ThatFrenchdemagoguewhomVictorHugoaptlycalledNapoleontheLittlewasaprimefactorinthehistoryoftheUnionandtheConfederacy。TheConfederatesideofhisintriguewillbetoldinitsproperplace。Here,letusobservehimfromthepointofviewofWashington。
Itistoomuchtoattempttopackintoasentenceortwothecomplicateddramaofdeceit,lies,andgraft,throughwhichhecreatedatlastapretextforinterventionintheaffairsofMexico;itisenoughthatintheautumnof1862aFrencharmyofinvasionmarchedfromVeraCruzuponMexicoCity。WehavealreadyseenthataboutthissametimeNapoleonproposedtoEnglandandRussiaajointinterventionwithFrancebetweenNorthandSouth——aproposalwhich,however,wasrejected。ThisMexicanventureexplainswhytheplanwassuggestedatthatparticulartime。
DisappointedinEnglandandRussia,Napoleonunexpectedlyreceivedencouragement,ashethought,fromwithintheUnitedStatesthroughthemediumoftheeccentriceditorofthe\"NewYorkTribune\"。WeshallhaveoccasiontoreturnlatertotheadventuresofHoraceGreeley——thaterraticindividualwhohasmanygoodandgenerousactstohiscredit,aswellasmanyfoolishones。Forthepresentwehavetonotethattowardthecloseof1862heapproachedtheFrenchAmbassadoratWashingtonwitharequestforimperialmediationbetweentheNorthandtheSouth。GreeleywasatypeofAmericanthatnoEuropeancanunderstand:hebelievedintalk,andmoretalk,andstillmoretalk,asthecureforearthlyills。Henevercouldunderstandthatanybodybesideshimselfcouldhavestrongconvictions。WhenhetoldtheAmbassadorthattheEmperor\'smediationwouldleadtoareconciliationofthesections,hewasdoubtlesssincereinhisbelief。TheastuteEuropeandiplomat,whocouldnotbelievesuchsimplicity,thoughtitamask。Whenheaskedfor,andreceived,permissiontopasstheFederallinesandvisitRichmond,heinterpretedthepermitinthelightofhisassumptionaboutGreeley。AtRichmond,hefoundnodesireforreunion。Puttingthisandthattogether,heconcludedthattheNorthwantedtogiveupthefightandwouldwelcomemediationtosaveitsface。ThedreadfuldefeatatFredericksburgfellinwiththisreasoning。HisreportsonAmericanconditionsledNapoleon,inJanuary,1863,toattemptalonewhathehadoncehopedtodosupportedbyEnglandandRussia。HeproposedhisgoodofficestotheGovernmentatWashingtonasamediatorbetweenNorthandSouth。
Hitherto,WashingtonhadbeenverydiscreetaboutMexico。AdroithintsnottogotoofarhadbeengivenNapoleoninfullmeasure,buttherewasnorealprotest。TheStateDepartmentnowcontinuedthiscautionandinthemostpolitetermsdeclinedNapoleon\'soffer。Congress,however,tookthemattermoregrimly,forthroughoutthedealingswithNapoleon,ithadbeenatoddswithLincoln。Itnowpassedthefirstofaseriesofresolutionswhichexpressedthewillofthecountry,ifnotquitethewillofthePresident,byresolvingthatanyfurtherproposalofmediationwouldberegardedbyitas\"anunfriendlyact。\"
Napoleonthenresumedhisschemingforjointintervention,whileinthemeantimehisarmiescontinuedtofighttheirwayuntiltheyenteredMexicoCityinJune,1863。ThetimehadnowcomewhenNapoleonthoughtitopportunetoshowhishand。
ThosewerethedayswhenLeeappearedinvincible,andwhenChancellorsvillecrownedasplendidseriesoftriumphs。InEngland,theSouthernpartymadeafreshstart;andsocietieswereorganizedtoaidtheConfederacy。AtLiverpool,LairdBrotherswerebuilding,ostensiblyforFrance,reallyfortheConfederacy,twoironcladssupposedtooutclasseveryshipintheNorthernnavy。InFrance,100,000unemployedcottonhandswereriotingforfood。ToraisefundsfortheConfederacythegreatErlangerbanking-houseofParisnegotiatedaloanbasedoncottonwhichwastobedeliveredafterthebreakingoftheblockade。NapoleondreamedofashatteredAmericanunion,twoenfeebledrepublics,andabroadwayforhisownschemeinMexico。
InJuneanEnglishpoliticianofSouthernsympathies,EdwardRoebuck,wentovertoFrance,wasreceivedbytheEmperor,andcametoanunderstandingwithhim。RoebuckwenthometoreporttotheSouthernpartythatNapoleonwasreadytointervene,andthatallhewaitedforwasEngland\'scooperation。Amotion\"toenterintonegotiationswiththeGreatPowersofEuropeforthepurposeofobtainingtheircooperationintherecognition\"oftheConfederacywasintroducedbyRoebuckintheHouseofCommons。
ThedebatewhichfollowedwasthelastchanceoftheSouthernpartyand,aseventsproved,thelastchanceofNapoleon。HowcompletelytheBritishministrywasnowcommittedtotheNorthappearsinthefactthatGladstone,fortheGovernment,opposedRoebuck\'smotion。JohnBrightattackeditinwhatLordMorleycalls\"perhapsthemostpowerfulandthenoblestspeechofhislife。\"TheSouthernpartywashardlyresoluteintheirsupportofRoebuckandpresentlyhewithdrewhismotion。
ButtherewerestilltheironcladsatLiverpool。Wehaveseenthatearlierinthewar,thecarelessnessoftheBritishauthoritieshadpermittedtheescapeofship290,subsequentlyknownastheConfederatecommercedestroyer,Alabama。Theauthoritiesdidnotwishtoallowarepetitionoftheincident。
ButcoulditbeshownthattheLairdshipswerenotreallyforaFrenchpurchaser?ItwasinthecourseofdiplomaticconversationsthatMr。Adams,speakingofthepossiblesailingoftheships,madearemarkdestinedtobecomefamous:\"Itwouldbesuperfluousinmetopointouttoyourlordshipthatthisiswar。\"Atjest,theauthoritiesweresatisfied。TheshipswereseizedandintheendboughtfortheBritishNavy。
AgainNapoleonstoodalone。Notonlyhadhefailedtoobtainaidfromabroad,butinFranceitselfhisMexicanschemeswerewidelyandbitterlycondemned。Yethehadgonetoofartorecede,andwhathehadbeenaimingatallalongwasnowrevealed。AnassemblyofMexicannotables,convenedbythegeneraloftheinvaders,votedtosetupanimperialgovernmentandofferedthecrowntoNapoleon\'snominee,theArchdukeMaximilianofAustria。
AndnowtheGovernmentatWashingtonwasfacedwithacomplicatedproblem。WhatabouttheMonroeDoctrine?DidtheUniondareriskwarwithFrance?DiditdarepassoverwithoutprotesttheestablishmentofmonarchyonAmericansoilbyforeignarms?
