第29章
加入书架 A- A+
点击下载App,搜索"METAPHYSICS",免费读到尾

  WEhavetreatedofthatwhichisprimarilyandtowhichallthe

  othercategoriesofbeingarereferred-i。e。ofsubstance。Foritisin

  virtueoftheconceptofsubstancethattheothersalsoaresaidto

  be-quantityandqualityandthelike;forallwillbefoundtoinvolve

  theconceptofsubstance,aswesaidinthefirstpartofourwork。

  Andsince’being’isinonewaydividedintoindividualthing,

  quality,andquantity,andisinanotherwaydistinguishedin

  respectofpotencyandcompletereality,andoffunction,letusnow

  addadiscussionofpotencyandcompletereality。Andfirstletus

  explainpotencyinthestrictestsense,whichis,however,notthe

  mostusefulforourpresentpurpose。Forpotencyandactuality

  extendbeyondthecasesthatinvolveareferencetomotion。Butwhen

  wehavespokenofthisfirstkind,weshallinourdiscussionsof

  actuality’explaintheotherkindsofpotencyaswell。

  Wehavepointedoutelsewherethat’potency’andtheword’can’

  haveseveralsenses。Ofthesewemayneglectallthepotenciesthat

  aresocalledbyanequivocation。Forsomearecalledsobyanalogy,

  asingeometrywesayonethingisorisnota’power’ofanotherby

  virtueofthepresenceorabsenceofsomerelationbetweenthem。But

  allpotenciesthatconformtothesametypeareoriginativesourcesof

  somekind,andarecalledpotenciesinreferencetooneprimarykind

  ofpotency,whichisanoriginativesourceofchangeinanother

  thingorinthethingitselfquaother。Foronekindisapotencyof

  beingactedon,i。e。theoriginativesource,intheverythingacted

  on,ofitsbeingpassivelychangedbyanotherthingorbyitselfqua

  other;andanotherkindisastateofinsusceptibilitytochangefor

  theworseandtodestructionbyanotherthingorbythethingitself

  quaotherbyvirtueofanoriginativesourceofchange。Inallthese

  definitionsisimpliedtheformulaifpotencyintheprimary

  sense-Andagaintheseso-calledpotenciesarepotencieseitherof

  merelyactingorbeingactedon,orofactingorbeingactedon

  well,sothatevenintheformulaeofthelattertheformulaeofthe

  priorkindsofpotencyaresomehowimplied。

  Obviously,then,inasensethepotencyofactingandofbeing

  actedonisoneforathingmaybe’capable’eitherbecauseitcan

  itselfbeactedonorbecausesomethingelsecanbeactedonbyit,

  butinasensethepotenciesaredifferent。Fortheoneisinthe

  thingactedon;itisbecauseitcontainsacertainoriginative

  source,andbecauseeventhematterisanoriginativesource,thatthe

  thingactedonisactedon,andonethingbyone,anotherby

  another;forthatwhichisoilycanbeburnt,andthatwhichyieldsin

  aparticularwaycanbecrushed;andsimilarlyinallothercases。But

  theotherpotencyisintheagent,e。g。heatandtheartofbuilding

  arepresent,oneinthatwhichcanproduceheatandtheotherinthe

  manwhocanbuild。Andso,insofarasathingisanorganicunity,

  itcannotbeactedonbyitself;foritisoneandnottwodifferent

  things。And’impotence’and’impotent’standfortheprivationwhichis

  contrarytopotencyofthissort,sothateverypotencybelongstothe

  samesubjectandreferstothesameprocessasacorresponding

  impotence。Privationhasseveralsenses;foritmeans1thatwhich

  hasnotacertainqualityand2thatwhichmightnaturallyhaveit

  buthasnotit,eitheraingeneralorbwhenitmightnaturally

  haveit,andeitherainsomeparticularway,e。g。whenithasnot

  itcompletely,orbwhenithasnotitatall。Andincertain

  casesifthingswhichnaturallyhaveaqualityloseitbyviolence,we

  saytheyhavesufferedprivation。

  Sincesomesuchoriginativesourcesarepresentinsoulless

  things,andothersinthingspossessedofsoul,andinsoul,andin

  therationalpartofthesoul,clearlysomepotencieswill,be

  non-rationalandsomewillbenon-rationalandsomewillbe

  accompaniedbyarationalformula。Thisiswhyallarts,i。e。all

  productiveformsofknowledge,arepotencies;theyareoriginative

  sourcesofchangeinanotherthingorintheartisthimselfconsidered

  asother。

  Andeachofthosewhichareaccompaniedbyarationalformulais

  alikecapableofcontraryeffects,butonenon-rationalpowerproduces

  oneeffect;e。g。thehotiscapableonlyofheating,butthemedical

  artcanproducebothdiseaseandhealth。Thereasonisthatscienceis

  arationalformula,andthesamerationalformulaexplainsathingand

  itsprivation,onlynotinthesameway;andinasenseitapplies

  toboth,butinasenseitappliesrathertothepositivefact。

  Thereforesuchsciencesmustdealwithcontraries,butwithonein

  virtueoftheirownnatureandwiththeothernotinvirtueoftheir

  nature;fortherationalformulaappliestooneobjectinvirtueof

  thatobject’snature,andtotheother,inasense,accidentally。

  Foritisbydenialandremovalthatitexhibitsthecontrary;forthe

  contraryistheprimaryprivation,andthisistheremovalofthe

  positiveterm。Nowsincecontrariesdonotoccurinthesamething,

  butscienceisapotencywhichdependsonthepossessionofarational

  formula,andthesoulpossessesanoriginativesourceofmovement;

