Translator—HenryReeve
BookOne
IntroductionSpecialIntroductionByHon。JohnT。MorganIntheelevenyearsthatseparatedtheDeclarationoftheIndependenceoftheUnitedStatesfromthecompletionofthatactintheordinationofourwrittenConstitution,thegreatmindsofAmericawerebentuponthestudyoftheprinciplesofgovernmentthatwereessentialtothepreservationofthelibertieswhichhadbeenwonatgreatcostandwithheroiclaborsandsacrifices。
TheirstudieswereconductedinviewoftheimperfectionsthatexperiencehaddevelopedinthegovernmentoftheConfederation,andtheywere,therefore,practicalandthorough。
WhentheConstitutionwasthusperfectedandestablished,anewformofgovernmentwascreated,butitwasneitherspeculativenorexperimentalastotheprinciplesonwhichitwasbased。Iftheyweretrueprinciples,astheywere,thegovernmentfoundeduponthemwasdestinedtoalifeandaninfluencethatwouldcontinuewhilethelibertiesitwasintendedtopreserveshouldbevaluedbythehumanfamily。Thoselibertieshadbeenwrungfromreluctantmonarchsinmanycontests,inmanycountries,andweregroupedintocreedsandestablishedinordinancessealedwithblood,inmanygreatstrugglesofthepeople。Theywerenotnewtothepeople。Theywereconsecratedtheories,butnogovernmenthadbeenpreviouslyestablishedforthegreatpurposeoftheirpreservationandenforcement。Thatwhichwasexperimentalinourplanofgovernmentwasthequestionwhetherdemocraticrulecouldbesoorganizedandconductedthatitwouldnotdegenerateintolicenseandresultinthetyrannyofabsolutism,withoutsavingtothepeoplethepowersooftenfoundnecessaryofrepressingordestroyingtheirenemy,whenhewasfoundinthepersonofasingledespot。
When,in1831,AlexisdeTocquevillecametostudyDemocracyinAmerica,thetrialofnearlyahalf—centuryoftheworkingofoursystemhadbeenmade,andithadbeenproved,bymanycrucialtests,tobeagovernmentof\"libertyregulatedbylaw,\"withsuchresultsinthedevelopmentofstrength,inpopulation,wealth,andmilitaryandcommercialpower,asnoagehadeverwitnessed。
[SeeAlexisDeTocqueville]
DeTocquevillehadaspecialinquirytoprosecute,inhisvisittoAmerica,inwhichhisgenerousandfaithfulsoulandthepowersofhisgreatintellectwereengagedinthepatrioticefforttosecuretothepeopleofFrancetheblessingsthatDemocracyinAmericahadordainedandestablishedthroughoutnearlytheentireWesternHemisphere。HehadreadthestoryoftheFrenchRevolution,muchofwhichhadbeenrecentlywritteninthebloodofmenandwomenofgreatdistinctionwhowerehisprogenitors;andhadwitnessedtheagitationsandterrorsoftheRestorationandoftheSecondRepublic,fruitfulincrimeandsacrifice,andbarrenofanygoodtomankind。
HehadjustwitnessedthespreadofrepublicangovernmentthroughallthevastcontinentalpossessionsofSpaininAmerica,andthelossofhergreatcolonies。Hehadseenthattheserevolutionswereaccomplishedalmostwithoutthesheddingofblood,andhewasfilledwithanxietytolearnthecausesthathadplacedrepublicangovernment,inFrance,insuchcontrastwithDemocracyinAmerica。
DeTocquevillewasscarcelythirtyyearsoldwhenhebeganhisstudiesofDemocracyinAmerica。Itwasaboldeffortforonewhohadnospecialtrainingingovernment,orinthestudyofpoliticaleconomy,buthehadtheexampleofLafayetteinestablishingthemilitaryfoundationoftheseliberties,andofWashington,Jefferson,Madison,andHamilton,allofwhomwereyoungmen,inbuildingupontheIndependenceoftheUnitedStatesthatwisestandbestplanofgeneralgovernmentthatwaseverdevisedforafreepeople。
