Dangersofanotherkindmightmorereasonablybeapprehendedfromthisperfectanddistinctorganization,civilandmilitary,oftheStates;towit,thatcertainStatesfromlocalandoccasionaldiscontents,mightattempttosecedefromtheUnion。Thisiscertainlypossible;andwouldbebefriendedbythisregularorganization。Butitisnotprobablethatlocaldiscontentscanspreadtosuchanextent,astobeabletofacethesoundpartsofsoextensiveanUnion;andifevertheyshouldreachthemajority,theywouldthenbecometheregulargovernment,acquiretheascendencyinCongress,andbeabletoredresstheirowngrievancesbylawspeaceablyandconstitutionallypassed。AndeventheStatesinwhichlocaldiscontentsmightengenderacommencementoffermentation,wouldbeparalyzedandself-checkedbythatverydivisionintopartiesintowhichwehavefallen,intowhichallStatesmustfallwhereinmenareatlibertytothink,speak,andactfreely,accordingtothediversitiesoftheirindividualconformations,andwhichare,perhaps,essentialtopreservethepurityofthegovernment,bythecensorshipwhichthesepartieshabituallyexerciseovereachother。
Youwillread,Iamsure,withindulgence,theexplanationsofthegroundsonwhichIhaveventuredtoformanopiniondifferingfromyours。Theyprovemyrespectforyourjudgment,anddiffidenceinmyown,whichhaveforbiddenmetoretain,withoutexamination,anopinionquestionedbyyou。Permitmenowtorendermyportionofthegeneraldebtofgratitude,byacknowledgementsinadvanceforthesingularbenefactionwhichisthesubjectofthisletter,totendermywishesforthecontinuanceofalifesousefullyemployed,andtoaddtheassurancesofmyperfectesteemandrespect。
THELATINAMERICANREVOLUTION
_ToAlexandervonHumboldt_
_Monticello,April14,1811_