Byreferringthematterfromargumenttoarms,anewaeraforpoliticsisstruck;anewmethodofthinkinghatharisen。
Allplans,proposals,&c。priortothenineteenthofApril,i。e。tothecommencementofhostilities,arelikethealmanacsofthelastyear;which,thoughproperthenaresupersededanduselessnow。Whateverwasadvancedbytheadvocatesoneithersideofthequestionthen,terminatedinoneandthesamepoint。viz。aunionwithGreat-Britain:theonlydifferencebetweenthepartieswasthemethodofeffectingit;theoneproposingforce,theotherfriendship;butithathsofarhappenedthatthefirsthathfailed,andthesecondhathwithdrawnherinfluence。
Asmuchhathbeensaidoftheadvantagesofreconciliationwhich,likeanagreeabledream,hathpassedawayandleftusaswewere,itisbutright,thatweshouldexaminethecontrarysideoftheargument,andinquireintosomeofthemanymaterialinjurieswhichthesecoloniessustain,andalwayswillsustain,bybeingconnectedwith,anddependentonGreatBritain:
Toexaminethatconnectionanddependence,ontheprinciplesofnatureandcommonsense,toseewhatwehavetotrustto,ifseparated,andwhatwearetoexpect,ifdependant。
Ihavehearditassertedbysome,thatasAmericahathflourishedunderherformerconnectionwithGreatBritainthatthesameconnectionisnecessarytowardsherfuturehappiness,andwillalwayshavethesameeffect。
Nothingcanbemorefallaciousthanthiskindofargument。
Wemayaswellassertthatbecauseachildhasthriveduponmilkthatitisnevertohavemeat,orthatthefirsttwentyyearsofourlivesistobecomeaprecedentforthenexttwenty。
Buteventhisisadmittingmorethanistrue,forIanswerroundly,thatAmericawouldhaveflourishedasmuch,andprobablymuchmore,hadnoEuropeanpowerhadanythingtodowithher。Thecommerce,bywhichshehathenrichedherself,arethenecessariesoflife,andwillalwayshaveamarketwhileeatingisthecustomofEurope。
Butshehasprotectedus,saysome。Thatshehasengrossedusistrue,anddefendedthecontinentatourexpenseaswellasherownisadmitted,andshewouldhavedefendedTurkeyfromthesamemotive,viz。thesakeoftradeanddominion。
Alas,wehavebeenlongledawaybyancientprejudices,andmadelargesacrificestosuperstition。WehaveboastedtheprotectionofGreatBritain,withoutconsidering,thathermotivewasINTERESTnotATTACHMENT;thatshedidnotprotectusfromOURENEMIESonOURACCOUNT,butfromHERENEMIESonHEROWNACCOUNT,fromthosewhohadnoquarrelwithusonanyOTHERACCOUNT,andwhowillalwaysbeourenemiesontheSAMEACCOUNT。
LetBritainwaveherpretensionstothecontinent,orthecontinentthrowoffthedependence,andweshouldbeatpeacewithFranceandSpainweretheyatwarwithBritain。
ThemiseriesofHanoverlastwaroughttowarnusagainstconnections。
Ithaslatelybeenassertedinparliament,thatthecolonieshavenorelationtoeachotherbutthroughtheparentcountry,i。e。thatPennsylvaniaandtheJerseys,andsoonfortherest,aresistercoloniesbythewayofEngland;thisiscertainlyaveryround-aboutwayofprovingrelationship,butitisthenearestandonlytruewayofprovingenemyship,ifImaysocallit。
FranceandSpainneverwere。norperhapseverwillbeourenemiesasAMERICANS,butasourbeingthesubjectsofGREATBRITAIN。
ButBritainistheparentcountry,saysome。Thenthemoreshameuponherconduct。Evenbrutesdonotdevourtheiryoung,norsavagesmakewarupontheirfamilies;whereforetheassertion,iftrue,turnstoherreproach;butithappensnottobetrue,oronlypartlysoandthephrasePARENTorMOTHERCOUNTRY
hathbeenjesuiticallyadoptedbythekingandhisparasites,withalowpapisticaldesignofgaininganunfairbiasonthecredulousweaknessofourminds。Europe,andnotEngland,istheparentcountryofAmerica。ThisnewworldhathbeentheasylumforthepersecutedloversofcivilandreligiouslibertyfromEVERYPART
ofEurope。Hitherhavetheyfled,notfromthetenderembracesofthemother,butfromthecrueltyofthemonster;anditissofartrueofEngland,thatthesametyrannywhichdrovethefirstemigrantsfromhome,pursuestheirdescendantsstill。
Inthisextensivequarteroftheglobe,weforgetthenarrowlimitsofthreehundredandsixtymiles(theextentofEngland)
andcarryourfriendshiponalargerscale;weclaimbrotherhoodwitheveryEuropeanChristian,andtriumphinthegenerosityofthesentiment。
Itispleasanttoobservebywhatregulargradationswesurmounttheforceoflocalprejudice,asweenlargeouracquaintancewiththeworld。AmanborninanytowninEnglanddividedintoparishes,willnaturallyassociatemostwithhisfellow-parishioners(becausetheirinterestsinmanycaseswillbecommon)anddistinguishhimbythenameofNEIGHBOUR;
ifhemeethimbutafewmilesfromhome,hedropsthenarrowideaofastreet,andsaluteshimbythenameofTOWNSMAN;ifhetraveloutofthecounty,andmeethiminanyother,heforgetstheminordivisionsofstreetandtown,andcallshimCOUNTRYMAN,i。e。COUNTRYMAN;
butifintheirforeignexcursionstheyshouldassociateinFranceoranyotherpartofEUROPE,theirlocalremembrancewouldbeenlargedintothatofENGLISHMEN。Andbyajustparityofreasoning,allEuropeansmeetinginAmerica,oranyotherquarteroftheglobe,areCOUNTRYMEN;forEngland,Holland,Germany,orSweden,whencomparedwiththewhole,standinthesameplacesonthelargerscale,whichthedivisionsofstreet,town,andcountydoonthesmallerones;
distinctionstoolimitedforcontinentalminds。Notonethirdoftheinhabitants,evenofthisprovince,areofEnglishdescent。
WhereforeIreprobatethephraseofparentormothercountryappliedtoEnglandonly,asbeingfalse,selfish,narrowandungenerous。
Butadmitting,thatwewereallofEnglishdescent,whatdoesitamountto?Nothing。Britain,beingnowanopenenemy,extinguisheseveryothernameandtitle:Andtosaythatreconciliationisourduty,istrulyfarcical。ThefirstkingofEngland,ofthepresentline(WilliamtheConqueror)
wasaFrenchman,andhalfthePeersofEnglandaredescendantsfromthesamecountry;therefore,bythesamemethodofreasoning,EnglandoughttobegovernedbyFrance。
MuchhathbeensaidoftheunitedstrengthofBritainandthecolonies,thatinconjunctiontheymightbiddefiancetotheworld。Butthisismerepresumption;thefateofwarisuncertain,neitherdotheexpressionsmeananything;forthiscontinentwouldneversufferitselftobedrainedofinhabitants,tosupporttheBritisharmsineitherAsia,Africa,orEurope。
Besideswhathavewetodowithsettingtheworldatdefiance?