HefoundthattheAmericanpeople,throughtheirchosenrepresentativeswhowereinstructedbytheirwisdomandexperienceandweresupportedbytheirvirtues—cultivated,purifiedandennobledbyself—relianceandtheloveofGod—hadmatured,intheexcellentwisdomoftheircounsels,anewplanofgovernment,whichembracedeverysecurityfortheirlibertiesandequalrightsandprivilegestoallinthepursuitofhappiness。
Hecameasanhonestandimpartialstudentandhisgreatcommentary,likethoseofPaul,waswrittenforthebenefitofallnationsandpeopleandinvindicationoftruthsthatwillstandfortheirdeliverancefrommonarchicalrule,whiletimeshalllast。
AFrencharistocratofthepureststrainofbloodandofthemosthonorablelineage,whosefamilyinfluencewascovetedbycrownedheads;whohadnoquarrelwiththerulersofthenation,andwassecureagainstwantbyhisinheritedestates;wasmovedbytheagitationsthatcompelledFrancetoattempttograspsuddenlythelibertiesandhappinesswehadgainedinourrevolutionand,byhisdevoutloveofFrance,tosearchoutandsubjecttothetestofreasonthebasicprinciplesoffreegovernmentthathadbeenembodiedinourConstitution。ThiswasthemissionofDeTocqueville,andnomissionwasevermorehonorablyorjustlyconducted,orconcludedwithgreatereclat,orbetterresultsforthewelfareofmankind。
Hisresearcheswerelogicalandexhaustive。Theyincludedeveryphaseofeveryquestionthatthenseemedtobeappositetothegreatinquiryhewasmaking。
Thejudgmentofallwhohavestudiedhiscommentariesseemstohavebeenunanimous,thathistalentsandlearningwerefullyequaltohistask。Hebeganwiththephysicalgeographyofthiscountry,andexaminedthecharacteristicsofthepeople,ofallracesandconditions,theirsocialandreligioussentiments,theireducationandtastes;theirindustries,theircommerce,theirlocalgovernments,theirpassionsandprejudices,andtheirethicsandliterature;leavingnothingunnoticedthatmightaffordanargumenttoprovethatourplanandformofgovernmentwasorwasnotadaptedespeciallytoapeculiarpeople,orthatitwouldbeimpracticableinanydifferentcountry,oramonganydifferentpeople。
TheprideandcomfortthattheAmericanpeopleenjoyinthegreatcommentariesofDeTocquevillearefarremovedfromtheselfishadulationthatcomesfromagreatandsingularsuccess。
Itistheconsciousnessofvictoryoverafalsetheoryofgovernmentwhichhasafflictedmankindformanyages,thatgivesjoytothetrueAmerican,asitdidtoDeTocquevilleinhisgreattriumph。
WhenDeTocquevillewrote,wehadlivedlessthanfiftyyearsunderourConstitution。Inthattimenogreatnationalcommotionhadoccurredthattesteditsstrength,oritspowerofresistancetointernalstrife,suchashadconvertedhisbelovedFranceintofieldsofslaughtertornbytempestsofwrath。
Hehadastrongconvictionthatnogovernmentcouldbeordainedthatcouldresisttheseinternalforces,when,theyaredirectedtoitsdestructionbybadmen,orunreasoningmobs,andmanythenbelieved,assomeyetbelieve,thatourgovernmentisunequaltosuchpressure,whentheassaultisthoroughlydesperate。
HadDeTocquevillelivedtoexaminethehistoryoftheUnitedStatesfrom1860to1870,hismisgivingsastothispowerofself—preservationwould,probably,havebeenclearedoff。Hewouldhaveseenthat,attheendofthemostdestructivecivilwarthateveroccurred,whenanimositiesofthebitterestsorthadbanishedallgoodfeelingfromtheheartsofourpeople,theStatesoftheAmericanUnion,stillincompleteorganizationandequippedwithalltheirofficialentourage,alignedthemselvesintheirplacesandtookupthepowersanddutiesoflocalgovernmentinperfectorderandwithoutembarrassment。Thiswouldhavedispelledhisapprehensions,ifhehadany,aboutthepoweroftheUnitedStatestowithstandtheseverestshocksofcivilwar。Couldhehavetracedthefurthercourseofeventsuntiltheyopentheportalsofthetwentiethcentury,hewouldhavecastawayhisfearsofourabilitytorestorepeace,order,andprosperity,inthefaceofanydifficulties,andwouldhaverejoicedtofindintheConstitutionoftheUnitedStatestheremedythatisprovidedforthehealingofthenation。
