Inoppositiontolabourandrentsinkindwefindagreatmanypaymentsinmoney。Someofthesearesaidinasmanywordstohavesteptintotheplaceoflabourservices;ofmowing,carrying,makinghedges,61*etc。Thesamemaybethecaseinregardtoproduce:barlicksilverispaidinsteadofbarley,fish-silverevidentlyinsteadoffish,malt-silverinsteadofmalt;acertainpaymentinsteadofsalt,andsoon。62*Butsometimestheoriginofthemoneyrentismoredifficulttoascertain。Wefind,forinstance,adutyonsheep,whichisalmostcertainlyanoriginalimpositionwhenitappearsasfald-silver。Evensothescythe-pennyfromeveryscythe,thebosing-silverfromeveryhorseandcart,thewood-penny,probablyfortheuseofwoodasfuel,mustberegardedasoriginaltaxesandnotquit-rentsorcommutation-rents。63*Pannageispaidinthesamewayfortheswinegrazinginthewoods。64*Ward-pennyappearsalsoinconnexionwithcattle,butwithsomespecialshadeofmeaningwhichitisdifficulttobringoutdefinitely;
thenameseemstopointtoprotection,andalsooccursinconnexionwithpolicearrangements。65*
ImustacknowledgethatinagoodmanycasesIhavebeenunabletofindasatisfactoryexplanationforvarioustermswhichoccurintherecordsforthediverspayments。Anattentivestudyoflocalusageswillprobablyleadtodefiniteconclusionsastomostofthem。66*Fromageneralpointofviewitisinterestingtonotice,thatwefindalreadyinourrecordssomeattemptstobringalltheperplexingvarietyofpaymentstoafewmaindesignations。Annualrentsare,ofcourse,reckonedoutundertheoneheadof’census。’Veryobviousreasonssuggestedtheadvisabilityofcomputingtheentiremoney-proceedyieldedbytheestate。67*Itsometimeshappensthatthegeneralsummadeupinthisway,fixedasitisataconstantamount,isusedalmostasanameforacomplexofland。68*Adivisionofrentsintooldandnewonesdoesnotrequireanyparticularexplanation。69*
Butseveralothersubdivisionsareworthnotice。Therentpaidfromthelandoftenappearsseparatelyaslandgafolorlandchere。
Itisnaturallyopposedtopaymentsthatfallonthepersonaspolltaxes。70*Theselastareconsideredguaranteedbytheasareturnforthepersonalprotectionlordtohissubjects。OfthecontrastbetweengafolasacustomaryrentandmalasapaymentincommutationIhavespokenalready,andIhaveonlytoaddnow,thatgildissometimesusedinthesamesenseasmal。71*
AnothertermindirectoppositiontogafolistheLatindonum。72*Itseemstoindicateaspecialpaymentimposedasakindofvoluntarycontributionontheentirevillage。Tobesure,therewasnotmuchfreewilltobeexercisedinthematter;allthedependentpeopleofthetownshiphadtopayaccordingtotheirmeans。73*Butthetaxmusthavebeenconsideredasasupplementaryoneinthesamesenseassupplementaryboon-work。
Itmayhavebeenoriginallyintendedinsomecasesasanequivalentforsomerightssurrenderedbythelord,asamalorgild,infact。74*Incloseconnexionwiththedonumwefindtheauxilium,75*alsoanextraordinarytaxpaidonceayear,anddistinguishedfromtheordinaryrent。Itappearsasadirectconsequenceofthepoliticalsubjectionofthetenantry。76*。Itis,infact,merelyanexpressionoftherighttotallage。Ourrecordsmentionitsometimesasapportionedaccordingtothenumberofcattleownedbythepeasant,butthisconcernsonlythemodeofimpositionofthedutyandhardlyitsorigin。77*AsI
havesaidalready,theauxiliumisineveryrespectlikethedonum。Oneverycharacteristictraitofbothtaxesis,thattheyarelaidprimarilyonthewholevillage,whichismadetopayacertainroundsumasabody。78*Theburdenisdividedafterwardsbetweentheseveralhouseholders,andthenumberofcattle,andmoreparticularlyofthebeastsofploughkeptontheholding,hasofcoursetobetakenintoaccountmorethananythingelse。Butthemanorialadministrationdoesnotmuchconcernitselfwiththesedetails:thetownshipisanswerableforthewholesum。
Itistobeaddedthatthepaymentissometimesactuallymentionedasapoliticaloneindirectconnexionwith’forinsec’
