TheFragmentwaspublishedanonymously,butBenthamhadconfidedthesecrettohisfatherbywayofsuggestingsomeslightset-offagainsthisapparentunwillingnesstoemergefromobscurity。ThebookwasatfirstattributedtoLordMansfield,LordCamden,andtoDunning。ItwaspiratedinDublin;
andmostofthefivehundredcopiesprintedappeartohavebeensold,thoughwithoutprofittotheauthor。Thefather’sindiscretionletoutthesecret;
andthesale,whenthebookwasknowntobewrittenbyanobody,felloffatonce,orsoBenthambelieved。Theanonymouswriter,however,wasdenouncedandaccusedofbeingtheauthorofmuchribaldry,andamongotheraccusationswassaidtobenotonlythetranslatorbutthewriteroftheWhiteBull。29*
Benthamhadfanciedthatallmannerof’torchesfromthehighestregions’
wouldcometolightthemselvesathis’farthingcandle。’Noneofthemcame,andhewasleftforsomeyearsinobscurity,thoughstilllabouringatthegreatworkwhichwasonedaytoenlightentheworld。Atlast,however,partialrecognitioncametohiminashapewhichgreatlyinfluencedhiscareer。LordShelburne,afterwardsmarquisofLansdowne,hadbeenimpressedbytheFragment,andin1781soughtoutBenthamathischambers。Shelburne’scareerwastoculminateinthefollowingyearwithhisbrieftenureofthepremiership3rdJuly1782to24thFebruary1783。Rightlyorwronglyhiscontemporariesfeltthedistrustindicatedbyhisnickname’Malagrida’,whichappearstohavebeenpartlysuggestedbyahabitofoverstrainedcompliment。Heincurredthedislikenotunfrequentlyexcitedbymenwhoclaimsuperiorityofintellectwithoutpossessingtheforceofcharacterwhichgivesacorrespondingweightinpoliticalaffairs。Althoughhiseducationhadbeenbad,hehadsomethingofthatcosmopolitantrainingwhichenabledmanymembersofthearistocracytolookbeyondthenarrowmiddle-classprejudicesandshareinsomedegreethewiderphilosophicalmovementsoftheday。HehadenjoyedthefriendshipofFranklin,andhadbeenthepatronofPriestley,whomadesomeofhischemicaldiscoveriesatBowood,andtowhomheallowedanannuity。HebelongedtothatsectionoftheWhigswhichhadmostsympathywiththerevolutionarymovement。HischiefpoliticallieutenantswereDunningandBarré;,whoatthetimesatforhisboroughCalne。HenowrapidlyformedanintimacywithBentham,whowenttostayatBowoodintheautumnof1781。BenthamnowandtheninlateryearsmadesomeratherdisparagingremarksuponShelburne,whomheapparentlyconsideredtoberatheranamateurthanaseriousphilosopher,andwhointheHouseofLordstalked’vaguegeneralities’——thesacredphrasebywhichtheUtilitariansdenouncedallpreachingbuttheirown——inawaytoimposeuponthethoughtless。HerespectedShelburne。however,asonewhotrustedthepeople,andwasdistrustedbytheWhigaristocracy。Hefelt,too,arealaffectionandgratitudeforthepatrontowhomheowedsomuch。