Itisnotsurprisingthatthedegreeofdifficultyinunitingtwospecies,andthedegreeofsterilityoftheirhybridoffspring,shouldgenerallycorrespond,thoughduetodistinctcauses;forbothdependontheamountofdifferenceofsomekindbetweenthespecieswhicharecrossed。Norisitsurprisingthatthefacilityofeffectingafirstcross,thefertilityofhybridsproducedfromit,andthecapacityofbeinggraftedtogether——thoughthislattercapacityevidentlydependsonwidelydifferentcircumstances——shouldallruntoacertainextentparallelwiththesystematicaffinityoftheformswhicharesubjectedtoexperiment;forsystematicaffinityattemptstoexpressallkindsofresemblancebetweenallspecies。
\"Firstcrossesbetweenformsknowntobevarieties,orsufficientlyaliketobeconsideredasvarieties,andtheirmongreloffspring,areverygenerally,butnotquiteuniversally,fertile。Noristhisnearlygeneralandperfectfertilitysurprising,whenwerememberhowliablewearetoargueinacirclewithrespecttovarietiesinastateofNature;andwhenwerememberthatthegreaternumberofvarietieshavebeenproducedunderdomesticationbytheselectionofmereexternaldifferences,andnotofdifferencesinthereproductivesystem。Inallotherrespects,excludingfertility,thereisaclosegeneralresemblancebetweenhybridsandmongrels。\"——Pp。276-8。
Wefullyagreewiththegeneraltenorofthisweightypassage;butforcibleasarethesearguments,andlittleasthevalueoffertilityorinfertilityasatestofspeciesmaybe,itmustnotbeforgottenthatthereallyimportantfact,sofarastheinquiryintotheoriginofspeciesgoes,is,thattherearesuchthingsinNatureasgroupsofanimalsandofplants,whosemembersareincapableoffertileunionwiththoseofothergroups;andthattherearesuchthingsashybrids,whichareabsolutelysterilewhencrossedwithotherhybrids。For,ifsuchphenomenaasthesewereexhibitedbyonlytwoofthoseassemblagesoflivingobjects,towhichthenameofspecies(whetheritbeusedinitsphysiologicalorinitsmorphologicalsense)isgiven,itwouldhavetobeaccountedforbyanytheoryoftheoriginofspecies,andeverytheorywhichcouldnotaccountforitwouldbe,sofar,imperfect。
Uptothispoint,wehavebeendealingwithmattersoffact,andthestatementswhichwehavelaidbeforethereaderwould,tothebestofourknowledge,beadmittedtocontainafairexpositionofwhatisatpresentknownrespectingtheessentialpropertiesofspecies,byallwhohavestudiedthequestion。Andwhatevermaybehistheoreticalviews,nonaturalistwillprobablybedisposedtodemurtothefollowingsummaryofthatexposition:——
Livingbeings,whetheranimalsorplants,aredivisibleintomultitudesofdistinctlydefinablekinds,whicharemorphologicalspecies。Theyarealsodivisibleintogroupsofindividuals,whichbreedfreelytogether,tendingtoreproducetheirlike,andarephysiologicalspecies。Normallyresemblingtheirparents,theoffspringofmembersofthesespeciesarestillliabletovary;andthevariationmaybeperpetuatedbyselection,asarace,whichrace,inmanycases,presentsallthecharacteristicsofamorphologicalspecies。Butitisnotasyetprovedthataraceeverexhibits,whencrossedwithanotherraceofthesamespecies,thosephenomenaofhybridizationwhichareexhibitedbymanyspecieswhencrossedwithotherspecies。Ontheotherhand,notonlyisitnotprovedthatallspeciesgiverisetohybridsinfertile’interse’,butthereismuchreasontobelievethat,incrossing,speciesexhibiteverygradationfromperfectsterilitytoperfectfertility。