dutiestowardstheking。TheburdenswhichlayonthelandinconsequenceoftherequirementsofStateandChurchappearnotunfrequentlyinthedocuments。Amongthosethescutageandhidagearethemostimportant。ThefirstofthesetaxesissowellknownthatIneednotstoptodiscussit。Itmaybenoticedhoweverthatinrelationtothedependentpeoplescutageisnotcommonlyspokenof;thetaxwasleviedunderthisnamefromthebaronsandthearmedgentry,andwasmostlytransmittedbythesetothelowerstrataofsocietyundersomeothername,asanaidoratallage。HidageishistoricallyconnectedwiththeoldEnglishDanegeldsystem,andinsomecasesitsamountissetoutseparatelyfromotherpayments,andthetenantsofamanorhavetopayittothebailiffofthehundredandnottothesteward。A
smallerpaymentcalledward-pennyisboundupwithit,probablyasasubstituteforthedutyofkeepingwatchandward。79*Inthenorththehidageisreplacedbycornage,80*ataxwhichhasgivenrisetolearnedcontroversyanddoubt;itlookslikeanassessmentaccordingtothenumberofhornsofcattle,pronumeroaveriorum,asourLatinextentswouldsay。TheChurchhasalsoanancientclaimonthehelpofthefaithful;thechurchscotofSaxontimesoftenoccursinthefeudalageunderthenameofchurisetorcheriset。81*Itismostlypaidinkind,butmaybefoundoccasionallyasamoney-rent。
Asurveyofthechiefaspectsassumedbytheworkandthepaymentsofthedependentpeoplewasabsolutelynecessary,inordertoenableustounderstandthedescriptionsofruralarrangementswhichformthemostinstructivepartoftheso-calledextents。ButeverysurveyoftermsanddistinctionsevenifitweremuchmoredetailedthantheoneIamabletopresent,willgiveonlyaveryimperfectideaoftheobligationsactuallylaidonthepeasantry。Itmustneedstakeupthedifferentspeciesonebyoneandconsiderthemseparately,whereasinrealitytheyweremeanttofittogetherintoawhole。
Ontheotherhanditmaycreateafalseimpressionbyenumeratinginsystematicorderfactswhichbelongedtodifferentlocalitiesandperhapstodifferentepochs。Tokeepclearofthesedangerswehavetoconsiderthedeviationsofpracticalarrangementsfromtheruleslaiddowninthebooksandtheusualcombinationsoftheelementsdescribed。
Whenonereadsthecarefulnoticesinthecartulariesastothenumberofdaysandtheparticularoccasionswhenworkhastobeperformedforthelord,asimplequestionissuggestedbytheminutenessofdetail。Whathappenedwhenthisverydefinitearrangementcameintocollisionwithsomeotherequallyexactingorder?Oneofthethreedaysofweek-workmight,forinstance,fallonagreatfeast;orelsetheweathermightbetoobadforout-of-doorswork。Whowastosufferortogainbysuchcasualties?Thequestionisnotauselessone。Themanorialrecordsraiseitoccasionally,andtheirwaysofsettlingitarenotalwaysthesame。Wefindthatinsomecasesthelordtriedtogetridoftheinconveniencesoccasionedbysuchevents,Oratleasttothrowonepartoftheburdenbackonthedependentpopulation;inBarling,forinstance,amanorofSt。Paul’s,London,82*oftwofeastsoccurringinoneweekandevenintwoconsecutiveweeks,oneprofitstothevillainsandtheothertothelord;thatistosay,thelabourerescapesoneday’sworkaltogether。Butthegeneralcourseseemstohavebeentoliberatethepeasantsfromworkbothonoccasionofafestivalandiftheweatherwasexceptionallyinclement。83*Bothfactsarenotwithoutimportance:itmustberememberedthatthenumberofChurchfestivalswasaveryconsiderableoneinthosedays。