DeTocquevilleexamined,withthecarethatisworthytheimportanceofthesubject,thenatureandvalueofthesystemof\"localself—government,\"aswestylethismostimportantfeatureofourplan,and(ashasoftenhappened)whenthisoranysubjecthasbecomeamatterofanxiousconcern,histreatmentofthequestionsisfoundtohavebeenmasterlyandhispreconceptionsalmostprophetic。
Wearefrequentlyindebtedtohimforableexpositionsandtruedoctrinesrelatingtosubjectsthathaveslumberedinthemindsofthepeopleuntiltheyweresuddenlyforcedonourattentionbyunexpectedevents。
Inhisintroductorychapter,M。DeTocquevillesays:
\"AmongstthenovelobjectsthatattractedmyattentionduringmystayintheUnitedStates,nothingstruckmemoreforciblythanthegeneralequalityofconditions。\"Hereferred,doubtless,tosocialandpoliticalconditionsamongthepeopleofthewhiterace,whoaredescribedas\"We,thepeople,\"intheopeningsentenceoftheConstitution。ThelastthreeamendmentsoftheConstitutionhavesochangedthis,thatthosewhowerethennegroslavesareclothedwiththerightsofcitizenship,includingtherightofsuffrage。Thiswasapoliticalpartymovement,intendedtoberadicalandrevolutionary,butitwill,ultimately,reactbecauseithasnotthesanctionofpublicopinion。
IfM。DeTocquevillecouldnowsearchforalawthatwouldnegativethisprovisioninitseffectuponsocialequality,hewouldfailtofindit。Buthewouldfinditintheunwrittenlawofthenaturalaversionoftheraces。Hewouldfinditinpublicopinion,whichisthevitalforceineverylawinafreegovernment。ThisisasubjectthatourConstitutionfailedtoregulate,becauseitwasnotcontemplatedbyitsauthors。Itisaquestionthatwillsettleitself,withoutseriousdifficulty。
Theequalityinthesuffrage,thusguaranteedtothenegrorace,alone—foritwasnotintendedtoincludeothercoloredraces—
createsanewphaseofpoliticalconditionsthatM。DeTocquevillecouldnotforesee。Yet,inhiscommendationofthelocaltownandcountygovernments,heapplaudsandsustainsthatelementaryfeatureofourpoliticalorganizationwhich,intheend,willrenderharmlessthiswidedeparturefromtheoriginalplanandpurposeofAmericanDemocracy。\"LocalSelf—Government,\"
independentofgeneralcontrol,exceptforgeneralpurposes,istherootandoriginofallfreerepublicangovernment,andistheantagonistofallgreatpoliticalcombinationsthatthreatentherightsofminorities。Itisthepublicopinionformedintheindependentexpressionsoftownsandothersmallcivildistrictsthatistherealconservatismoffreegovernment。Itisequallytheenemyofthatdangerousevil,thecorruptionoftheballot—box,fromwhichitisnowapprehendedthatoneofourgreatesttroublesistoarise。
Thevoterisselected,underourlaws,becausehehascertainphysicalqualifications—ageandsex。Hisdisqualifications,whenanyareimposed,relatetohiseducationorproperty,andtothefactthathehasnotbeenconvictedofcrime。Ofallmenheshouldbemostdirectlyamenabletopublicopinion。