Ourplaniscommerce,andthat,wellattendedto,willsecureusthepeaceandfriendshipofallEurope;because,itistheinterestofallEuropetohaveAmericaaFREEPORT。Hertradewillalwaysbeaprotection,andherbarrennessofgoldandsilversecureherfrominvaders。
Ichallengethewarmestadvocateforreconciliation,toshew,asingleadvantagethatthiscontinentcanreap,bybeingconnectedwithGreatBritain。Irepeatthechallenge,notasingleadvantageisderived。OurcornwillfetchitspriceinanymarketinEurope,andourimportedgoodsmustbepaidfor,buythemwherewewill。
Buttheinjuriesanddisadvantageswesustainbythatconnection,arewithoutnumber;andourdutytomankindatlarge,aswellastoourselves,instructustorenouncethealliance:
Because,anysubmissionto,ordependenceonGreatBritain,tendsdirectlytoinvolvethiscontinentinEuropeanwarsandquarrels;
andsetsusatvariancewithnations,whowouldotherwiseseekourfriendship,andagainstwhom,wehaveneitherangernorcomplaint。AsEuropeisourmarketfortrade,weoughttoformnopartialconnectionwithanypartofit。
ItisthetrueinterestofAmericatosteerclearofEuropeancontentions,whichshenevercando,whilebyherdependenceonBritain,sheismadethemake-weightinthescaleofBritishpolitics。
Europeistoothicklyplantedwithkingdomstobelongatpeace,andwheneverawarbreaksoutbetweenEnglandandanyforeignpower,thetradeofAmericagoestoruin,BECAUSEOFHERCONNECTIONWITHENGLAND。
Thenextwarmaynotturnoutlikethelast,andshoulditnot,theadvocatesforreconciliationnow,willbewishingforseparationthen,because,neutralityinthatcase,wouldbeasaferconvoythanamanofwar。
Everythingthatisrightornaturalpleadsforseparation。Thebloodoftheslain,theweepingvoiceofnaturecries,’TISTIMETOPART。
EventhedistanceatwhichtheAlmightyhathplacedEnglandandAmerica,isastrongandnaturalproof,thattheauthorityoftheone,overtheother,wasneverthedesignofHeaven。Thetimelikewiseatwhichthecontinentwasdiscovered,addsweighttotheargument,andthemannerinwhichitwaspeopledincreasestheforceofit。ThereformationwasprecededbythediscoveryofAmerica,asiftheAlmightygraciouslymeanttoopenasanctuarytothePersecutedinfutureyears,whenhomeshouldaffordneitherfriendshipnorsafety。
TheauthorityofGreatBritainoverthiscontinent,isaformofgovernment,whichsoonerorlatermusthaveanend:
Andaseriousmindcandrawnotruepleasurebylookingforwardunderthepainfulandpositiveconviction,thatwhathecalls\"thepresentconstitution\"ismerelytemporary。Asparents,wecanhavenojoy,knowingthatTHISGOVERNMENTisnotsufficientlylastingtoensureanythingwhichwemaybequeathtoposterity:
Andbyaplainmethodofargument,aswearerunningthenextgenerationintodebt,weoughttodotheworkofit,otherwiseweusethemmeanlyandpitifully。Inordertodiscoverthelineofourdutyrightly,weshouldtakeourchildreninourhand,andfixourstationafewyearsfartherintolife;thateminencewillpresentaprospect,whichafewpresentfearsandprejudicesconcealfromoursight。
ThoughIwouldcarefullyavoidgivingunnecessaryoffense,yetIaminclinedtobelieve,thatallthosewhoespousethedoctrineofreconciliation,maybeincludedwithinthefollowingdescriptions。
Interestedmen,whoarenottobetrusted;weakmen,whoCANNOTsee;
prejudicedmen,whoWILLNOTsee;andacertainsetofmoderatemen,whothinkbetteroftheEuropeanworldthanitdeserves;
andthislastclass,byanill-judgeddeliberation,willbethecauseofmorecalamitiestothiscontinent,thanalltheotherthree。
Itisthegoodfortuneofmanytolivedistantfromthesceneofsorrow;
theevilisnotsufficientbroughttotheirdoorstomakeTHEM
feeltheprecariousnesswithwhichallAmericanpropertyispossessed。
ButletourimaginationstransportusfarafewmomentstoBoston,thatseatofwretchednesswillteachuswisdom,andinstructusforevertorenounceapowerinwhomwecanhavenotrust。
Theinhabitantsofthatunfortunatecity,whobutafewmonthsagowereineaseandaffluence,havenow,nootheralternativethantostayandstarve,orturnandbeg。Endangeredbythefireoftheirfriendsiftheycontinuewithinthecity,andplunderedbythesoldieryiftheyleaveit。Intheirpresentconditiontheyareprisonerswithoutthehopeofredemption,andinageneralattackfortheirrelief,theywouldbeexposedtothefuryofbotharmies。
MenofpassivetemperslooksomewhatlightlyovertheoffensesofBritain,and,stillhopingforthebest,areapttocallout,\"COME,COME,WESHALLBEFRIENDSAGAIN,FORALLTHIS。\"