Betweenthesehornsofadilemma,theGovernmentmaintaineditsprecariouspositionduringanotheryear。Seward\'scorrespondencewithPariswasamasterpieceofevasion。HeneitherprotestedagainsttheinterventionofNapoleonnoracknowledgedtheauthorityofMaximilian。Apparently,bothheandLincolnweredividedbetweenfearofaFrenchalliancewiththeConfederacyandfearofprematureactionintheNorththatwouldrenderNapoleondesperate。JusthowfartheycomprehendedNapoleonandhisproblemsisanopenquestion。
Whetherreallycomprehendingormerelytrustingtoitsinstinct,Congresstookaboldercourse。Twomenprovetheantagonistsofaparliamentaryduel——CharlesSumner,chairmanoftheSenateCommitteeonForeignRelations,andHenryWinterDavis,chairmanofthecorrespondingcommitteeoftheHouse。SumnerplayedthehandoftheAdministration。FieryresolutionsdemandingtheevacuationofMexicooranAmericandeclarationofwarwereskillfullyburiedinthesilenceofSumner\'scommittee。Buttherewasneverthelessoneresolutionthataffectedhistory:itwasaringingcondemnationoftheattempttoestablishamonarchyinMexico。IntheHouse,ajointresolutionwhichDavissubmittedwaspassedwithoutonedissentingvote。WhenitcametotheSenate,Sumnerburieditashehadburiedearlierresolutions。NonethelessitwentouttotheworldattendedbythenewsoftheunanimousvoteintheHouse。
Shortlyafterwards,theAmericanAmbassadoratPariscalledupontheimperialForeignSecretary,M。DrouyndeL\'huys。Newsofthisresolutionhadprecededhim。Hewasmetbythecurtquestion,\"Doyoubringpeaceorwar?\"Again,theWashingtonGovernmentwasskillfullyevasive。TheAmbassadorwasinstructedtoexplainthattheresolutionhadnotbeeninspiredbythePresidentand\"theFrenchGovernmentwouldbeseasonablyapprizedofanychangeofpolicy……whichthePresidentmightatanyfuturetimethinkitpropertoadopt。\"
ThereseemslittledoubtthatLincoln\'scoursewasverywidelycondemnedastimid。Whenwecometothepoliticalcampaignof1864,weshallmeetHenryWinterDavisamonghismostrelentlesspersonalenemies。DissatisfactionwithLincoln\'sMexicanpolicyhasnotbeensufficientlyconsideredinaccountingfortheoppositiontohim,insidethewarparty,in1864。Toitmaybetracedanarticleintheplatformofthewarparty,adoptedinJune,1864,protestingagainsttheestablishmentofmonarchy\"innearproximitytotheUnitedStates。\"InthesamemonthMaximilianenteredMexicoCity。
ThesubsequentmovesofNapoleonareexplainedelsewhere。*Thecentralfactinthestoryishisvirtualchangeofattitude,inthesummerof1864。TheConfederateagentatPariscomplainedofagrowingcoolness。Beforetheendofthesummer,theConfederateSecretaryofStatewasbitterinhisdenunciationofNapoleonforhavingdesertedtheSouth。Napoleon\'spuppetMaximilianrefusedtoreceiveanenvoyfromtheConfederacy。ThoughWashingtondidnotformallyprotestagainstthepresenceofMaximilianinMexico,itdeclinedtorecognizehisGovernment,andthatGovernmentcontinuedunrecognizedatWashingtonthroughoutthewar。
*NathanielW。Stephenson,\"TheDayoftheConfederacy\"。In\"TheChroniclesofAmerica\"。
CHAPTERXIII。THEPLEBISCITEOF1864
EverygreatrevolutionamongAnglo-Saxonpeople——perhapsamongallpeople——hasproducedstrangetypesofdreamers。InAmerica,however,neithersectioncouldclaimamonopolyofsuchtypes,andeventhelatter-dayvisionarieswhocanseeeverythinginheavenandearth,exceptingfact,hadtheirNorthernandSouthernoriginalsinthetimeofthegreatAmericanwar。Amongtheseisastrangecongregationwhichassembledinthespringof1864andwhichhascometobeknown,fromitsplaceofmeeting,astheClevelandConvention。Itscomingtogetherwastheresultofaloosecooperationamongseveralminorpoliticalgroups,allofwhichwerefortheUnionandthewar,andviolentlyopposedtoLincoln。Sofarastheyhadacommonpurpose,itwastosupplantLincolnbyFremontinthenextelection。
TheConventionwasnotableforthelargeproportionofagnosticsamongitsmembers。Amotionwasmadetoamendaresolutionthat\"theRebellionmustbeputdown\"byaddingthewords\"withGod\'sassistance。\"Thistouchofpietywasstormilyrejected。AnothergrouprepresentedatClevelandwasmadeupofextremeabolitionistsundertheleadershipofthatbrilliantbutdisorderedgenius,WendellPhillips。HesentaletterdenouncingLincolnandpledginghissupportofFremontbecauseofthelatter\'s\"clearsightedstatesmanshipandraremilitaryability。\"
Theconventiondeclareditselfapoliticalparty,underthestyleoftheRadicalDemocracy,andnominatedFremontforPresident。
Therewasanotherbodyofdreamers,stillmoresingular,whowerealsobitteropponentsofLincoln。Theywere,however,notinfavorofwar。Theirpoliticalmachineryconsistedofsecretsocieties。Asearlyas1860,theKnightsoftheGoldenCirclewereactiveinIndiana,wheretheydidyeomanserviceforBreckinridge。LaterthissocietyacquiredsomeundergroundinfluenceinotherStates,especiallyinOhio,anddiditsshareinbringingaboutthevictoriesatthepollsintheautumnof1862,whentheDemocratscapturedtheIndianalegislature。