  therefore,whilethewholesomeproducesonlyhealthandthe

  calorificonlyheatandthefrigorificonlycold,thescientificman

  producesboththecontraryeffects。Fortherationalformulaisone

  whichappliestoboth,thoughnotinthesameway,anditisinasoul

  whichpossessesanoriginativesourceofmovement;sothatthesoul

  willstartbothprocessesfromthesameoriginativesource,having

  linkedthemupwiththesamething。Andsothethingswhosepotencyis

  accordingtoarationalformulaactcontrariwisetothethingswhose

  potencyisnon-rational;fortheproductsoftheformerareincluded

  underoneoriginativesource,therationalformula。

  Itisobviousalsothatthepotencyofmerelydoingathingor

  havingitdonetooneisimpliedinthatofdoingitorhavingitdone

  well,butthelatterisnotalwaysimpliedintheformer:forhewho

  doesathingwellmustalsodoit,buthewhodoesitmerelyneed

  notalsodoitwell。

  Therearesomewhosay,astheMegaricschooldoes,thatathing

  ’can’actonlywhenitisacting,andwhenitisnotactingit

  ’cannot’act,e。g。thathewhoisnotbuildingcannotbuild,but

  onlyhewhoisbuilding,whenheisbuilding;andsoinallother

  cases。Itisnothardtoseetheabsurditiesthatattendthisview。

  Foritisclearthatonthisviewamanwillnotbeabuilder

  unlessheisbuildingfortobeabuilderistobeabletobuild,

  andsowiththeotherarts。If,then,itisimpossibletohavesuch

  artsifonehasnotatsometimelearntandacquiredthem,anditis

  thenimpossiblenottohavethemifonehasnotsometimelostthem

  eitherbyforgetfulnessorbysomeaccidentorbytime;foritcannot

  bebythedestructionoftheobject,forthatlastsforever,aman

  willnothavetheartwhenhehasceasedtouseit,andyethemay

  immediatelybuildagain;howthenwillhehavegottheart?And

  similarlywithregardtolifelessthings;nothingwillbeeither

  coldorhotorsweetorperceptibleatallifpeoplearenot

  perceivingit;sothattheupholdersofthisviewwillhaveto

  maintainthedoctrineofProtagoras。But,indeed,nothingwilleven

  haveperceptionifitisnotperceiving,i。e。exercisingits

  perception。If,then,thatisblindwhichhasnotsightthoughit

  wouldnaturallyhaveit,whenitwouldnaturallyhaveitandwhenit

  stillexists,thesamepeoplewillbeblindmanytimesinthe

  day-anddeaftoo。

  Again,ifthatwhichisdeprivedofpotencyisincapable,that

  whichisnothappeningwillbeincapableofhappening;buthewhosays

  ofthatwhichisincapableofhappeningeitherthatitisorthatit

  willbewillsaywhatisuntrue;forthisiswhatincapacitymeant。

  Thereforetheseviewsdoawaywithbothmovementandbecoming。For

  thatwhichstandswillalwaysstand,andthatwhichsitswillalways

  sit,sinceifitissittingitwillnotgetup;forthatwhich,as

  wearetold,cannotgetupwillbeincapableofgettingup。Butwe

  cannotsaythis,sothatevidentlypotencyandactualityaredifferent

  buttheseviewsmakepotencyandactualitythesame,andsoitis

  nosmallthingtheyareseekingtoannihilate,sothatitispossible

  thatathingmaybecapableofbeingandnothe,andcapableofnot

  beingandyethe,andsimilarlywiththeotherkindsofpredicate;