Butexaminethepassionsandfeelingsofmankind,Bringthedoctrineofreconciliationtothetouchstoneofnature,andthentellme,whetheryoucanhereafterlove,honor,andfaithfullyservethepowerthathathcarriedfireandswordintoyourland?Ifyoncannotdoallthese,thenareyouonlydeceivingyourselves,andbyyourdelaybringingruinuponposterity。YourfutureconnectionwithBritain,whomyoucanneitherlovenorhonorwillbeforcedandunnatural,andbeingformedonlyontheplanofpresentconvenience,willinalittletimefallintoarelapsemorewretchedthanthefirst。
Butifyousay,youcanstillpasstheviolationsover,thenIask,Hathyourhousebeenburnt?Hathyourpropertybeendestroyedbeforeyourface!Areyourwifeandchildrendestituteofabedtolieon,orbreadtoliveon?Haveyoulostaparentorachildbytheirhands,andyourselftheruinedandwretchedsurvivor!Ifyouhavenot,thenareyounotajudgeofthosewhohave。Butifyouhave,andstillcanshakehandswiththemurderers,thenareyouunworthythenameofhusband,father,friend,orlover,andwhatevermaybeyourrankortitleinlife,youhavetheheartofacoward,andthespiritofasycophant。
Thisisnotinflamingorexaggeratingmatters,buttryingthembythosefeelingsandaffectionswhichnaturejustifies,andwithoutwhich,weshouldbeincapableofdischargingthesocialdutiesoflife,orenjoyingthefelicitiesofit。
Imeannottoexhibithorrorforthepurposeofprovokingrevenge,buttoawakenusfromfatalandunmanlyslumbers,thatwemaypursuedeterminatelysomefixedobject。ItisnotinthepowerofBritainorofEuropetoconquerAmerica,ifshedonotconquerherselfbyDELAYandTIMIDITY。Thepresentwinterisworthanageifrightlyemployed,butiflostorneglected,thewholecontinentwillpartakeofthemisfortune;
andthereisnopunishmentwhichthatmanwillnotdeserve,behewho,orwhat,orwherehewill,thatmaybethemeansofsacrificingaseasonsopreciousanduseful。
Itisrepugnanttoreason,totheuniversalorderofthings,toallexamplesfromformerages,tosuppose,thatthiscontinentcanlongerremainsubjecttoanyexternalpower。
ThemostsanguineinBritaindoesnotthinkso。Theutmoststretchofhumanwisdomcannot,atthistime,compassaplanshortofseparation,whichcanpromisethecontinentevenayear’ssecurity。ReconciliationisNOWafallaciousdream。
Naturehathdesertedtheconnection,andArtcannotsupplyherplace。For,asMiltonwiselyexpresses,\"nevercantruereconcilementgrow,wherewoundsofdeadlyhatehavepiercedsodeep。\"
Everyquietmethodforpeacehathbeenineffectual。Ourprayershavebeenrejectedwithdisdain;andonlytendedtoconvinceus,thatnothingBattersvanity,orconfirmsobstinacyinKingsmorethanrepeatedpetitioning-andnothinghathcontributedmorethanthatverymeasuretomaketheKingsofEuropeabsolute:
WitnessDenmarkandSweden。Wherefore,sincenothingbutblowswilldo,forGod’ssake,letuscometoafinalseparation,andnotleavethenextgenerationtobecuttingthroats,undertheviolatedunmeaningnamesofparentandchild。
Tosay,theywillneverattemptitagainisidleandvisionary,wethoughtsoattherepealofthestamp-act,yetayearortwoundeceivedus;aswellmaywesupposethatnations,whichhavebeenoncedefeated,willneverrenewthequarrel。
Astogovernmentmatters,itisnotinthepowerofBritaintodothiscontinentjustice:Thebusinessofitwillsoonbetooweighty,andintricate,tobemanagedwithanytolerabledegreeofconvenience,byapowersodistantfromus,andsoveryignorantofus;foriftheycannotconquerus,theycannotgovernus。Tobealwaysrunningthreeorfourthousandmileswithataleorapetition,waitingfourorfivemonthsforananswer,whichwhenobtainedrequiresfiveorsixmoretoexplainitin,willinafewyearsbelookeduponasfollyandchildishness——Therewasatimewhenitwasproper,andthereisapropertimeforittocease。
Smallislandsnotcapableofprotectingthemselves,aretheproperobjectsforkingdomstotakeundertheircare;
butthereissomethingveryabsurd,insupposingacontinenttobeperpetuallygovernedbyanisland。Innoinstancehathnaturemadethesatellitelargerthanitsprimaryplanet,andasEnglandandAmerica,withrespecttoeachother,reversesthecommonorderofnature,itisevidenttheybelongtodifferentsystems;EnglandtoEurope,Americatoitself。
Iamnotinducedbymotivesofpride,party,orresentmenttoespousethedoctrineofseparationandindependance;
Iamclearly,positively,andconscientiouslypersuadedthatitisthetrueinterestofthiscontinenttobeso;
thateverythingshortofTHATismerepatchwork,thatitcanaffordnolastingfelicity,——thatitisleavingtheswordtoourchildren,andshrinkingbackatatime,when,alittlemore,alittlefarther,wouldhaverenderedthiscontinentthegloryoftheearth。