ThemostseriouschargeagainsttheGoldenCirclewascomplicityinanattempttoassassinateOliverP。Morton,GovernorofIndiana,whowasfiredat,onenight,ashewasleavingthestatehouse。WhenMortondemandedaninvestigationoftheGoldenCircle,thelegislaturerefusedtosanctionit。OnhisownauthorityandwithFederalaidhemadeinvestigationsandpublishedareportwhich,ifitdidnotactuallyprovetreason,camedangerouslyneartoproof。Thereafter,thissocietydropsoutofsight,anditsmembersappeartohaveformedthenewOrderoftheAmericanKnights,whichinitsturnwaseclipsedbytheSonsofLiberty。Therewereseveralothersuchsocietiesallorganizedonamilitaryplanandwithagreatpretenseofarmingtheirmembers。This,however,hadtobedonesurreptitiously。
BoxesofriflespurchasedintheEastwereshippedWestlabeled\"Sunday-schoolbooks,\"andnegotiationswereevenundertakenwiththeConfederacytobringinarmsbywayofCanada。AtameetingofthesupremecounciloftheSonsofLiberty,inNewYork,February22,1864,itwasclaimedthattheorderhadnearlyamillionmembers,thoughtheGovernmentsecretserviceconsideredhalfamillionamoreexactestimate。
Aseventssubsequentlyproved,thesocietieswerenotasformidableasthesefigureswouldimply。Mostofthemenwhojoinedthemseemtohavebeenfancifulcreatureswholovedsecrecyforitsownsake。Whilerealmen,NorthandSouth,werelayingdowntheirlivesfortheirprinciples,thesemake-believemenwereholdingbombasticinitiationsandtakingoathssuchasthisfromtheritualoftheAmericanKnights:\"Idofurthersolemnlypromiseandswear,thatIwillevercherishthesublimelessonswhichthesacredemblemsofourordersuggest,andwill,sofarasinmelies,impartthoselessonstothepeopleoftheearth,wherethemysticacornfallsfromitsparentbough,inwhosevisiblefirmamentOrion,Arcturus,andthePleiadesrideintheircoldresplendentglories,andwheretheSouthernCrossdazzlestheeyeofdegradedhumanitywithitscoruscationsofgoldenlight,fitemblemofTruth,whileitinvitesoursacredordertoconsecratehertemplesinthefourcornersoftheearth,wheremoraldarknessreignsanddespotismholdssway……Divineessence,sohelpmethatIfailnotinmytroth,lestIshallbesummonedbeforethetribunaloftheorder,adjudgedandcondemnedtocertainandshamefuldeath,whilemynameshallberecordedontherollsofinfamy。Amen。\"
ThesecretordersfoughthardtopreventtheLincolnvictoryintheelectionsof1863。EvenbeforethattimetheirleadershadtalkedmysteriouslyofanotherdisruptionoftheUnionandtheformationofaNorthwesternConfederacyinalliancewiththeSouth。TheschemewasknowntotheConfederates,allusionstoitaretobefoundinSouthernnewspapers,andeventheConfederatemilitaryauthoritiesconsideredit。Earlyin1863,GeneralBeauregardthoughttheConfederatesmight\"getintoOhioandcalluponthefriendsofVallandighamtoriseforhisdefenseandsupport;then……calluponthewholeNorthwesttojoininthemovement,formaconfederacyoftheirown,andjoinusbyatreatyofalliance,offensiveanddefensive。\"Relianceonthesupportofthesocietieswasthewill-o\'-the-wispthatdeceivedGeneralJohnMorganinhisdesperateattempttocarryoutBeauregard\'sprogramme。Thoughbrushedasideasameredetailbymilitaryhistorians,Morgan\'sraid,withhisforceofirregularcavalry,inJuly,1863,throughIndianaandOhio,wasoneofthemostromanticepisodesofthewar。Butitendedinhisdefeatandcapture。Whilehisgallanttroopersrodetotheirdestruction,themenwholovedtoswearbyArcturusandtogabbleaboutthePleiadesshowedthefibertobeexpectedofsuchpeople,andstayedsnugintheirbeds。
ButneithertheirownlackofhardihoodnorthedisastersoftheirSouthernfriendscoulddampentheirpeculiarardor。TheirherowasVallandigham。ThatredoubtablepersonhadfixedhisheadquartersinCanada,whencehedirectedhispartisansintheirvainattempttoelecthimGovernorofOhio。TheirnextmovewastohonorhimwiththeofficeofSupremeCommanderoftheSonsofLiberty,andnowVallandighamresolvedtowinthemartyr\'scrowninveryfact。InJune,1864,hepreparedforthedramaticeffectbycarefullyadvertisinghisintentionandcamehome。ButtohisgreatdisappointmentLincolnignoredhim,andthedramaticmartyrdomwhichhehadplanneddidnotcomeoff。
Therestillexistedthepossibilityofagreatuprising,andtothatendarrangementsweremadewithSouthernagentsinCanada。
Confederatesoldiers,pickedmen,madetheirwayindisguisetoChicago。TheretheworshipersofArcturusweretojointheminamightymultitude;theConfederateprisonersatCampDouglasinChicagoweretobeliberated;aroundthatcoreofveterans,thehostsofthePleiadesweretorally。AllthiswastocoincidewiththeassemblingatChicagooftheDemocraticnationalconvention,inwhichVallandighamwastoappear。Theorganizersoftheconspiracydreamedthatthetwoeventsmightcoalesce;
thattheconventionmightbestampededbytheiruprising;thatagreatpart,ifnotthewhole,oftheconventionwouldendorsetheestablishmentofaNorthwesternConfederacy。
AlasforhimwhobuildsontheframeofmindthatdelightsincheaprhetoricwhileRomeisafire!Atthemomentofhazard,theSonsofLibertyshowedthewhitefeather,werefullofspeciouswords,wouldnotact。TheConfederatesoldiers,indignantatthissecondbetrayal,hadtomaketheirescapefromthecountry。
