IwillventuretosayanotherwordupontheuniformityofNaturedifficulty。Itiseasy,saysMill,toconceiveofthingshappeningatrandom。Itis,indeed,inonesenseperfectlyeasy。
’Raw’things,orunanalysedconcreteevents,dohappenatrandom,thatis,withoutuniformantecedents。Nothingiseasierthantothinkofthingswithoutthinkingoftheircauses。Theprimitivemind,andeventhecultivatedmind,maysimplywatchtheseriesofeventswithouttryingtofindanyconnectionorindulginginanyreasoning。Butthisisquitedifferentfromthinkingofthingsaspositivelyuncaused。Aphenomenonsuddenlyintrudeswithoutwarning。Imayacceptitwithoutaskingwhenceitcomes,orwhy。Butthereisnoreallypositivemeaninginthestatementthatitiscausedby’nothing。’Itdoesnotimplyacontradiction,suchasoccurswhenIputtogetherthewordscrookedandstraight,roundandsquare;butitrepresentsnointelligiblemeaning。Itcorrespondstoasimpleabsenceofthought。WhenIspeakoftheuniformityofNature,ImeansimplytoindicateaconditionofthinkingaboutNatureatall。Imayceasetoreasonortothink;butifIthink,Imustthinkcoherently,andassumewhathasbeencalledthe’UniversalPostulate。’92*Thephraseseemstometobeinadequate;andatanyrateitisapostulatewiththispeculiarity,thatwecannotmakeanyother。Todenyitistoallowcontradictorystatementsonthemostintimatetissueofourreasoning。Itisasimpossibletodowithoutitastodowithouttheprincipleofcontradictioninpurelogic。Ithelpsustonopositivestatement;butitisawarningthatourstatementsmustbecoherent。Hence,wemustallowthemindtohavethismodestcapacityforworkingupitsexperience。Ifitstartsfromsounprejudicedapointofviewastoadmitcontradictions,orallowofinconsistentstatementsaboutthings,itwillneverbeabletogetanywhere,andwhenMillhasreducedallourknowledgetotherelationsbetweenideasinthemind,itisreallyquiteinconsistenttoallowthemindnopowerofputtingideastogether。Withoutsuchapoweritisdifficulttosaywhatisevenmeantbytheperceptionof’coexistences’and’sequences。’Theprogressofknowledge,then,mustbeunderstoodascorrespondingtotheprocessbywhichthechaosofimpressionsandideasisgraduallyreducedtocosmos;
andasstartingfromapositioninwhichnocausehasbeenyetdiscoveredforgreatmassesoffacts,notfromapositioninwhich’nocause’isanequallyprobablealternativewith’somecause。’Toreasonatallaboutfactsistoarrangetheminorderofcausation,andtosupposethemashavingcertaintime-andspace-relations。Togetbehindthatprimitivegermofreasoningisreallytomakelogicimpossiblefromthestart。Mill’sdreadofaprioriintuitionsandnecessaryresultsthusledhimintoperfectlygratuitousdifficulties。Grantingthe’necessity’ofarithmeticorgeometry,itisstillahypotheticalnecessity。Itcannevertakeusbeyondexperience。Suchtheoremscannottellusoftheexistenceofasinglethingorofitsnature。Theycanonlysaythatifweseethingsinspacetheywillhavecertainrelationswhicharededuciblefromthespecialconfirmation。
Withoutthatpowertheuniversewouldbeundecipherable,butwithitourknowledgestillhasthroughoutacompletelyempiricalbase。Notasinglestatementoffactcanbemadewhichisnotderivedfrom,andjustifiedby,experience;norcanourexperienceevergetbeyondsayingthatanygivensectionofthewholeisdevelopedoutof,anddevelopsinto,precedingandsucceedingsections。
VIII。THEFOURMETHODS
......购买会员看全站小说,或者下载APP免费观看所有作品 点击立即下载,搜索"John Stuart Mill",免费读到尾