Thetestofmoralcharacteranddevotiontothedutiesofgoodcitizenshipareignoredinthelaws,becausethecourtscanseldomdealwithsuchquestionsinauniformandsatisfactoryway,underrulesthatapplyaliketoall。Thusthevoter,selectedbylawtorepresenthimselfandfourothernon—votingcitizens,isoftenapersonwhoisunfitforanypublicdutyortrust。Inatowngovernment,havingasmallareaofjurisdiction,wherethevoiceofthemajorityofqualifiedvotersisconclusive,thefitnessofthepersonwhoistoexercisethathighrepresentativeprivilegecanbedeterminedbyhisneighborsandacquaintances,and,inthegreatmajorityofcases,itwillbedecidedhonestlyandforthegoodofthecountry。Insuchmeetings,thereisalwaysaspiritofloyaltytotheState,becausethatisloyaltytothepeople,andareverenceforGodthatgivesweighttothedutiesandresponsibilitiesofcitizenship。
M。DeTocquevillefoundintheseminorlocaljurisdictionsthetheoreticalconservatismwhich,intheaggregate,isthesafestrelianceoftheState。Sowehavefoundthem,inpractice,thetrueprotectorsofthepurityoftheballot,withoutwhichallfreegovernmentwilldegenerateintoabsolutism。
InthefutureoftheRepublic,wemustencountermanydifficultanddangeroussituations,buttheprinciplesestablishedintheConstitutionandthecheckuponhastyorinconsideratelegislation,anduponexecutiveaction,andthesupremearbitramentofthecourts,willbefoundsufficientforthesafetyofpersonalrights,andforthesafetyofthegovernment,andthepropheticoutlookofM。DeTocquevillewillbefullyrealizedthroughtheinfluenceofDemocracyinAmerica。
EachsucceedinggenerationofAmericanswillfindinthepureandimpartialreflectionsofDeTocquevilleanewsourceofprideinourinstitutionsofgovernment,andsoundreasonsforpatrioticefforttopreservethemandtoinculcatetheirteachings。TheyhavemasteredthepowerofmonarchicalruleintheAmericanHemisphere,freeingreligionfromallshackles,andwillspread,byaquietbutresistlessinfluence,throughtheislandsoftheseastootherlands,wheretheappealsofDeTocquevilleforhumanrightsandlibertieshavealreadyinspiredthesoulsofthepeople。
Hon。JohnT。MorganSpecialIntroductionByHon。JohnJ。IngallsNearlytwo—thirdsofacenturyhaselapsedsincetheappearanceof\"DemocracyinAmerica,\"byAlexisCharlesHenriClereldeTocqueville,aFrenchnobleman,bornatParis,July29,1805。
Bredtothelaw,heexhibitedanearlypredilectionforphilosophyandpoliticaleconomy,andattwenty—twowasappointedjudge—auditoratthetribunalofVersailles。
In1831,commissionedostensiblytoinvestigatethepenitentiarysystemoftheUnitedStates,hevisitedthiscountry,withhisfriend,GustavedeBeaumont,travellingextensivelythroughthosepartsoftheRepublicthensubduedtosettlement,studyingthemethodsoflocal,State,andnationaladministration,andobservingthemannersandhabits,thedailylife,thebusiness,theindustriesandoccupationsofthepeople。
\"DemocracyinAmerica,\"thefirstoffourvolumesupon\"AmericanInstitutionsandtheirInfluence,\"waspublishedin1835。ItwasreceivedatoncebythescholarsandthinkersofEuropeasaprofound,impartial,andentertainingexpositionoftheprinciplesofpopular,representativeself—government。
Napoleon,\"Themightysomnambulistofavanisheddream,\"hadabolishedfeudalismandabsolutism,mademonarchsanddynastiesobsolete,andsubstitutedforthedivinerightofkingsthesovereigntyofthepeople。
