CATEGORIES

第2章

试读中

第2章

CATEGORIES Aristotle translated by E.M.Ed

后面的故事,去 App 接着看,下载后搜索书名即可继续阅读。

CATEGORIES
阅读主题
字体大小

  Itmaybequestionedwhetheritistruethatnosubstanceisrelative,asseemstobethecase,orwhetherexceptionistobemadeinthecaseofcertainsecondarysubstances。Withregardtoprimarysubstances,itisquitetruethatthereisnosuchpossibility,forneitherwholesnorpartsofprimarysubstancesarerelative。Theindividualmanoroxisnotdefinedwithreferencetosomethingexternal。Similarlywiththeparts:aparticularhandorheadisnotdefinedasaparticularhandorheadofaparticularperson,butasthehandorheadofaparticularperson。Itistruealso,forthemostpartatleast,inthecaseofsecondarysubstances;

  thespecies\'man\'andthespecies\'ox\'arenotdefinedwithreferencetoanythingoutsidethemselves。Wood,again,isonlyrelativeinsofarasitissomeone\'sproperty,notinsofarasitiswood。Itisplain,then,thatinthecasesmentionedsubstanceisnotrelative。Butwithregardtosomesecondarysubstancesthereisadifferenceofopinion;thus,suchtermsas\'head\'and\'hand\'aredefinedwithreferencetothatofwhichthethingsindicatedareapart,andsoitcomesaboutthattheseappeartohavearelativecharacter。Indeed,ifourdefinitionofthatwhichisrelativewascomplete,itisverydifficult,ifnotimpossible,toprovethatnosubstanceisrelative。If,however,ourdefinitionwasnotcomplete,ifthosethingsonlyareproperlycalledrelativeinthecaseofwhichrelationtoanexternalobjectisanecessaryconditionofexistence,perhapssomeexplanationofthedilemmamaybefound。

  Theformerdefinitiondoesindeedapplytoallrelatives,butthefactthatathingisexplainedwithreferencetosomethingelsedoesnotmakeitessentiallyrelative。

  Fromthisitisplainthat,ifamandefinitelyapprehendsarelativething,hewillalsodefinitelyapprehendthattowhichitisrelative。Indeedthisisself-evident:forifamanknowsthatsomeparticularthingisrelative,assumingthatwecallthatarelativeinthecaseofwhichrelationtosomethingisanecessaryconditionofexistence,heknowsthatalsotowhichitisrelated。Forifhedoesnotknowatallthattowhichitisrelated,hewillnotknowwhetherornotitisrelative。Thisisclear,moreover,inparticularinstances。Ifamanknowsdefinitelythatsuchandsuchathingis\'double\',hewillalsoforthwithknowdefinitelythatofwhichitisthedouble。Forifthereisnothingdefiniteofwhichheknowsittobethedouble,hedoesnotknowatallthatitisdouble。Again,ifheknowsthatathingismorebeautiful,itfollowsnecessarilythathewillforthwithdefinitelyknowthatalsothanwhichitismorebeautiful。Hewillnotmerelyknowindefinitelythatitismorebeautifulthansomethingwhichislessbeautiful,forthiswouldbesupposition,notknowledge。Forifhedoesnotknowdefinitelythatthanwhichitismorebeautiful,hecannolongerclaimtoknowdefinitelythatitismorebeautifulthansomethingelsewhichislessbeautiful:foritmightbethatnothingwaslessbeautiful。Itis,therefore,evidentthatifamanapprehendssomerelativethingdefinitely,henecessarilyknowsthatalsodefinitelytowhichitisrelated。

  Nowthehead,thehand,andsuchthingsaresubstances,anditispossibletoknowtheiressentialcharacterdefinitely,butitdoesnotnecessarilyfollowthatweshouldknowthattowhichtheyarerelated。

后续内容在 App 继续看

精彩内容未完,打开 App 继续阅读

后面的故事已为你准备好,下载 App 后搜索“CATEGORIES”即可继续阅读这一章。