AsBritainhathnotmanifestedtheleastinclinationtowardsacompromise,wemaybeassuredthatnotermscanbeobtainedworthytheacceptanceofthecontinent,oranywaysequaltotheexpenseofbloodandtreasurewehavebeenalreadyputto。
Theobject,contendedfor,oughtalwaystobearsomejustproportiontotheexpense。TheremovalofNorth,orthewholedetestablejunto,isamatterunworthythemillionswehaveexpended。Atemporarystoppageoftrade,wasaninconvenience,whichwouldhavesufficientlybalancedtherepealofalltheactscomplainedof,hadsuchrepealsbeenobtained;
hutifthewholecontinentmusttakeuparms,ifeverymanmustbeasoldier,itisscarcelyworthourwhiletofightagainstacontemptibleministryonly。
Dearly,dearly,dowepayfortherepealoftheacts,ifthatisallwefightfor;forinajustestimation,itisasgreatafollytopayaBunker-hillpriceforlaw,asforland。AsIhavealwaysconsideredtheindependancyofthiscontinent,asanevent,whichsoonerorlatermustarrive,sofromthelaterapidprogressofthecontinenttomaturity,theeventcouldnotbefaroff。Wherefore,onthebreakingoutofhostilities,itwasnotworthwhiletohavedisputedamatter,whichtimewouldhavefinallyredressed,unlesswemeanttobeinearnest;otherwise,itislikewastinganestateonasuitatlaw,toregulatethetrespassesofatenant,whoseleaseisjustexpiring。Nomanwasawarmerwisherforreconciliationthanmyself,beforethefatalnineteenthofApril1775,butthemomenttheeventofthatdaywasmadeknown,Irejectedthehardened,sullentemperedPharaohofEnglandforever;anddisdainthewretch,thatwiththepretendedtitleofFATHEROFHISPEOPLEcanunfeelinglyhearoftheirslaughter,andcomposedlysleepwiththeirblooduponhissoul。
Butadmittingthatmatterswerenowmadeup,whatwouldbetheevent?
Ianswer,theruinofthecontinent。Andthatforseveralreasons。
FIRST。Thepowersofgoverningstillremaininginthehandsoftheking,hewillhaveanegativeoverthewholelegislationofthiscontinent。Andashehathshewnhimselfsuchaninveterateenemytoliberty。anddiscoveredsuchathirstforarbitrarypower;ishe,orishenot,apropermantosaytothesecolonies,\"YOUSHALLMAKENOLAWSBUTWHATIPLEASE。’
AndisthereanyinhabitantinAmericasoignorantasnottoknow,thataccordingtowhatiscalledthePRESENTCONSTITUTION,thatthiscontinentcanmakenolawsbutwhatthekinggivesleaveto;
andisthereanymansounwise,asnottosee,that(consideringwhathashappened)hewillsuffernolawtobemadehere,butsuchassuitHISpurpose。WemaybeaseffectuallyenslavedbythewantoflawsinAmerica,asbysubmittingtolawsmadeforusinEngland。
Aftermattersaremadeup(asitiscalled)cantherebeanydoubt,butthewholepowerofthecrownwillbeexerted,tokeepthiscontinentaslowandhumbleaspossible?Insteadofgoingforwardweshallgobackward,orbeperpetuallyquarrellingorridiculouslypetitioning。
——WEarealreadygreaterthanthekingwishesustobe,andwillhenothereafterendeavourtomakeusless?Tobringthemattertoonepoint。
Isthepowerwhoisjealousofourprosperity,aproperpowertogovernus?
WhoeversaysNotothisquestion,isanINDEPENDANT,forindependancymeansnomore,than,whetherweshallmakeourownlaws,orwhethertheking,thegreatestenemythiscontinenthath,orcanhave,shalltellus\"THERESHALLBENOLAWSBUTSUCHASILIKE。\"
ButthekingyouwillsayhasanegativeinEngland;thepeopletherecanmakenolawswithouthisconsent。Inpointofrightandgoodorder,thereissomethingveryridiculous,thatayouthoftwenty-one(whichhathoftenhappened)shallsaytoseveralmillionsofpeople,olderandwiserthanhimself,Iforbidthisorthatactofyourstobelaw。
ButinthisplaceIdeclinethissortofreply,thoughIwillneverceasetoexposetheabsurdityofit,andonlyanswer,thatEnglandbeingtheKing’sresidence,andAmericanotso,makesquiteanothercase。Theking’snegativeHEREistentimesmoredangerousandfatalthanitcanbeinEngland,forTHEREhewillscarcelyrefusehisconsenttoabillforputtingEnglandintoasstrongastateofdefenseaspossible,andinAmericahewouldneversuffersuchabilltobepassed。
AmericaisonlyasecondaryobjectinthesystemofBritishpolitics,EnglandconsultsthegoodofTHIScountry,nofartherthanitanswersherOWNpurpose。Wherefore,herowninterestleadshertosuppressthegrowthofOURSineverycasewhichdothnotpromoteheradvantage,orintheleastinterfereswithit。Aprettystateweshouldsoonbeinundersuchasecondhandgovernment,consideringwhathashappened!