ItmustnotbesupposedthatthisDemocraticnationalconventionwasmadeupaltogetherofSecessionists。Thepeacepartywasstill,asinthepreviousyear,astrangecomplex,amixtureofallsortsandconditions。ItscohesionwasnotsomuchduetoitsloveofpeaceastoitsdislikeofLincolnanditshatredofhisparty。Vallandighamwasamemberofthecommitteeonresolutions。ThepermanentchairmanwasGovernorSeymourofNewYork。TheConventionwascalledtoorderbyAugustBelmont,aforeignerbybirth,theAmericanrepresentativeoftheRothschilds。HewastheheadandfrontofthatbodyofNortherncapitalwhichhadsolongfinancedtheSouthandwhichhadalwaysopposedthewar。InopeningtheConventionhesaid:\"Fouryearsofmisrulebyasectional,fanatical,andcorruptpartyhavebroughtourcountrytothevergeofruin。\"IntheplatformLincolnwasaccusedofalistofcrimeswhichithadbecomethehabitofthepeacepartytochargeagainsthim。Hisadministrationwasdescribedas\"fouryearsoffailure,\"andMcClellanwasnominatedforPresident。
TheRepublicanmanagerscalledaconventionatBaltimoreinJune,1864,withaviewtoorganizingacompositeUnionPartyinwhichtheWarDemocratsweretoparticipate。Theirplanwassuccessful。ThesecondplaceontheUnionticketwasacceptedbyaWarDemocrat,AndrewJohnson,ofTennessee。Lincolnwasrenominated,thoughnotwithoutopposition,andhewassokeenlyawarethathewasnottheunanimouschoiceoftheUnionPartythathepermittedthefacttoappearinapublicutterancesoonafterward。\"Idonotallowmyself,\"hesaid,inaddressingadelegationoftheNationalUnionLeague,\"tosupposethateithertheConventionortheLeaguehaveconcludedtodecidethatIameitherthegreatestorthebestmaninAmerica,butrathertheyhaveconcludeditisnotbesttoswaphorseswhilecrossingtheriver,andhavefurtherconcludedthatIamnotsopoorahorsethattheymightnotmakeabotchofitintryingtoswap。\"
ButtheUnionPartywassofarfrombeingaunitthatduringthesummerfactionalquarrelsdevelopedwithinitsranks。AlltheelementsthatwereunfriendlytoLincolntookheartfromadisputebetweenthePresidentandCongresswithregardtoreconstructioninLouisiana,overalargepartofwhichFederaltroopshadestablishedacivilgovernmentonthePresident\'sauthority。Asanincidentinthehistoryofreconstruction,thiswholematterhasitsplaceinanothervolume。*Butitalsohasaplaceinthehistoryofthepresidentialcampaignof1864。
Lincoln\'splanofreconstructionwasobnoxioustotheRadicalsinCongressinasmuchasitdidnotdefinitelyabolishslaveryinLouisiana,althoughitrequiredthenewGovernmenttogiveitsadherencetotheEmancipationProclamation。CongresspassedabilltakingreconstructionoutofthePresident\'shandsanddefinitelyrequiringthereconstructedStatestoabolishslavery。
LincolntookthepositionthatCongresshadnopoweroverslaveryintheStates。WhenhisProclamationwasthrowninhisteeth,hereplied,\"IconceivethatImayinanemergencydothingsonmilitarygroundswhichcannotbedoneconstitutionallybyCongress。\"IncidentallytherewasafurtherdisagreementbetweenthePresidentandtheRadicalsovernegrosuffrage。Thoughneitherschemeprovidedforit,Lincolnwouldextendit,ifatall,onlytotheexceptionalnegroes,whiletheRadicalswerereadyforasweepingextension。ButLincolnrefusedtosigntheirbillanditlapsed。ThereuponBenjaminWadeofOhioandHenryWinterDavisofMarylandissuedasavagedenunciationofLincolnwhichhasbeenknowneversinceasthe\"Wade-DavisManifesto\"。
*WalterL。Fleming,\"TheSequelofAppomattox\"。In\"TheChroniclesofAmerica\"。
TherewasafactionintheUnionPartywhichwemayjustlynametheVindictives。The\"Manifesto\"gavethemarallyingcry。AtaconferenceinNewYorktheydecidedtocompeltheretirementofLincolnandthenominationofsomeothercandidate。ForthispurposeanewconventionwastobecalledatCincinnatiinSeptember。IntheranksoftheVindictivesatthistimewastheimpetuouseditorofthe\"NewYorkTribune\",HoraceGreeley。Hispresencetherecallsforsomeexplanation。Perhapsthemostsingularfigureofthetime,hewasoneofthemostirresponsibleandyet,throughhispaper,oneofthemostinfluential。Hehadatrickofphrasewhich,somehow,madehimappearoraculartotheplainpeople,especiallyintheruraldistricts——theverypeopleonwhomLincolnreliedforalargepartofhissupport。Greeleyknewhispower,andhismindwasnotlargeenoughtocarrytheknowledgewell。Furthermore,hiswasthesortofnaturethatrelatesitselftolifeaboveallthroughthesensibilities。
Kiplingspeaksscornfullyofpeoplewhoiftheir\"ownfrontdoorisshutwillsweartheworldiswarm。\"TheyarerelationsinthefullbloodofHoraceGreeley。
InJuly,whenthebreachbetweenthePresidentandtheVindictiveswasjustbeginningtobeevident,Greeleywaspursuinganadventureofhisown。Amongtheleastsensibleminorincidentsofthewarwereanumberoffantasticattemptsofprivatepersonstonegotiatepeace。Withoneexceptiontheyhadnohistoricimportance。TheexceptionisanegotiationcarriedonbyGreeley,whichseemstohavebeentheultimatecauseofhisalliancewiththeVindictives。
InthemiddleofJuly,1864,goldwassellinginNewYorkat285。
Therewasdistressanddiscontentthroughoutthecountry。ThehorribleslaughteroftheWilderness,stillfreshineverybody\'smind,hadputthewholeUnionPartyintomourning。TheimpressionableGreeleybecamefranticforpeacepeaceatanyprice。AtthepsychologicalmomentwordwasconveyedtohimthattwopersonsinCanadaheldauthorityfromtheConfederacytoenterintonegotiationsforpeace。GreeleywrotetoLincolndemandingnegotiationsbecause\"ourbleeding,bankrupt,almostdyingcountrylongsforpeace,shuddersattheprospectoffreshconscriptions,offurtherwholesaledevastations,andofnewriversofhumanblood。\"