Althoughbybirthandsympathiesanaristocrat,M。deTocquevillesawthatthereignoftraditionandprivilegeatlastwasended。Heperceivedthatcivilization,aftermanybloodycenturies,hadenteredanewepoch。Hebeheld,anddeplored,theexcessesthathadattendedthegenesisofthedemocraticspiritinFrance,andwhilehelovedliberty,hedetestedthecrimesthathadbeencommittedinitsname。Belongingneithertotheclasswhichregardedthesocialrevolutionasaninnovationtoberesisted,nortothatwhichconsideredpoliticalequalitytheuniversalpanaceafortheevilsofhumanity,heresolvedbypersonalobservationoftheresultsofdemocracyintheNewWorldtoascertainitsnaturalconsequences,andtolearnwhatthenationsofEuropehadtohopeorfearfromitsfinalsupremacy。
Thatayouthoftwenty—sixshouldentertainadesignsobroadandboldimpliessingularintellectualintrepidity。Hehadneithermodelnorprecedent。Thevastnessandnoveltyoftheundertakingincreaseadmirationfortheremarkableabilitywithwhichthetaskwasperformed。
Wereliteraryexcellencethesoleclaimof\"DemocracyinAmerica\"todistinction,thesplendorofitscompositionalonewouldentitleittohighplaceamongthemasterpiecesofthecentury。Thefirstchapter,upontheexteriorformofNorthAmerica,asthetheatreuponwhichthegreatdramaistobeenacted,forgraphicandpicturesquedescriptionofthephysicalcharacteristicsofthecontinentisnotsurpassedinliterature:
noristhereanysubdivisionoftheworkinwhichtheseverestphilosophyisnotinvestedwiththegraceofpoetry,andthedrieststatisticswiththecharmofromance。WesternemigrationseemedcommonplaceandprosaictillM。deTocquevillesaid,\"ThisgradualandcontinuousprogressoftheEuropeanracetowardtheRockyMountainshasthesolemnityofaprovidentialevent;itislikeadelugeofmenrisingunabatedly,anddailydrivenonwardbythehandofGod!\"
ThemindofM。deTocquevillehadthecandorofthephotographiccamera。Itrecordedimpressionswiththeimpartialityofnature。Theimagewassometimesdistorted,andtheperspectivewasnotalwaystrue,buthewasneitherapanegyrist,noranadvocate,noracritic。HeobservedAmericanphenomenaasillustrations,notasproofnorarguments;andalthoughitisapparentthatthetendencyofhismindwasnotwhollyfavorabletothedemocraticprinciple,yetthosewhodissentfromhisconclusionsmustcommendtheabilityandcouragewithwhichtheyareexpressed。
ThoughnotoriginallywrittenforAmericans,\"DemocracyinAmerica\"mustalwaysremainaworkofengrossingandconstantlyincreasinginteresttocitizensoftheUnitedStatesasthefirstphilosophicandcomprehensiveviewofoursociety,institutions,anddestiny。Noonecanriseevenfromthemostcursoryperusalwithoutclearerinsightandmorepatrioticappreciationoftheblessingsoflibertyprotectedbylaw,norwithoutencouragementforthestabilityandperpetuityoftheRepublic。ThecauseswhichappearedtoM。deTocquevilletomenaceboth,havegone。
Thedespotismofpublicopinion,thetyrannyofmajorities,theabsenceofintellectualfreedomwhichseemedtohimtodegradeadministrationandbringstatesmanship,learning,andliteraturetothelevelofthelowest,arenolongerconsidered。Theviolenceofpartyspirithasbeenmitigated,andthejudgmentofthewiseisnotsubordinatedtotheprejudicesoftheignorant。
Otherdangershavecome。Equalityofconditionsnolongerexists。Prophetsofevilpredictthedownfallofdemocracy,butthestudentofM。deTocquevillewillfindconsolationandencouragementinthereflectionthatthesamespiritwhichhasvanquishedtheperilsofthepast,whichheforesaw,willbeequallypreparedfortheresponsibilitiesofthepresentandthefuture。
ThelastofthefourvolumesofM。deTocqueville’sworkuponAmericaninstitutionsappearedin1840。
In1838hewaschosenmemberoftheAcademyofMoralandPoliticalSciences。In1839hewaselectedtotheChamberofDeputies。HebecameamemberoftheFrenchAcademyin1841。