Mendonotchangefromenemiestofriendsbythealterationofaname:
Andinordertoshewthatreconciliationnowisadangerousdoctrine,Iaffirm,THATITWOULDBEPOLICYINTHEKINGATTHISTIME,TOREPEAL
THEACTSFORTHESAKEOFREINSTATINGHIMSELFINTHEGOVERNMENT
OFTHEPROVINCES;inorder,thatHEMAYACCOMPLISHBYCRAFTANDSUBTLETY,INTHELONGRUN,WHATHECANNOTDOBYFORCEANDVIOLENCEINTHESHORTONE。
Reconciliationandruinarenearlyrelated。
SECONDLY。Thataseventhebestterms,whichwecanexpecttoobtain,canamounttonomorethanatemporaryexpedient,orakindofgovernmentbyguardianship,whichcanlastnolongerthantillthecoloniescomeofage,sothegeneralfaceandstateofthings,intheinterim,willbeunsettledandunpromising。Emigrantsofpropertywillnotchoosetocometoacountrywhoseformofgovernmenthangsbutbyathread,andwhoiseverydaytotteringonthebrinkofcommotionanddisturbance;andnumbersofthepresentinhabitantswouldlayholdoftheinterval,todispenseoftheireffects,andquitthecontinent。
Butthemostpowerfulofallarguments,is,thatnothingbutindependence,i。e。acontinentalformofgovernment,cankeepthepeaceofthecontinentandpreserveitinviolatefromcivilwars。IdreadtheeventofareconciliationwithBritainnow,asitismorethanprobable,thatitwillbefollowedbyarevoltsomewhereorother,theconsequencesofwhichmaybefarmorefatalthanallthemaliceofBritain。
ThousandsarealreadyruinedbyBritishbarbarity;(thousandsmorewillprobablysufferthesamefate)Thosemenhaveotherfeelingsthanuswhohavenothingsuffered。AlltheyNOWpossessisliberty,whattheybeforeenjoyedissacrificedtoitsservice,andhavingnothingmoretolose,theydisdainsubmission。Besides,thegeneraltemperofthecolonies,towardsaBritishgovernment,willbelikethatofayouth,whoisnearlyoutofhistime;theywillcareverylittleabouther。
Andagovernmentwhichcannotpreservethepeace,isnogovernmentatall,andinthatcasewepayourmoneyfornothing;andpraywhatisitthatBritaincando,whosepowerwillhewhollyonpaper。shouldaciviltumultbreakouttheverydayafterreconciliation!Ihaveheardsomemensay,manyofwhomIbelievespokewithoutthinking,thattheydreadedanindependence,fearingthatitwouldproducecivilwars。
Itisbutseldomthatourfirstthoughtsaretrulycorrect,andthatisthecasehere;fortherearetentimesmoretodreadfromapatchedupconnectionthanfromindependence。Imakethesuffererscasemyown,andIprotest,thatwereIdrivenfromhouseandhome,mypropertydestroyed,andmycircumstancesruined,thatasman,sensibleofinjuries,Icouldneverrelishthedoctrineofreconciliation,orconsidermyselfboundthereby。
Thecolonieshavemanifestedsuchaspiritofgoodorderandobediencetocontinentalgovernment,asissufficienttomakeeveryreasonablepersoneasyandhappyonthathead。Nomancanassigntheleastpretenceforhisfears,onanyothergrounds,thansuchasaretrulychildishandridiculous,viz。thatonecolonywillbestrivingforsuperiorityoveranother。
Wheretherearenodistinctionstherecanbenosuperiority,perfectequalityaffordsnotemptation。TherepublicsofEuropeareall(andwemaysayalways)inpeace。HollandandSwitzerlandarewithoutwars,foreignordomestic:Monarchicalgovernments,itistrue,areneverlongatrest;thecrownitselfisatemptationtoenterprisingruffiansatHOME;andthatdegreeofprideandinsolenceeverattendantonregalauthority,swellsintoarupturewithforeignpowers,ininstances,wherearepublicangovernment,bybeingformedonmorenaturalprinciples,wouldnegotiatethemistake。
Ifthereisanytruecauseoffearrespectingindependence,itisbecausenoplanisyetlaiddown。Mendonotseetheirwayout——
Wherefore,asanopeningintothatbusiness,Iofferthefollowinghints;
atthesametimemodestlyaffirming,thatIhavenootheropinionofthemmyself,thanthattheymaybethemeansofgivingrisetosomethingbetter。Couldthestragglingthoughtsofindividualsbecollected,theywouldfrequentlyformmaterialsforwiseandablementoimproveintousefulmatter。
LETtheassembliesbeannual,withaPresidentonly。
Therepresentationmoreequal。Theirbusinesswhollydomestic,andsubjecttotheauthorityofaContinentalCongress。
Leteachcolonybedividedintosix,eight,orten,convenientdistricts,eachdistricttosendapropernumberofdelegatestoCongress,sothateachcolonysendatleastthirty。ThewholenumberinCongresswillbeatleast390。EachCongresstositandtochooseapresidentbythefollowingmethod。Whenthedelegatesaremet,letacolonybetakenfromthewholethirteencoloniesbylot,afterwhich,letthewholeCongresschoose(byballot)apresidentfromoutofthedelegatesofthatprovince。
