TheintrigantsofautocraticsystemshaveneverbeenabletounderstandthattheurgeofthespiritofindependenceinmenisnotprimarilytobreakshacklesbuttoSTANDALONEandthatthebreakingofbondsisincidentaltothetruedemonstrationoffreedom。TheBourbonsandtheiragentswerenomorenorlessblindtothegreatprinciplestirringtheheartsofmenintheirdaythanwerethePrussianizedhostsoverahundredyearslaterwho,havingthemselvesnoacquaintancewiththelawofliberty,couldnotforeseethathalfaworldwouldriseinarmstomaintainthatlaw。
WhentheWarofIndependencehadended,theFrenchMinister,Vergennes,andtheSpanishMinister,Floridablanca,secretlyworkedinunisontopreventEngland’srecognitionofthenewrepublic;andFloridablancain1782evenofferedtoassistEnglandifshewouldmakefurthereffortstosubdueher\"rebelsubjects。\"BothLatinpowershadtheirownaxestogrind,andAmericawastotendthegrindstone。FrancelookedforrecoveryofheroldprestigeinEuropeandexpectedtosupersedeEnglandincommerce。Shewoulddothis,inthebeginning,chieflythroughcontrolofAmericaandofAmerica’scommerce。VergennesthereforesoughtnotonlytodictatethefinaltermsofpeacebutalsotosaywhattheAmericancommissionersshouldandshouldnotdemand。
Ofthelattergentlemenhesaidthattheypossessed\"caracterespeumaniables!\"InwritingtoLuzerne,theFrenchAmbassadorinPhiladelphia,onOctober14,1782,Vergennessaid:\"itbehoovesustoleavethem[theAmericancommissioners]totheirillusions,todoeverythingthatcanmakethemfancythatwesharethem,andundertakeonlytodefeatanyattemptstowhichthoseillusionsmightcarrythemifourcooperationisrequired。\"Amongthese\"illusions\"wereAmerica’sdesiresinregardtothefisheriesandtothewesternterritory。ConcerningtheWest,VergenneshadwrittentoLuzerne,asearlyasJuly18,1780:\"Atthemomentwhentherevolutionbrokeout,thelimitsoftheThirteenStatesdidnotreachtheRiver[Mississippi]anditwouldbeabsurdforthemtoclaimtherightsofEngland,apowerwhoseruletheyhadabjured。\"BythesecrettreatywithSpain,furthermore,FrancehadagreedtocontinuethewaruntilGibraltarshouldbetaken,and——iftheBritishshouldbedrivenfromNewfoundland——tosharethefisheriesonlywithSpain,andtosupportSpainindemandingthattheThirteenStatesrenounceallterritorywestoftheAlleghanies。TheAmericanStatesmustbynomeansachieveagenuineindependencebutmustfeeltheneedofsureties,allies,andprotection。*
*SeeJohnJay,\"OnthePeaceNegotiationsof1782-1788asIllustratedbytheSecretCorrespondenceofFranceandEngland,\"
NewYork,1888。