In1848hewasintheAssembly,andfromJune2ndtoOctober31sthewasMinisterofForeignAffairs。Thecoupd’etatofDecember2,1851drovehimfromthepublicservice。In1856hepublished\"TheOldRegimeandtheRevolution。\"HediedatCannes,April15,1859,attheageoffifty—four。
Hon。JohnJ。IngallsIntroductoryChapterAmongstthenovelobjectsthatattractedmyattentionduringmystayintheUnitedStates,nothingstruckmemoreforciblythanthegeneralequalityofconditions。Ireadilydiscoveredtheprodigiousinfluencewhichthisprimaryfactexercisesonthewholecourseofsociety,bygivingacertaindirectiontopublicopinion,andacertaintenortothelaws;byimpartingnewmaximstothegoverningpowers,andpeculiarhabitstothegoverned。I
speedilyperceivedthattheinfluenceofthisfactextendsfarbeyondthepoliticalcharacterandthelawsofthecountry,andthatithasnolessempireovercivilsocietythanovertheGovernment;itcreatesopinions,engenderssentiments,suggeststheordinarypracticesoflife,andmodifieswhateveritdoesnotproduce。ThemoreIadvancedinthestudyofAmericansociety,themoreIperceivedthattheequalityofconditionsisthefundamentalfactfromwhichallothersseemtobederived,andthecentralpointatwhichallmyobservationsconstantlyterminated。
Ithenturnedmythoughtstoourownhemisphere,whereI
imaginedthatIdiscernedsomethinganalogoustothespectaclewhichtheNewWorldpresentedtome。IobservedthattheequalityofconditionsisdailyprogressingtowardsthoseextremelimitswhichitseemstohavereachedintheUnitedStates,andthatthedemocracywhichgovernstheAmericancommunitiesappearstoberapidlyrisingintopowerinEurope。Ihenceconceivedtheideaofthebookwhichisnowbeforethereader。
Itisevidenttoallalikethatagreatdemocraticrevolutionisgoingonamongstus;buttherearetwoopinionsastoitsnatureandconsequences。Tosomeitappearstobeanovelaccident,whichassuchmaystillbechecked;toothersitseemsirresistible,becauseitisthemostuniform,themostancient,andthemostpermanenttendencywhichistobefoundinhistory。
LetusrecollectthesituationofFrancesevenhundredyearsago,whentheterritorywasdividedamongstasmallnumberoffamilies,whoweretheownersofthesoilandtherulersoftheinhabitants;therightofgoverningdescendedwiththefamilyinheritancefromgenerationtogeneration;forcewastheonlymeansbywhichmancouldactonman,andlandedpropertywasthesolesourceofpower。Soon,however,thepoliticalpoweroftheclergywasfounded,andbegantoexertitself:theclergyopeneditsrankstoallclasses,tothepoorandtherich,thevilleinandthelord;equalitypenetratedintotheGovernmentthroughtheChurch,andthebeingwhoasaserfmusthavevegetatedinperpetualbondagetookhisplaceasapriestinthemidstofnobles,andnotinfrequentlyabovetheheadsofkings。
Thedifferentrelationsofmenbecamemorecomplicatedandmorenumerousassocietygraduallybecamemorestableandmorecivilized。Thencethewantofcivillawswasfelt;andtheorderoflegalfunctionariessoonrosefromtheobscurityofthetribunalsandtheirdustychambers,toappearatthecourtofthemonarch,bythesideofthefeudalbaronsintheirermineandtheirmail。Whilstthekingswereruiningthemselvesbytheirgreatenterprises,andthenoblesexhaustingtheirresourcesbyprivatewars,thelowerorderswereenrichingthemselvesbycommerce。TheinfluenceofmoneybegantobeperceptibleinStateaffairs。Thetransactionsofbusinessopenedanewroadtopower,andthefinancierrosetoastationofpoliticalinfluenceinwhichhewasatonceflatteredanddespised。Graduallythespreadofmentalacquirements,andtheincreasingtasteforliteratureandart,openedchancesofsuccesstotalent;sciencebecameameansofgovernment,intelligenceledtosocialpower,andthemanofletterstookapartintheaffairsoftheState。