LincolnconsentedtoanegotiationbutstipulatedthatGreeleyhimselfshouldbecomeresponsibleforitsconduct。ThoughthiswasnotwhatGreeleywantedforhistypealwayspreferstotellotherswhattodo——hesullenlyaccepted。HeproceededtoNiagaratomeetthereputedcommissionersoftheConfederacy。Thedetailsofthefutileconferencedonotconcernus。TheConfederateagentswerenotempoweredtotreatforpeace——atleastnotonanytermsthatwouldbeconsideredatWashington。
Theirrealpurposewasfarsubtler。AppreciatingthedelicatebalanceinNorthernpolitics,theyaimedatmakingitappearthatLincolnwasbeggingforterms。Lincoln,whoforesawthispossibleturnofevents,hadexpresslylimitedGreeleytonegotiationsfor\"theintegrityofthewholeUnionandtheabandonmentofslavery。\"Greeleychosetobelievethattheseinstructions,andnotthesubtletyoftheConfederateagentsandhisownimpulsiveness,werethecauseofthefalsepositioninwhichtheagentsnowplacedhim。Theypublishedanaccountoftheepisode,thuseffectinganexposurewhichledtosharpattacksuponGreeleybytheNorthernpress。InthebitternessofhismortificationGreeleythenwentfromoneextremetotheotherandjoinedtheVindictives。
LessthanthreeweeksaftertheconferenceatNiagara,the\"Wade-DavisManifesto\"appeared。ItwascommunicatedtothecountrythroughthecolumnsofGreeley\'spaperonthe5thofAugust。Greeley,whososhortatimebeforewasforpeaceatanyprice,wentthewholelengthofreactionbyproclaimingthat\"Mr。
Lincolnisalreadybeaten……Wemusthaveanothertickettosaveusfromutteroverthrow。IfwehadsuchaticketascouldbemadebynamingGrant,Butler,orShermanforPresidentandFarragutforVice,wecouldmakeafightyet。\"
AtaboutthissametimethechairmanoftheRepublicannationalcommittee,whowasaLincolnman,wrotetothePresidentthatthesituationwasdesperate。Lincolnhimselfisknowntohavemadeaprivatememorandumcontainingthewords,\"ItseemsextremelyprobablethatthisAdministrationwillnotbereelected。\"Onthe1stofSeptember,1864,withthreepresidentialcandidatesinthefield,Northernpoliticswerebewildering,andthecountrywasshroudedinthedeepestgloom。TheWildernesscampaign,afterslaughterunparalleled,hadnotinthepopularmindachievedresults。Sherman,inGeorgia,thoughhislosseswerenotasterribleasGrant\'s,hadnotyetdoneanythingtolightenthegloom。NotevenFarragut\'svictoryinMobileBay,inAugust,far-reachingasitprovedtobe,reassuredtheNorth。AbittercryforpeacewentupevenfromloversoftheUnionwhoseheartshadfailed。
Meanwhile,thebrilliantstrategistinGeorgiawaspressinghisdriveforpoliticalaswellasformilitaryeffect。TorousethoseUnionistswhohadlostheartwaspartofhispurposewhenhehurledhiscolumnsagainstAtlanta,fromwhichHoodwasdriveninoneofthemostdisastrousofConfederatedefeats。Onthe3rdofSeptemberLincolnissuedaproclamationappointingadayofthanksgivingforthesegreatvictoriesofShermanandFarragut。
Onthatday,itwouldseem,thetideturnedinNorthernpolitics。
SomehistoriansarecontentwithAtlantaastheexplanationofallthatfollowed;buttherearethreeseparateeventsofimportancethatnowoccurredasincidentsinthecomplicatedsituation。Inthefirstplace,threeweekslatertheradicaloppositionhadcollapsed;theplanforanewconventionwasabandoned;theVindictiveleaderscameoutinsupportofLincoln。
Almostsimultaneouslyoccurredtheremainingtwosurprisingevents。Fremontwithdrewfromhiscandidacyinordertodohis\"parttowardpreventingtheelectionoftheDemocraticcandidate。\"AndLincolnaskedfortheresignationofamemberofhisCabinet,Postmaster-GeneralMontgomeryBlair,whowastheespecialenemyoftheVindictives。
TheofficialbiographersofLincoln*keepthesethreeeventsseparate。TheyholdthatBlair\'sremovalwaswhollyLincoln\'sidea,andthatfromchivalrousreasonshewouldnotabandonhisfriendaslongasheseemedtobelosingthegame。ThehistorianRhodeswritesconfidentlyofabargainwithFremont,holdingthatBlairwasremovedtoterminateaquarrelwithFremontwhichdatedbackeventohisownremovalin1861。ApossiblethirdtheoryturnsuponChase,whosehostilitytoBlairwasquiteequaltothatoftheillbalancedFremont。IthadbeenstimulatedthepreviouswinterbyafiercearraignmentofChasemadebyBlair\'sbrotherinCongress,inwhichChasewasbluntlyaccusedoffraudandofmakingmoney,orallowinghisfriendstomakemoney,throughillicittradeincotton。AndChasewasamanofmightamongtheVindictives。Theintrigue,however,nevercomestotheforegroundinhistory,butlurksinthebackgroundthickwithshadows。OnceortwiceamongthoseshadowsweseemtocatchaglimpseofthefigureofThurlowWeed,themaster-politicianofthetime。Takingonethingwithanother,wemayrisktheguessthatsomehowthetworadicalgroupswhichwerebothrelentlessagainstBlairwereledtopooltheirissues,andthatBlair\'sremovalwasthepriceLincolnpaidnottoonefactionofradicalsbuttothewholeunmercifulcrowd。
*Hisprivatesecretaries,JohnG。NicolayandJohnHay。
Whatevercomplexofpurposeslaybackofthetriplecoincidence,thelatterpartofSeptembersawageneralreunionofthefactionswithintheUnionParty,followedbyaswiftrecoveryofstrength。Whentheelectioncame,Lincolnreceivedanelectoralvoteof212against21,andapopularvoteof2,330,552against1,835,985。
Theinevitablequestionarisesastowhatwastherealcauseofthissuccess。Itissafetosaythatthepoliticalcampaigncontainedsomeadroitstrategy;thatShermanwaswithoutdoubtanenormousfactor;thattheDemocratsmadenumerousblunders;andthatthesecretsocietieshadaneffectotherthantheyintended。