Again,althoughthestewardswerenotlikelytobeverysentimentalastobadweather,theusualtestofcoldincaseofploughingseemstohavebeenthehardnessofthesoil——acertainpercentageoffreedaysmusthaveoccurredduringthewinteratleast。Andwhatisevenmoretobeconsidered——whenthemenwereverystrictlykepttotheirweek-workunderunfavourablecircumstances,thelandlordmusthavegainedverylittlealthoughtheworkingpeoplesufferedmuch。Thereadermayeasilyfancytheeffectsofwhatmusthavebeenaverycommonoccurrence,whenthevillagehouseholderssentouttheirploughsonheavyclayintorrentsofrain。Thesystemofcustomaryworkoncertaindayswasespeciallyclumsyinsuchrespects,anditisworthnoticethatinharvest-timethelandlordsrelychieflyonboon-days。Thesewerenotirrevocablyfixed,andcouldbeshiftedaccordingtothestateoftheweather。Stilltheweek-workwassoimportantaniteminthegeneralarrangementoflabour-servicesthattheinconveniencesdescribedmusthaveactedpowerfullyinfavourofcommutation。
Ofcourse,thepassagefromonesystemtotheother,howeverdesirableforthepartiesconcerned,wasnottobeeffectedeasilyandatonce:aconsiderableamountofcapitalinthehandsofthepeasantrywasrequiredtomakeitpossible,andanothernecessaryrequirementwasasufficientcirculationofmoney。
Whilethesewerewantingthepeoplehadtoabidebytheoldlaboursystem。Thefactswehavebeendiscussinggiveindirectproofthattherewasnotmuchroomforarbitrarychangesinthissystem。Everythingseemsruledandsettledforever。Itmayhappen,ofcourse,thatnotwithstandingthesupposedequalitybetweentheeconomicstrengthofthe,differentholdings,sometenantsareunabletofulfilthedutieswhichtheircompanionsperform。84*Asitwasnoticedbefore,thesharescouldnotbemadetocorrespondabsolutelytoeachother,andthedistributionofworkandpaymentsaccordingtoadefinitepatternwasoftenonlyapproximate。85*Again,thelordhadsomelatitudeinselectingoneortheotherkindofservicetobeperformedbyhismen。86*But,speakinggenerally,thesettlementofdutieswasaveryconstantone,andmanorialdocumentstestifythateveryattemptbythelordtodictateachangewasmetbyemphaticprotestsonthepartofthepeasantry。87*Thetenacityofcustommaybegatheredfromthefactthatwhenwechancetopossesstwosetsofextentsfollowingeachotherafteraveryconsiderablelapseoftime,therendersinkindandthelabour-servicesremainunmodifiedinthemain。88*Onehastoguardespeciallyagainsttheassumptionthatsuchexpressionsas’todowhateverheisbid’or’whateverthelordcommands’implyacompleteservilityofthetenantandunrestrictedpoweronthepartofthelordtoexploithissubordinateaccordingtohispleasure。Suchexpressionshavebeenusedasatestofthedegreeofsubjectionofthevillainsatdifferentepochs;ithasbeencontended,thattheearlierourevidenceis,themorecompletethelord’sswayappearstobe。89*Theexpressionsquotedabovemayseematfirstglancetocountenancetheidea,butanattentiveandextendedstudyofthedocumentswilleasilyshowthat,saveinexceptionalcases,theearlierrecordsarebynomeansharderintheirtreatmentofthepeasantrythanthelater。
Theeleventhcenturyis,ifanything,morefavourabletothesubjectedclassasregardstheimpositionoflabour-servicesthanthethirteenth,andweshallseeby-and-bythattheobservationappliesevenmoretoSaxontimes。Inthelightofsuchageneralcomparison,wehavetoexplaintheabove-mentionedphrasesinadifferentway。’Whateverheisbid’appliestothequalityandnottothequantityofthework。90*Itdoesnotmeanthatthestewardhasarighttoorderthepeasantaboutlikeaslave,totearhimatpleasurefromhisownwork,andtoincreasehisburdenwheneverhelikes。Itmeanssimplythatsuchandsuchavirgaterorcotterhastoappearinpersonorbyproxytoperformhisweekworkofthreedays,ortwodays,orfourdays,accordingtothecase,andthatitisnotsettledbeforehandwhatkindofworkheistoperform。Hemayhavetoplough,ortocarry,ortodigtrenches,ortodoanythingelse,accordingtothebiddingofthesteward。Asimilarinstanceofuncertaintymaybefoundintheexpression’withoutmeasure’91*whichsometimesoccursinextents。Itwouldbepreposteroustoconstrueitasanindicationofworktobeimposedatpleasure。Itismerelyaphraseusedtosuitthecasewhentheworkhadtobedonebythedayandnotbyasetquantity;if,forinstance,amanhadtoploughsomanytimesandthenumberofacrestobeploughedwasnotspecified。