Thevalueattachedtotheprivilegesofbirthdecreasedintheexactproportioninwhichnewpathswerestruckouttoadvancement。Intheeleventhcenturynobilitywasbeyondallprice;inthethirteenthitmightbepurchased;itwasconferredforthefirsttimein1270;andequalitywasthusintroducedintotheGovernmentbythearistocracyitself。
InthecourseofthesesevenhundredyearsitsometimeshappenedthatinordertoresisttheauthorityoftheCrown,ortodiminishthepoweroftheirrivals,thenoblesgrantedacertainshareofpoliticalrightstothepeople。Or,morefrequently,thekingpermittedthelowerorderstoenjoyadegreeofpower,withtheintentionofrepressingthearistocracy。InFrancethekingshavealwaysbeenthemostactiveandthemostconstantoflevellers。Whentheywerestrongandambitioustheysparednopainstoraisethepeopletothelevelofthenobles;
whentheyweretemperateorweaktheyallowedthepeopletoriseabovethemselves。Someassistedthedemocracybytheirtalents,othersbytheirvices。LouisXIandLouisXIVreducedeveryrankbeneaththethronetothesamesubjection;LouisXVdescended,himselfandallhisCourt,intothedust。
Assoonaslandwasheldonanyotherthanafeudaltenure,andpersonalpropertybeganinitsturntoconferinfluenceandpower,everyimprovementwhichwasintroducedincommerceormanufacturewasafreshelementoftheequalityofconditions。
Henceforwardeverynewdiscovery,everynewwantwhichitengendered,andeverynewdesirewhichcravedsatisfaction,wasasteptowardstheuniversallevel。Thetasteforluxury,theloveofwar,theswayoffashion,andthemostsuperficialaswellasthedeepestpassionsofthehumanheart,co—operatedtoenrichthepoorandtoimpoverishtherich。
Fromthetimewhentheexerciseoftheintellectbecamethesourceofstrengthandofwealth,itisimpossiblenottoconsidereveryadditiontoscience,everyfreshtruth,andeverynewideaasagermofpowerplacedwithinthereachofthepeople。Poetry,eloquence,andmemory,thegraceofwit,theglowofimagination,thedepthofthought,andallthegiftswhicharebestowedbyProvidencewithanequalhand,turnedtotheadvantageofthedemocracy;andevenwhentheywereinthepossessionofitsadversariestheystillserveditscausebythrowingintoreliefthenaturalgreatnessofman;itsconquestsspread,therefore,withthoseofcivilizationandknowledge,andliteraturebecameanarsenalwherethepoorestandtheweakestcouldalwaysfindweaponstotheirhand。
Inperusingthepagesofourhistory,weshallscarcelymeetwithasinglegreatevent,inthelapseofsevenhundredyears,whichhasnotturnedtotheadvantageofequality。TheCrusadesandthewarsoftheEnglishdecimatedthenoblesanddividedtheirpossessions;theerectionofcommunitiesintroducedanelementofdemocraticlibertyintothebosomoffeudalmonarchy;
theinventionoffire—armsequalizedthevilleinandthenobleonthefieldofbattle;printingopenedthesameresourcestothemindsofallclasses;thepostwasorganizedsoastobringthesameinformationtothedoorofthepoorman’scottageandtothegateofthepalace;andProtestantismproclaimedthatallmenarealikeabletofindtheroadtoheaven。ThediscoveryofAmericaofferedathousandnewpathstofortune,andplacedrichesandpowerwithinthereachoftheadventurousandtheobscure。IfweexaminewhathashappenedinFranceatintervalsoffiftyyears,beginningwiththeeleventhcentury,weshallinvariablyperceivethatatwofoldrevolutionhastakenplaceinthestateofsociety。Thenoblehasgonedownonthesocialladder,andtheroturierhasgoneup;theonedescendsastheotherrises。Everyhalfcenturybringsthemnearertoeachother,andtheywillveryshortlymeet。