However,therealclueseemstobefoundinonesentencefromaletterwrittenbyLowelltoMotleywhentheoutlookforhispartywasdarkest:\"Themercantileclassesarelongingforpeace,butI
believethatthepeoplearemorefirmthanever。\"Ofthegreat,silentmassofthepeople,thetruetemperseemstobestruckoffinapopularpoemofthetime,writteninresponsetooneofthecallsformoretroops,apoemwithrefrainsbuiltonthemodelofthiscouplet:
\"We\'recomingfromthehillside,we\'recomingfromtheshore,We\'recoming,FatherAbraham,sixhundredthousandmore。\"
CHAPTERXIV。LINCOLN\'SFINALINTENTIONS
ThevictoryoftheUnionPartyinNovemberenabledLincolntoenjoyforabriefperiodofhiscareerasPresidentwhatmaybethoughtofasalullinthestorm。Heknewnowthathehadatlastbuiltupafirmandpowerfulsupport。Withthisassured,hispolicy,bothdomesticandforeign——thekeytowhichwasstilltheblockade——mightbeconsideredvictoriousatallpoints。
Thereremainstobenoticed,however,oneeventoftheyear1864
whichwasofvitalimportanceinmaintainingtheblockade。
Itisaprincipleofinternationallawthatabelligerentmustitselfattendtothegreattaskofsuppressingcontrabandtradewithitsenemy。Lincolnwascarefultoobservethisprinciple。
ThoughBritishmerchantswerefranklyspeculatingincontrabandtrade,hemadenodemandupontheBritishGovernmenttorelievehimofthedifficultyofstoppingit。Englandalsotookthelegitimatepositionunderinternationallawandwarnedhermerchantsthat,whileitwasnoneoftheGovernment\'sbusinesstopreventsuchtrade,theypractiseditattheirownrisk,subjecttowell-understoodpenaltiesagreeduponamongnations。Themerchantsneverthelesscontinuedtotaketherisk,whileboththeyandtheauthoritiesoftheConfederacythoughttheysawawayofminimizingthedanger。InsteadofshippingsuppliesdirecttotheConfederateportstheyshippedthemtoMatamoros,inMexico,ortotheWestIndies。Astheseportswereinneutralterritory,themerchantsthoughttheirgoodswouldbesafeagainstcaptureuntiltheylefttheMexicanorWestIndianportontheirbriefconcludingpassagetotheterritoryoftheConfederacy。Nassau,thenapettyWestIndiatown,wasthechiefdepotofsuchtradeandsoonbecameagreatcommercialcenter。
ToitcamevastquantitiesofEuropeangoodswhichwerethentransferredtoswift,smallvessels,or\"blockade-runners,\"whichtookagambler\'schanceandoftensucceededineludingtheFederalpatrolshipsandinrushingtheircargoessafeintoaConfederateport。
Obviously,itwasagreatdisadvantagetotheUnitedStatestoallowcontrabandsuppliestobeaccumulated,withoutinterference,closetotheblockadedcoast,andtheLincolnGovernmentdeterminedtoremovethisdisadvantage。Withthisendinviewitevokedtheprincipleofthecontinuousvoyage,whichindeedwasnotnew,butwhichwasdestinedtobecomefixedininternationallawbytheSupremeCourtoftheUnitedStates。
AmericancruiserswereinstructedtostopBritishshipssailingbetweentheBritishportsofLiverpoolandNassau;theyweretousetherecognizedinternationalrightsofvisitandsearch;andiftherewasevidencethatthecargowasnotdestinedforactualconsumptionatNassau,theyweretobringtheshipintoanAmericanporttobedealtwithbyanAmericanprizecourt。Whensucharrestsbegan,theownersclamoredtotheBritishGovernment,andbothdealersincontrabandandprofessionalblockade-runnersworkedthemselvesintoafurybecauseAmericancruiserswatchedBritishportsandsearchedBritishshipsonthehighseas。Withregardtothismatter,theBritishGovernmentandtheGovernmentatWashingtonhadtheirlastimportantcorrespondenceduringthewar。TheUnitedStatesstoodfirmfortheideathatwhengoodswereultimatelyintendedfortheConfederacy,nomatterhowroundaboutthejourney,theycouldbeconsideredasmakingasinglecontinuousvoyageandwereliabletocapturefromthedaytheyleftLiverpool。Earlyin1865,theSupremeCourtoftheUnitedStatesfullydevelopedtheprincipleofcontinuousvoyageinfourcelebratedcasesthatarenowamongthelandmarksofinternationallaw。*
*TheGreatwarhasonceagainledtocontroversyoverthissubject,sovitaltoneutralstates。
Thiswasthelaststepinmakingtheblockadeeffective。
Thereafter,itslowlystrangledtheSouth。TheFederalarmiesenormouslyovermatchedtheSouthern,andfromNovember,1864,theircontinuanceinthefieldwasmadesure。GrimworkstilllaybeforeLincoln,butthedayofanxietywaspast。Inthismomentofcomparativeease,theagedChiefJusticeTaneydied,andLincolnappointedtothathighpositionhisungenerousrival,Chase。
EvennowLincolnhadnotestablishedhimselfasaleadersuperiortoparty,buthehadthesatisfaction,earlyin1865,ofseeingtheranksoftheoppositionbegintobreak。Naturally,theThirteenthAmendmenttotheConstitution,abolishingslaverythroughouttheUnitedStates,appearedtoLincolnasinawaytheconsummationofhislabors。WhentheHousevotedontheresolutiontosendthisamendmenttotheStates,severalDemocratsjoinedthegovernmentforces。Twonightsafterward,speakingtoaserenadingpartyattheWhiteHouse,Lincolnmadeabriefspeech,partofwhichisthusreportedbyhissecretaries:
\"Hethoughtthismeasurewasaveryfittingifnotanindispensableadjuncttothewindingupofthegreatdifficulty。
HewishedthereunionofalltheStatesperfected,andsoeffectedastoremoveallcausesofdisturbanceinthefuture;
