablishedbyGod,andchangesthoseofhisowninstituting。Heislefttohisprivatedirection,thoughalimitedbeing,andsubject,likeallfiniteintelligences,toignoranceanderror:evenhisimperfectknowledgeheloses;andasasensiblecreature,heishurriedawaybyathousandimpetuouspassions。SuchabeingmighteveryinstantforgethisCreator;Godhasthereforeremindedhimofhisdutybythelawsofreligion。Suchabeingisliableeverymomenttoforgethimself;

  philosophyhasprovidedagainstthisbythelawsofmorality。Formedtoliveinsociety,hemightforgethisfellow—creatures;legislatorshavethereforebypoliticalandcivillawsconfinedhimtohisduty。

  2。OftheLawsofNature。Antecedenttotheabove—mentionedlawsarethoseofnature,socalled,becausetheyderivetheirforceentirelyfromourframeandexistence。Inordertohaveaperfectknowledgeoftheselaws,wemustconsidermanbeforetheestablishmentofsociety:

  thelawsreceivedinsuchastatewouldbethoseofnature。

  Thelawwhich,impressingonourmindstheideaofaCreator,inclinesustowardsHim,isthefirstinimportance,thoughnotinorder,ofnaturallaws。Maninastateofnaturewouldhavethefacultyofknowing,beforehehadacquiredanyknowledge。Plainitisthathisfirstideaswouldnotbeofaspeculativenature;hewouldthinkofthepreservationofhisbeing,beforehewouldinvestigateitsorigin。Suchamanwouldfeelnothinginhimselfatfirstbutimpotencyandweakness;

  hisfearsandapprehensionswouldbeexcessive;asappearsfrominstances(werethereanynecessityofprovingit)ofsavagesfoundinforests,[2]tremblingatthemotionofaleaf,andflyingfromeveryshadow。

  Inthisstateeveryman,insteadofbeingsensibleofhisequality,wouldfancyhimselfinferior。Therewouldthereforebenodangeroftheirattackingoneanother;peacewouldbethefirstlawofnature。

  ThenaturalimpulseordesirewhichHobbesattributestomankindofsubduingoneanotherisfarfrombeingwellfounded。Theideaofempireanddominionissocomplex,anddependsonsomanyothernotions,thatitcouldneverbethefirstwhichoccurredtothehumanunderstanding。

  Hobbes[3]inquires,\"Forwhatreasongomenarmed,andhavelocksandkeystofastentheirdoors,iftheybenotnaturallyinastateofwar?\"

  Butisitnotobviousthatheattributestomankindbeforetheestablishmentofsocietywhatcanhappenbutinconsequenceofthisestablishment,whichfurnishesthemwithmotivesforhostileattacksandself—defence?

  Nexttoasenseofhisweaknessmanwouldsoonfindthatofhiswants。

  Henceanotherlawofnaturewouldprompthimtoseekfornourishment。

  Fear,Ihaveobserved,wouldinducementoshunoneanother;butthemarksofthisfearbeingreciprocal,wouldsoonengagethemtoassociate。Besides,thisassociationwouldquicklyfollowfrom。theverypleasureoneanimalfeelsattheapproachofanotherofthesamespecies。Again,theattractionarisingfromthedifferenceofsexeswouldenhancethispleasure,andthenaturalinclinationtheyhaveforeachotherwouldformathirdlaw。

  Besidethesenseorinstinctwhichmanpossessesincommonwithbrutes,hehastheadvantageofacquiredknowledge;andthencearisesasecondtie,whichbruteshavenot。Mankindhavethereforeanewmotiveofuniting;andafourthlawofnatureresultsfromthedesireoflivinginsociety。

  3。OfPositiveLaws。Assoonasmanentersintoastateofsocietyhelosesthesenseofhisweakness;equalityceases,andthencommencesthestateofwar。

  Eachparticularsocietybeginstofeelitsstrength,whencearisesastateofwarbetweendifferentnations。Theindividualslikewiseofeachsocietybecomesensibleoftheirforce;hencetheprincipaladvantagesofthissocietytheyendeavourtoconverttotheirownemolument,whichconstitutesastateofwarbetweenindividuals。

  Thesetwodifferentkindsofstatesgiverisetohumanlaws。Consideredasinhabitantsofsogreataplanet,whichnecessarilycontainsavarietyofnations,theyhavelawsrelatingtotheirmutualintercourse,whichiswhatwecallthelawofnations。Asmembersofasocietythatmustbeproperlysupported,theyhavelawsrelatingtothegovernorsandthegoverned,andthiswedistinguishbythenameofpoliticlaw。Theyhavealsoanothersortoflaw,astheystandinrelationtoeachother;

  bywhichisunderstoodthecivillaw。

  Thelawofnationsisnaturallyfoundedonthisprinciple,thatdifferentnationsoughtintimeofpeacetodooneanotherallthegoodtheycan,andintimeofwaraslittleinjuryaspossible,withoutprejudicingtheirrealinterests。

  Theobjectofwarisvictory;thatofvictoryisconquest;andthatofconquestpreservation。Fromthisandtheprecedingprincipleallthoserulesarederivedwhichconstitutethelawofnations。

  Allcountrieshavealawofnations,notexceptingtheIroquoisthemselves,thoughtheydevourtheirprisoners:fortheysendandreceiveambassadors,andunderstandtherightsofwarandpeace。Themischiefisthattheirlawofnationsisnotfoundedontrueprinciples。