NoristhisphenomenonatallpeculiartoFrance。
WhithersoeverweturnoureyesweshallwitnessthesamecontinualrevolutionthroughoutthewholeofChristendom。Thevariousoccurrencesofnationalexistencehaveeverywhereturnedtotheadvantageofdemocracy;allmenhaveaideditbytheirexertions:thosewhohaveintentionallylaboredinitscause,andthosewhohaveserveditunwittingly;thosewhohavefoughtforitandthosewhohavedeclaredthemselvesitsopponents,haveallbeendrivenalonginthesametrack,havealllaboredtooneend,someignorantlyandsomeunwillingly;allhavebeenblindinstrumentsinthehandsofGod。
Thegradualdevelopmentoftheequalityofconditionsisthereforeaprovidentialfact,anditpossessesallthecharacteristicsofadivinedecree:itisuniversal,itisdurable,itconstantlyeludesallhumaninterference,andalleventsaswellasallmencontributetoitsprogress。Wouldit,then,bewisetoimaginethatasocialimpulsewhichdatesfromsofarbackcanbecheckedbytheeffortsofageneration?Isitcrediblethatthedemocracywhichhasannihilatedthefeudalsystemandvanquishedkingswillrespectthecitizenandthecapitalist?Willitstopnowthatithasgrownsostronganditsadversariessoweak?Nonecansaywhichwaywearegoing,foralltermsofcomparisonarewanting:theequalityofconditionsismorecompleteintheChristiancountriesofthepresentdaythanithasbeenatanytimeorinanypartoftheworld;sothattheextentofwhatalreadyexistspreventsusfromforeseeingwhatmaybeyettocome。
Thewholebookwhichishereofferedtothepublichasbeenwrittenundertheimpressionofakindofreligiousdreadproducedintheauthor’smindbythecontemplationofsoirresistiblearevolution,whichhasadvancedforcenturiesinspiteofsuchamazingobstacles,andwhichisstillproceedinginthemidstoftheruinsithasmade。ItisnotnecessarythatGodhimselfshouldspeakinordertodisclosetoustheunquestionablesignsofHiswill;wecandiscerntheminthehabitualcourseofnature,andintheinvariabletendencyofevents:Iknow,withoutaspecialrevelation,thattheplanetsmoveintheorbitstracedbytheCreator’sfinger。Ifthemenofourtimewereledbyattentiveobservationandbysincerereflectiontoacknowledgethatthegradualandprogressivedevelopmentofsocialequalityisatoncethepastandfutureoftheirhistory,thissolitarytruthwouldconferthesacredcharacterofaDivinedecreeuponthechange。ToattempttocheckdemocracywouldbeinthatcasetoresistthewillofGod;
andthenationswouldthenbeconstrainedtomakethebestofthesociallotawardedtothembyProvidence。
TheChristiannationsofourageseemtometopresentamostalarmingspectacle;theimpulsewhichisbearingthemalongissostrongthatitcannotbestopped,butitisnotyetsorapidthatitcannotbeguided:theirfateisintheirhands;yetalittlewhileanditmaybesonolonger。Thefirstdutywhichisatthistimeimposeduponthosewhodirectouraffairsistoeducatethedemocracy;towarmitsfaith,ifthatbepossible;topurifyitsmorals;todirectitsenergies;tosubstituteaknowledgeofbusinessforitsinexperience,andanacquaintancewithitstrueinterestsforitsblindpropensities;toadaptitsgovernmenttotimeandplace,andtomodifyitincompliancewiththeoccurrencesandtheactorsoftheage。Anewscienceofpoliticsisindispensabletoanewworld。This,however,iswhatwethinkofleast;launchedinthemiddleofarapidstream,weobstinatelyfixoureyesontheruinswhichmaystillbedescribedupontheshorewehaveleft,whilstthecurrentsweepsusalong,anddrivesusbackwardstowardsthegulf。