andtoattainthisend,itwasnecessarythattheoriginaldisturbingcauseshould,ifpossible,berootedout。\"
AneventwhichinitsfulldetailbelongstoConfederateratherthantoUnionhistorytookplacesoonafterthis。AtHamptonRoads,LincolnandSewardmetConfederatecommissionerswhohadaskedforaparley——withregardtopeace。Nothingcameofthemeeting,buttheconferencegaverisetoalegend,falseinfactandyettrueinspirit,accordingtowhichLincolnwroteonasheetofpapertheword\"Union,\"pusheditacrosstoAlexanderH。
Stephensandsaid,\"Writeunderthatanythingyouplease。\"
ThisfictionexpressesLincoln\'sattitudetowardthesinkingConfederacy。OnhisreturnfromHamptonRoadshesubmittedtohisCabinetadraftofamessagewhichheproposedtosendtoCongress。Herecommendedtheappropriationof$400,000,000tobedistributedamongtheslavestatesonconditionthatwarceasebeforeApril1,1865。NotamemberoftheCabinetapproved。Hissecretary,Mr。Nicolay,writes:\"ThePresident,inevidentsurpriseandsorrowatthewantofstatesmanlikeliberalityshownbyhisexecutivecouncil,foldedandlaidawaythedraftofhismessage……\"Withadeepsighheadded,\"Butyouareallopposedtome,andIwillnotsendthemessage。\"
Hissecondinaugurationpassedwithoutstrikingincidents。
Chase,asChiefJustice,administeredtheoath。Thesecondinauguraladdresscontainedwordswhicharenowfamous:\"Withmalicetowardsnone;withcharityforall;withfirmnessintheright,asGodgivesustoseetheright,letusstriveontofinishtheworkwearein;tobindupthenation\'swounds;tocareforhimwhoshallhavebornethebattle,andforhiswidow,andhisorphan——todoallwhichmayachieveandcherishajustandalastingpeaceamongourselves,andwithallnations。\"
Thatgiganticsystemoffleetsandarmies,thecreationofwhichwasduetoLincoln,wasclosingtightaroundthedyingConfederacy。FiveweeksaftertheinaugurationLeesurrendered,andthewarwasvirtuallyatanend。Whatwastocomeafterwasinevitablytheovershadowingtopicofthehour。ManyanecdotesrepresentLincoln,intheselastfewdaysofhislife,aspossessedbyahighthoughmelancholymoodofextrememercy。
Therefore,muchhasbeeninferredfromthefollowingwords,inhislastpublicaddress,madeonthenightofthe11thofApril:
\"Inthepresentsituation,asthephrasegoes,itmaybemydutytomakesomenewannouncementtothepeopleoftheSouth。Iamconsideringandshallnotfailtoactwhenactionshallbeproper。\"
WhatwastobedonefortheSouth,whattreatmentshouldbeaccordedtheSouthernleaders,engrossedthePresidentandhisCabinetatthemeetingonthe14thofApril,whichwasdestinedtobetheirlast。SecretaryWelleshaspreservedthespiritofthemeetinginastrikinganecdote。Lincolnsaidthatnooneneedexpecthewould\"takeanypartinhangingorkillingthosemen,eventheworstofthem。Frightenthemoutofthecountry,openthegates,letdownthebars,scarethemoff;\"saidhe,throwinguphishandsasifscaringsheep。\"Enoughliveshavebeensacrificed;wemustextinguishourresentmentsifweexpectharmonyandunion。\"
WhileLincolnwasthusarminghimselfwithavaliantmercy,abandofconspiratorsatanobscureboardinghouseinWashingtonwereplanninghisassassination。TheirleaderwasJohnWilkesBooth,anactor,brotherofthemuchablerEdwinBooth。Thereseemslittledoubtthathewasinsane。AroundhimgatheredasmallgroupofvisionaryextremistsinwhommuchbroodinguponSouthernwrongshadproducedanunbalancedcondition。OnlyamorbidinterestcanattachtodaytothestrangecunningwithwhichBoothlaidhisplans,thinkingofhimselfallthewhileasareincarnationoftheRomanBrutus。
Onthenightofthe14thofApril,thePresidentattendedaperformanceof\"OurAmericanCousin\"。Whiletheplaywasinprogress,BoothstoleintothePresident\'sbox,cameclosebehindhim,andshothimthroughthehead。Lincolnneverspokeagainand,shortlyaftersevennextmorning,ceasedbreathing。
Atthesametime,afutileattemptwasmadeuponthelifeofSeward。Boothtemporarilyescaped。Laterhewasovertakenandshot。Hisaccompliceswerehanged。
ThepassageofsixtyyearshasprovedfullynecessarytotheplacingofLincolninhistoricperspective。NoPresident,inhisowntime,withthepossibleexceptionofWashington,wassobitterlyhatedandsofiercelyreviled。Ontheotherhand,nonehasbeentheobjectofsuchintemperatehero-worship。However,thegreatestofthelandwere,inthemain,quicktoseehiminperspectiveandtorecognizehishistoricsignificance。ItisrecordedofDavisthatinafterdayshepaidabeautifultributetoLincolnandsaid,\"NexttothedestructionoftheConfederacy,thedeathofAbrahamLincolnwasthedarkestdaytheSouthhasknown。\"
BIBLIOGRAPHICALNOTE
Therearetwogeneralhistories,ofconspicuousability,thatdealwiththisperiod:
J。F。Rhodes,\"HistoryoftheUnitedStatesfromtheCompromiseof1850\",7vols。1893-1906,andJ。B。McMaster,\"HistoryofthePeopleoftheUnitedStates\",7vols。1883-1912。McMasterhasthemore\"modern\"pointofviewandisexcellentbutdry,withoutanysenseofnarrative。Rhodeshasasomewhatolderpointofview。Forexample,hemakesonlyacasualreference,inaquotation,tothemunitionsproblemof1861,thoughanalyzingwithgreatforceandcandorsuchconstitutionalissuesasthearrestsunderthesuspensionofthewritofhabeascorpus。Theotherstrongpointsinhisworkareitssenseofnarrative,itsfreedomfromhero-worship,itsindependenceofconventionalviewsofNorthernleaders。AstotheSouth,itsuffersfromacertainNarrownessofvisionduetothecomparativescantinessofthematerialused。ThesamemaybesaidofMcMaster。