InthenextCongress,letacolonybetakenbylotfromtwelveonly,omittingthatcolonyfromwhichthepresidentwastakenintheformerCongress,andsoproceedingontillthewholethirteenshallhavehadtheirproperrotation。
AndinorderthatnothingmaypassintoalawbutwhatissatisfactorilyjustnotlessthanthreefifthsoftheCongresstobecalledamajority——
Hethatwillpromotediscord,underagovernmentsoequallyformedasthis,wouldhavejoinedLuciferinhisrevolt。
Butasthereisapeculiardelicacy,fromwhom,orinwhatmanner,thisbusinessmustfirstarise,andasitseemsmostagreeableandconsistent,thatitshouldcomefromsomeintermediatebodybetweenthegovernedandthegovernors,thatis,betweentheCongressandthepeople。letaCONTINENTALCONFERENCEbeheld,inthefollowingmanner,andforthefollowingpurpose。
Acommitteeoftwenty-sixmembersofCongress,viz。twoforeachcolony。
TwoMembersfromeachHouseofAssembly,orProvincialConvention;
andfiverepresentativesofthepeopleatlarge,tobechoseninthecapitalcityortownofeachprovince,forandinbehalfofthewholeprovince,byasmanyqualifiedvotersasshallthinkpropertoattendfromallpartsoftheprovinceforthatpurpose;or,ifmoreconvenient,therepresentativesmaybechosenintwoorthreeofthemostpopulouspartsthereof。Inthisconference,thusassembled,willbeunited,thetwograndprinciplesofbusinessKNOWLEDGEandPOWER。ThemembersofCongress,Assemblies,orConventions,byhavinghadexperienceinnationalconcerns,willbeableandusefulcounsellors,andthewhole,beingempoweredbythepeople,willhaveatrulylegalauthority。
Theconferringmembersbeingmet,lettheirbusinessbetoframeaCONTINENTALCHARTER,OrCharteroftheUnitedColonies;
(answeringtowhatiscalledtheMagnaCartaofEngland)fixingthenumberandmannerofchoosingmembersofCongress,membersofAssembly,withtheirdateofsitting,anddrawingthelineofbusinessandjurisdictionbetweenthem:(Alwaysremembering,thatourstrengthiscontinental,notprovincial:)Securingfreedomandpropertytoallmen,andaboveallthings,thefreeexerciseofreligion,accordingtothedictatesofconscience;withsuchothermatterasisnecessaryforachartertocontain。Immediatelyafterwhich,thesaidConferencetodissolve,andthebodieswhichshallbechosencomformabletothesaidcharter,tobethelegislatorsandgovernorsofthiscontinentforthetimebeing:
WhosepeaceandhappinessmayGodpreserve,Amen。
Shouldanybodyofmenbehereafterdelegatedforthisorsomesimilarpurpose,IofferthemthefollowingextractsorthatwiseobserverongovernmentsDRAGONETTI。
\"Thescience\"sayshe\"ofthepoliticianconsistsinfixingthetruepointofhappinessandfreedom。
Thosemenwoulddeservethegratitudeofages,whoshoulddiscoveramodeofgovernmentthatcontainedthegreatestsumofindividualhappiness,withtheleastnationalexpense。[Dragonettionvirtueandrewards]
Butwhere,sayssome,istheKingofAmerica?I’lltellyou。
Friend,hereignsabove,anddothnotmakehavocofmankindliketheRoyalBruteofBritain。Yetthatwemaynotappeartobedefectiveeveninearthlyhonors,letadaybesolemnlysetapartforproclaimingthecharter;letitbebroughtforthplacedonthedivinelaw,thewordofGod;letacrownbeplacedthereon,bywhichtheworldmayknow,thatsofarweapproveofmonarchy,thatinAmericaTHELAWISKING。ForasinabsolutegovernmentstheKingislaw,soinfreecountriesthelawOUGHTtobeKing;
andthereoughttobenoother。Butlestanyilluseshouldafterwardsarise,letthecrownattheconclusionoftheceremony,bedemolished,andscatteredamongthepeoplewhoserightitis。
Agovernmentofourownisournaturalright:Andwhenamanseriouslyreactsontheprecariousnessofhumanaffairs,hewillbecomeconvinced,thatitisinfinitelywiserandsafer,toformaconstitutionofourowninacooldeliberatemanner,whilewehaveitinourpower,thantotrustsuchaninterestingeventtotimeandchance。
Ifweomititnow,some[ThomasAnellootherwiseMassanelloafishermanofNaples,whoafterspiritinguphiscountrymeninthepublicmarketplace,againsttheoppressionsoftheSpaniards,towhomtheplacewasthensubjectpromptedthemtorevolt,andinthespaceofadaybecameking。]Massanellomayhereafterarise,wholayingholdofpopulardisquietudes,maycollecttogetherthedesperateandthediscontented,andbyassumingtothemselvesthepowersofgovernment,maysweepawaythelibertiesofthecontinentlikeadeluge。ShouldthegovernmentofAmericareturnagainintothehandsofBritain,thetotteringsituationofthingswillbeatemptationforsomedesperateadventurertotryhisfortune;andinsuchacase,thatreliefcanBritaingive?