  itmaybecapableofwalkingandyetnotwalk,orcapableofnot

  walkingandyetwalk。Andathingiscapableofdoingsomethingif

  therewillbenothingimpossibleinitshavingtheactualityofthat

  ofwhichitissaidtohavethecapacity。Imean,forinstance,ifa

  thingiscapableofsittinganditisopentoittosit,therewillbe

  nothingimpossibleinitsactuallysitting;andsimilarlyifitis

  capableofbeingmovedormoving,orofstandingormakingtostand,

  orofbeingorcomingtobe,orofnotbeingornotcomingtobe。

  Theword’actuality’,whichweconnectwith’completereality’,

  has,inthemain,beenextendedfrommovementstootherthings;for

  actualityinthestrictsenseisthoughttobeidenticalwith

  movement。Andsopeopledonotassignmovementtonon-existentthings,

  thoughtheydoassignsomeotherpredicates。E。g。theysaythat

  non-existentthingsareobjectsofthoughtanddesire,butnotthat

  theyaremoved;andthisbecause,whileexhypothesitheydonot

  actuallyexist,theywouldhavetoexistactuallyiftheywere

  moved。Forofnon-existentthingssomeexistpotentially;butthey

  donotexist,becausetheydonotexistincompletereality。

  Ifwhatwehavedescribedisidenticalwiththecapableor

  convertiblewithit,evidentlyitcannotbetruetosay’thisis

  capableofbeingbutwillnotbe’,whichwouldimplythatthethings

  incapableofbeingwouldonthisshowingvanish。Suppose,for

  instance,thataman-onewhodidnottakeaccountofthatwhichis

  incapableofbeing-weretosaythatthediagonalofthesquareis

  capableofbeingmeasuredbutwillnotbemeasured,becauseathing

  maywellbecapableofbeingorcomingtobe,andyetnotbeorbe

  abouttobe。Butfromthepremissesthisnecessarilyfollows,that

  ifweactuallysupposedthatwhichisnot,butiscapableofbeing,to

  beortohavecometobe,therewillbenothingimpossibleinthis;

  buttheresultwillbeimpossible,forthemeasuringofthediagonal

  isimpossible。Forthefalseandtheimpossiblearenotthesame;that

  youarestandingnowisfalse,butthatyoushouldbestandingis

  notimpossible。

  Atthesametimeitisclearthatif,whenAisreal,Bmustbe

  real,then,whenAispossible,Balsomustbepossible。ForifBneed

  notbepossible,thereisnothingtopreventitsnotbeingpossible。

  NowletAbesupposedpossible。Then,whenAwaspossible,weagreed

  thatnothingimpossiblefollowedifAweresupposedtobereal;and

  thenBmustofcoursebereal。ButwesupposedBtobeimpossible。Let

  itbeimpossiblethen。If,then,Bisimpossible,Aalsomustbeso。

  Butthefirstwassupposedimpossible;thereforethesecondalsois

  impossible。If,then,Aispossible,Balsowillbepossible,if

  theyweresorelatedthatifA,isreal,Bmustbereal。If,then,A

  andBbeingthusrelated,Bisnotpossibleonthiscondition,andB

  willnotberelatedaswassupposed。AndifwhenAispossible,Bmust

  bepossible,thenifAisreal,Balsomustbereal。FortosaythatB

  mustbepossible,ifAispossible,meansthis,thatifAisrealboth

  atthetimewhenandinthewayinwhichitwassupposedcapableof

  beingreal,Balsomustthenandinthatwaybereal。

点击下载App,搜索"METAPHYSICS",免费读到尾