ForLincoln,thereisnoadequatebriefbiography。Perhapsthebestisthemostrecent,\"AbrahamLincoln\",byLordCharnwood\"MakersoftheNineteenthCentury\",1917。Ithasakindofcooldetachmentthathardlyanybiographerhadshownpreviously,andyetthiscoolnessisjoinedwithextremeadmiration。ShortbiographiesworthconsideringareJohnT。Morse,Jr。,AbrahamLincoln\"\"AmericanStatesmen\"Series,2vols。,1893,andIdaM。
Tarbell,\"LifeofAbrahamLincoln\",2vols。1900。Theofficialbiographyisintenvolumes,\"AbrahamLincoln,aHistory\",byhissecretaries,JohnG。NicolayandJohnHay1890。Itisapricelessdocumentandassuchislittlelikelytobeforgotten。
ButitseventsaresonumerousthattheyswampthefigureofLincolnandyetarenotnumerousenoughtoconstituteadefinitivehistoryofthetimes。Itiswhollyeulogistic。Thesameauthorsedited\"TheWritingsofAbrahamLincoln\"
BiographicalEdition,2vols。,1894,whichhassincebeenexpanded1905andnowfillstwelvevolumes。ItisthedefinitivepresentationofLincoln\'smind。AbookmuchsoughtafterbyhisenemiesisWilliamHenryHerndonandJesseWilliamWeik,\"TheHistoryandPersonalRecollectionsofAbrahamLincoln\",8vols。1889;unexpurgatededition。Itcontainsaboutallweknowofhisearlylifeandpaintsapictureofsordidugliness。Itsreliabilityhasbeendisputed。NostudyofLincolniscompleteunlessonehasmarchedthroughthe\"Diary\"ofGideonWelles,SecretaryoftheNavy,3vols。1911,whichisourmostimportantdocumentshowingLincolninhisCabinet。
ImportantsidelightsonhischaracteranddevelopmentareshowninWardHillLamon,\"RecollectionsofLincoln\"1911;DavidHomerBates,\"LincolnintheTelegraphOffice\"1907;andFrederickTrevorHill,\"LincolnasaLawyer\"1906。A
bibliographyofLincolnisinthetwelfthvolumeofthelatesteditionofthe\"Writings\"。
Thelesserstatesmenofthetime,bothNorthernandSouthern,still,asarule,awaitpropertreatmentbydetachedbiographers。
TwoNorthernershavehadsuchtreatment,inAllenJohnson\'s\"StephenA。Douglas\"1908,andFredericBancroft\'s\"LifeofWilliamH。Seward\",2vols。1900。Good,butwithouttherequisitedetachment,isMoorfieldStorey\'s\"CharlesSumner\",\"AmericanStatesmenSeries\",1900。Withsimilarexcellencesbutwiththesamedefect,thoughstillthebestinitsfield,isAlbertBushnellHart\'s\"SalmonP。Chase\"\"AmericanStatesmenSeries\",1899。AmongtheSouthernstatesmeninvolvedintheeventsofthisvolume,onlythePresidentoftheConfederacyhasreceivedadequatereconsiderationinrecentyears,inWilliamE。
Dodd\'s\"JeffersonDavis\"1907。Thelatestlifeof\"RobertToombs\",byUlrichB。Phillips1914,isnotdefinitive,butthebestextant。ThegreatneedforadequatelivesofStephensandYanceyisnotatallmetbytheobsoleteworks——R。M。JohnstonandW。M。Browne,\"LifeofAlexanderH。Stephens\"1878,andJ。
W。DuBose,\"TheLifeandTimesofWilliamLowndesYancey\"
1892。ThereisabriefbiographyofStephensbyLouisPendleton,inthe\"AmericanCrisisBiographies\"。Mostoftheremainingbiographiesoftheperiod,whetherNorthernorSouthern,areeithertoosuperficialortoopartisantoberecommendedforgeneraluse。Almostaloneintheirwayarethedelightful\"ConfederatePortraits\",byGamalielBradford1914,andthesameauthor\'s\"UnionPortraits\"1916。
UponconditionsintheNorthduringthewarthereisavastamountofmaterial;butlittleisaccessibletothegeneralreader。AbookofgreatvalueisEmersonFite\'sSocialandIndustrialConditionsintheNorthduringtheCivilWar1910。
Outofunnumberedbooksofreminiscence,onestandsforthforthesincerityofitsdisinterested,ifsharp,observation——W。H。
Russell\'s\"MyDiaryNorthandSouth\"1868。Twonewspapersareinvaluable:The\"NewYorkTribune\"foraversionofeventsasseenbythewarparty,\"TheNewYorkHerald\"fortheoppositepointofview;theChicagopapersarealsoimportant,chieflythe\"Times\"and\"Tribune\";the\"Republican\"ofSpringfield,Mass。,hadbegunitsdistinguishedcareer,whilethe\"Journal\"and\"Advertiser\"ofBostonrevealedEasternNewEngland。FortheSouthernpointofview,nopapersaremoreimportantthantheRichmond\"Examiner\",theCharleston\"Mercury\",andtheNewOrleans\"Picayune\"。FinancialandeconomicproblemsarewellsummedupinD。R。Dewey\'s\"FinancialHistoryoftheUnitedStates\"3dedition,1907,andinE。P。Oberholzer\'s\"JayCooks\",2vols。1907。ForeignaffairsaresummarizedadequatelyinC。F。Adams\'s\"CharlesFrancisAdams\"\"AmericanStatesmenSeries\",1900,JohnBigelow\'s\"FranceandtheConfederateNavy\"1888,A。P。Martin\'s\"MaximilianinMexico\"
1914,andJohnBassettMoore\'s\"DigestofInternationalLaw\",8
vols。1906。
Thedocumentsoftheperiodrangingfromnewspaperstopresidentialmessagesarenotlikelytobeconsideredbythegeneralreader,butifgivenafairchancewillprovefascinating。BesidesthebiographicaleditionofLincoln\'sWritings,shouldbenamed,firstofall,\"TheCongressionalGlobe\"fordebatesinCongress;the\"StatutesatLarge\";the\"ExecutiveDocuments\",publishedbytheGovernmentandcontainingagreatnumberofreports;andtheenormouscollectionissuedbytheWarDepartmentunderthetitle\"OfficialRecordsoftheUnionandConfederateArmies\",128vols。1880-1901,especiallythegroupsofvolumesknownassecondandthirdseries。