Ereshecouldhearthenews,thefatalbusinessmightbedone;
andourselvessufferinglikethewretchedBritonsundertheoppressionoftheConqueror。Yethatopposeindependencenow,yeknownotwhatyedo;yeareopeningadoortoeternaltyranny,bykeepingvacanttheseatofgovernment。Therearethousands,andtensofthousands,whowouldthinkitglorioustoexpelfromthecontinentthatbarbarousandhellishpower,whichhathstirreduptheIndiansandNegroestodestroyus;
thecrueltyhathadoubleguilt,itisdealingbrutallybyus,andtreacherouslybythem。
Totalkoffriendshipwiththoseinwhomourreasonforbidsustohavefaith,andouraffectionswoundedthroughathousandporesinstructustodetest,ismadnessandfolly。Everydaywearsoutthelittleremainsofkindredbetweenusandthem,andcantherebeanyreasontohope,thatastherelationshipexpires,theaffectionwillincrease,orthatweshallagreebetter,whenwehavetentimesmoreandgreaterconcernstoquarreloverthanever?
Yethattellusofharmonyandreconciliation,canyerestoretousthetimethatispast?Canyegivetoprostitutionitsformerinnocence?
NeithercanyereconcileBritainandAmerica。Thelastcordnowisbroken,thepeopleofEnglandarepresentingaddressesagainstus。
Thereareinjurieswhichnaturecannotforgive;shewouldceasetobenatureifshedid。Aswellcantheloverforgivetheravisherofhismistress,asthecontinentforgivethemurdersofBritain。TheAlmightyhathimplantedinustheseunextinguishablefeelingsforgoodandwisepurposes。
Theyaretheguardiansofhisimageinourhearts。Theydistinguishusfromtheherdofcommonanimals。Thesocialcompactwoulddissolve,andjusticebeextirpatedtheearth,orhaveonlyacasualexistencewerewecalloustothetouchesofaffection。Therobber,andthemurderer,wouldoftenescapeunpunished,didnottheinjurieswhichourtemperssustain,provokeusintojustice。
Oyethatlovemankind!Yethatdareoppose,notonlythetyranny,butthetyrant,standforth!Everyspotoftheoldworldisoverrunwithoppression。Freedomhathbeenhuntedroundtheglobe。Asia,andAfrica,havelongexpelledher——Europeregardsherlikeastranger,andEnglandhathgivenherwarningtodepart。O!receivethefugitive,andprepareintimeanasylumformankind。
OFTHEPRESENT_ABILITY_OF_AMERICA_,WITHSOMEMISCELLANEOUS_REFLECTIONS_
Ihavenevermetwithaman,eitherinEnglandorAmerica,whohathnotconfessedhisopinionthataseparationbetweenthecountries,wouldtakeplaceonetimeorother:Andthereisnoinstance,inwhichwehaveshewnlessjudgement,thaninendeavouringtodescribe,whatwecalltheripenessorfitnessoftheContinentforindependence。
Asallmenallowthemeasure,andvaryonlyintheiropinionofthetime,letus,inordertoremovemistakes,takeageneralsurveyofthings,andendeavour,ifpossible,tofindouttheVERYtime。Butweneednotgofar,theinquiryceasesatonce,for,theTIMEHATHFOUNDUS。
Thegeneralconcurrence,thegloriousunionofallthingsprovethefact。
Itisnotinnumbers,butinunity,thatourgreatstrengthlies;
yetourpresentnumbersaresufficienttorepeltheforceofalltheworld。
TheContinenthath,atthistime,thelargestbodyofarmedanddisciplinedmenofanypowerunderHeaven;andisjustarrivedatthatpitchofstrength,inwhichnosinglecolonyisabletosupportitself,andthewhole,whenunited,canaccomplishthematter,andeithermore,or,lessthanthis,mightbefatalinitseffects。Ourlandforceisalreadysufficient,andastonavalaffairs,wecannotbeinsensible,thatBritainwouldneversufferanAmericanmanofwartobebuilt,whilethecontinentremainedinherhands。Wherefore,weshouldbenoforwarderanhundredyearshenceinthatbranch,thanwearenow;
butthetruthis,weshouldbelessso,becausethetimberofthecountryiseverydaydiminishing,andthat,whichwillremainatlast,willbefaroffanddifficulttoprocure。
Werethecontinentcrowdedwithinhabitants,hersufferingsunderthepresentcircumstanceswouldbeintolerable。Themoreseaporttownswehad,themoreshouldwehavebothtodefendandtolose。Ourpresentnumbersaresohappilyproportionedtoourwants,thatnomanneedbeidle。
Thediminutionoftradeaffordsanarmy,andthenecessitiesofanarmycreateanewtrade。
Debtswehavenone;andwhateverwemaycontractonthisaccountwillserveasagloriousmementoofourvirtue。Canwebutleaveposteritywithasettledformofgovernment,anindependentconstitutionofitsown,thepurchaseatanypricewillbecheap。Buttoexpendmillionsforthesakeofgettingafewvileactsrepealed,androutingthepresentministryonly,isunworthythecharge,andisusingposteritywiththeutmostcruelty;
becauseitisleavingthemthegreatworktodo,andadebtupontheirbacks,fromwhichtheyderivenoadvantage。Suchathoughtisunworthyofamanofhonor,andisthetruecharacteristicofanarrowheartandapeddlingpolitician。
Thedebtwemaycontractdothnotdeserveourregard,iftheworkbebutaccomplished。Nonationoughttobewithoutadebt。
Anationaldebtisanationalbond;andwhenitbearsnointerest,isinnocaseagrievance。Britainisoppressedwithadebtofupwardsofonehundredandfortymillionssterling,forwhichshepaysupwardsoffourmillionsinterest。Andasacompensationforherdebt,shehasalargenavy;Americaiswithoutadebt,andwithoutanavy;