  Besidesthelawofnationsrelatingtoallsocieties,thereisapolityorcivilconstitutionforeachparticularlyconsidered。Nosocietycansubsistwithoutaformofgovernment。\"Theunitedstrengthofindividuals,\"asGravina[4]wellobserves,\"constituteswhatwecallthebodypolitic。\"

  Thegeneralstrengthmaybeinthehandsofasingleperson,orofmany。

  Somethinkthatnaturehavingestablishedpaternalauthority,themostnaturalgovernmentwasthatofasingleperson。Buttheexampleofpaternalauthorityprovesnothing。Forifthepowerofafatherrelatestoasinglegovernment,thatofbrothersafterthedeathofafather,andthatofcousins—germanafterthedeceaseofbrothers,refertoagovernmentofmany。Thepoliticalpowernecessarilycomprehendstheunionofseveralfamilies。

  Betterisittosay,thatthegovernmentmostconformabletonatureisthatwhichbestagreeswiththehumouranddispositionofthepeopleinwhosefavouritisestablished。

  Thestrengthofindividualscannotbeunitedwithoutaconjunctionofalltheirwills。\"Theconjunctionofthosewills,\"asGravinaagainveryjustlyobserves,\"iswhatwecallthecivilstate。\"

  Lawingeneralishumanreason,inasmuchasitgovernsalltheinhabitantsoftheearth:thepoliticalandcivillawsofeachnationoughttobeonlytheparticularcasesinwhichhumanreasonisapplied。

  Theyshouldbeadaptedinsuchamannertothepeopleforwhomtheyareframedthatitshouldbeagreatchanceifthoseofonenationsuitanother。

  Theyshouldbeinrelationtothenatureandprincipleofeachgovernment;whethertheyformit,asmaybesaidofpoliticlaws;orwhethertheysupportit,asinthecaseofcivilinstitutions。

  Theyshouldbeinrelationtotheclimateofeachcountry,tothequalityofitssoil,toitssituationandextent,totheprincipaloccupationofthenatives,whetherhusbandmen,huntsmen,orshepherds:

  theyshouldhaverelationtothedegreeoflibertywhichtheconstitutionwillbear;tothereligionoftheinhabitants,totheirinclinations,riches,numbers,commerce,manners,andcustoms。Infine,theyhaverelationstoeachother,asalsototheirorigin,totheintentofthelegislator,andtotheorderofthingsonwhichtheyareestablished;inallofwhichdifferentlightstheyoughttobeconsidered。

  ThisiswhatIhaveundertakentoperforminthefollowingwork。TheserelationsIshallexamine,sinceallthesetogetherconstitutewhatI

  calltheSpiritofLaws。

  Ihavenotseparatedthepoliticalfromthecivilinstitutions,asIdonotpretendtotreatoflaws,butoftheirspirit;andasthisspiritconsistsinthevariousrelationswhichthelawsmaybeartodifferentobjects,itisnotsomuchmybusinesstofollowthenaturalorderoflawsasthatoftheserelationsandobjects。

  Ishallfirstexaminetherelationswhichlawsbeartothenatureandprincipleofeachgovernment;andasthisprinciplehasastronginfluenceonlaws,Ishallmakeitmystudytounderstanditthoroughly:

  andifIcanbutonceestablishit,thelawswillsoonappeartoflowthenceasfromtheirsource。Ishallproceedafterwardstootherandmoreparticularrelations。

  ______

  1。\"Law,\"saysPlutarch,\"isthekingofmortalandimmortalbeings。\"

  Seehistreatise,ADiscoursetoanUnlearnedPrince。

  2。WitnessthesavagefoundintheforestsofHanover,whowascarriedovertoEnglandduringthereignofGeorgeI。

  3。Inpref。,Decive。

  4。Italianpoetandjurist,1664—1718。

  BookII。OfLawsDirectlyDerivedfromtheNatureofGovernment1。OftheNatureofthethreedifferentGovernments。Therearethreespeciesofgovernment:republican,monarchical,anddespotic。Inordertodiscovertheirnature,itissufficienttorecollectthecommonnotion,whichsupposesthreedefinitions,orratherthreefacts:thatarepublicangovernmentisthatinwhichthebody,oronlyapartofthepeople,ispossessedofthesupremepower;monarchy,thatinwhichasinglepersongovernsbyfixedandestablishedlaws;adespoticgovernment,thatinwhichasinglepersondirectseverythingbyhisownwillandcaprice。

  ThisiswhatIcallthenatureofeachgovernment;wemustnowinquireintothoselawswhichdirectlyconformtothisnature,andconsequentlyarethefundamentalinstitutions。

  2。OftheRepublicanGovernment,andtheLawsinrelationtoDemocracy。[1]Whenthebodyofthepeopleispossessedofthesupremepower,itiscalledademocracy。Whenthesupremepowerislodgedinthehandsofapartofthepeople,itisthenanaristocracy。

  Inademocracythepeopleareinsomerespectsthesovereign,andinothersthesubject。

  Therecanbenoexerciseofsovereigntybutbytheirsuffrages,whicharetheirownwill;nowthesovereign’swillisthesovereignhimself。

  Thelawsthereforewhichestablishtherightofsuffragearefundamentaltothisgovernment。Andindeeditisasimportanttoregulateinarepublic,inwhatmanner,bywhom,towhom,andconcerningwhat,suffragesaretobegiven,asitisinamonarchytoknowwhoistheprince,andafterwhatmannerheoughttogovern。

  Libanius[2]saysthatatAthensastrangerwhointermeddledintheassembliesofthepeoplewaspunishedwithdeath。Thisisbecausesuchamanusurpedtherightsofsovereignty。

点击下载App,搜索"The Spirit of Laws",免费读到尾