yetforthetwentiethpartoftheEnglishnationaldebt,couldhaveanavyaslargeagain。ThenavyofEnglandisnotworth,atthistime,morethanthreemillionsandanhalfsterling。
Thefirstandsecondeditionsofthispamphletwerepublishedwithoutthefollowingcalculations,whicharenowgivenasaproofthattheaboveestimationofthenavyisjust。
[SeeEntic’snavalhistory,intro。page56。]
Thechargeofbuildingashipofeachrate,andfurnishingherwithmasts,yards,sailsandrigging,togetherwithaproportionofeightmonthsboatswain’sandcarpenter’sseastores,ascalculatedbyMr。Burchett,Secretarytothenavy。
[poundsSterling]
Forashipofa100guns-35,553
90——29,886
80——23,638
70——17,795
60——14,197
50——10,606
40——7,558
30——5,846
20——3,710
Andfromhenceitiseasytosumupthevalue,orcostrather,ofthewholeBritishnavy,whichintheyear1757,whenitwasatitsgreatestgloryconsistedofthefollowingshipsandguns:
Ships。Guns。Costofone。Costofall6-100-35,553-213,318
12-90-29,886-358,632
12-80-23,638-283,656
43-70-17,785-764,755
35-60-14,197-496,895
40-50-10,606-424,240
45-40-7,558-340,110
58-20-3,710-215,180
85Sloops,bombs,andfireships,one2,000170,000
withanother,_________
Cost3,266,786
Remainsforguns,_________233,214
_________
3,500,000
Nocountryontheglobeissohappilysituated,orsointernallycapableofraisingafleetasAmerica。Tar,timber,iron,andcordagearehernaturalproduce。Weneedgoabroadfornothing。WhereastheDutch,whomakelargeprofitsbyhiringouttheirshipsofwartotheSpaniardsandPortuguese,areobligedtoimportmostoftheirmaterialstheyuse。
Weoughttoviewthebuildingafleetasanarticleofcommerce,itbeingthenaturalmanufactoryofthiscountry。Itisthebestmoneywecanlayout。
Anavywhenfinishedisworthmorethanitcost。Andisthatnicepointinnationalpolicy,inwhichcommerceandprotectionareunited。Letusbuild;
ifwewantthemnot,wecansell;andbythatmeansreplaceourpapercurrencywithreadygoldandsilver。
Inpointofmanningafleet,peopleingeneralrunintogreaterrors;
itisnotnecessarythatonefourthpartshouldhesailors。
TheTerribleprivateer,CaptainDeath,stoodthehottestengagementofanyshiplastwar,yethadnottwentysailorsonboard,thoughhercomplementofmenwasupwardsoftwohundred。
Afewableandsocialsailorswillsooninstructasufficientnumberofactivelandmeninthecommonworkofaship。Wherefore,wenevercanbemorecapabletobeginonmaritimemattersthannow,whileourtimberisstanding,ourfisheriesblockedup,andoursailorsandshipwrightsoutofemploy。MenofwarofseventyandeightygunswerebuiltfortyyearsagoinNew-England,andwhynotthesamenow?Ship-buildingisAmerica’sgreatestpride,andinwhichshewillintimeexcelthewholeworld。
Thegreatempiresoftheeastaremostlyinland,andconsequentlyexcludedfromthepossibilityofrivallingher。
Africaisinastateofbarbarism;andnopowerinEuropehatheithersuchanextentofcoast,orsuchaninternalsupplyofmaterials。
Wherenaturehathgiventheone,shehaswithheldtheother;
toAmericaonlyhathshebeenliberalofboth。ThevastempireofRussiaisalmostshutoutfromthesea:wherefore,herboundlessforests,hertar,iron,andcordageareonlyarticlesofcommerce。
Inpointofsafety,oughtwetobewithoutafleet?Wearenotthelittlepeoplenow,whichweweresixtyyearsago;atthattimewemighthavetrustedourpropertyinthestreets,orfieldsrather;andsleptsecurelywithoutlocksorboltstoourdoorsorwindows。Thecasenowisaltered,andourmethodsofdefenseoughttoimprovewithourincreaseofproperty。Acommonpirate,twelvemonthsago,mighthavecomeuptheDelaware,andlaidthecityofPhiladelphiaunderinstantcontribution,forwhatsumhepleased;andthesamemighthavehappenedtootherplaces。
Nay,anydaringfellow,inabrigoffourteenorsixteengunsmighthaverobbedthewholecontinent,andcarriedoffhalfamillionofmoney。
Thesearecircumstanceswhichdemandourattention,andpointoutthenecessityofnavalprotection。
Some,perhaps,willsay,thatafterwehavemadeitupBritain,shewillprotectus。Canwebesounwiseastomean,thatsheshallkeepanavyinourharboursforthatpurpose?
Commonsensewilltellus,thatthepowerwhichhathendeavouredtosubdueus,isofallothersthemostimpropertodefendus。
Conquestmaybeeffectedunderthepretenceoffriendship;
andourselvesafteralongandbraveresistance,beatlastcheatedintoslavery。Andifhershipsarenottobeadmittedintoourharbours,Iwouldask,howisshetoprotectus?Anavythreeorfourthousandmilesoffcanbeoflittleuse,andonsuddenemergencies,noneatall。
Wherefore,ifwemusthereafterprotectourselves,whynotdoitforourselves?
TheEnglishlistofshipsofwar,islongandformidable,butnotatenthpartofthemareatanyonetimefitforservice,numbersofthemnotinbeing;yettheirnamesarepompouslycontinuedinthelist,fonlyaplankbeleftoftheship:andnotafifthpartofsuchasarefitforservice,canbesparedonanyonestationatonetime。
TheEastandWestIndies,Mediterranean,Africa,andotherpartsoverwhichBritainextendsherclaim,makelargedemandsuponhernavy。