Theschoolofexample,mylord,istheworld:andthemastersofthisschoolarehistoryandexperience。Iamfarfromcontendingthattheformerispreferabletothelatter。Ithinkuponthewholeotherwise:butthisI
say,thattheformerisabsolutelynecessarytoprepareusforthelatter,andtoaccompanyuswhilstweareunderthedisciplineofthelatter,thatis,throughthewholecourseofourlives。Nodoubtsomefewmenmaybequoted,towhomnaturegavewhatartandindustrycangivetonoman。Butsuchexampleswillprovenothingagainstme,becauseIadmitthatthestudyofhistory,withoutexperience,isinsufficient,butassert,thatexperienceitselfissowithoutgenius。Geniusispreferabletotheothertwo;butIwouldwishtofindthethreetogether:forhowgreatsoeverageniusmaybe,andhowmuchsoeverhemayacquirenewlightandheat,asheproceedsinhisrapidcourse,certainitisthathewillnevershinewiththefulllustre,norshedthefullinfluenceheiscapableof,unlesstohisownexperienceheaddstheexperienceofothermenandotherages。Genius,withouttheimprovement,atleastofexperience,iswhatcometsoncewerethoughttobe,ablazingmeteor,irregularinhiscourse,anddangerousinhisapproach;ofnousetoanysystem,andabletodestroyany。Meresonsofearth,iftheyhaveexperiencewithoutanyknowledgeofthehistoryoftheworld,arebuthalfscholarsinthescienceofmankind。Andiftheyareconversantinhistorywithoutexperience,theyareworsethanignorant;theyarepedants,alwaysincapable,sometimesmeddlingandpresuming。Theman,whohasallthree,isanhonortohiscountry,andapublicblessing:andsuch,Itrust,yourlordshipwillbeinthiscentury,asyourgreat-grandfather,wasinthelast。
Ihaveinsistedalittlelongeronthishead,andhavemadethesedistinctionstherather,becausethoughIattributeagreatdealmorethanmanywillbereadytoallow,tothestudyofhistory,yetIwouldnotwillinglyevenseemtofallintotheridiculeofascribingittosuchextravaganteffects,asseveralhavedonefromTullydowntoCasaubon,LaMotheleVayer,andothermodernpedants。WhenTullyinformsus,inthesecondbookofhisTusculandisputations,thatthefirstScipioAfricanushadalwaysinhishandstheworksofXenophon,headvancesnothingbutwhatisprobableandreasonable。
Tosaynothingoftheretreatofthetenthousand,norofotherpartsofXenophon’swritings;theimagesofvirtue,representedinthatadmirablepicturetheCyropaedia,werepropertoentertainasoulthatwasfraughtwithvirtue,andCyruswasworthytobeimitatedbyScipio。SoSelimemulatedCaesar,whosecommentariesweretranslatedforhisuseagainstthecustomsoftheTurks;soCaesaremulatedAlexander;andAlexander,Achilles。Thereisnothingridiculoushere,excepttheusethatismadeofthispassagebythosewhoquoteit。ButwhatthesameTullysays,inthefourthbookofhisacademicaldisputations,concerningLucullus,seemstomeveryextraordinary。
“InAsiamfactusimperatorvenit;cumessetRomaprofectusreimilitarisrudis;“[onewouldbereadytoascribesosuddenachange,andsovastanimprovement,tonothinglessthanknowledgeinfusedbyinspiration,ifwewerenotassuredinthesameplacethattheywereeffectedbyverynaturalmeans,bysuchasitisineveryman’spowertoemploy]“partimpercontandoaperitis,partiminrebusgestislegendis。“Lucullus,accordingtothisaccount,verifiedthereproachontheRomannobility,whichSallustputsintothemouthofMarius。ButasIdiscoverthepassionofMarius,andhisprejudicestothepatricians,inonecase;soIdiscover,methinks,thecunningofTully,andhispartialitytohimself,intheother。Lucullus,afterhehadbeenchosenconsul,obtainedbyintriguethegovernmentofCilicia,andsoputhimselfintoasituationofcommandingtheRomanarmyagainstMithridates:Tullyhadthesamegovernmentafterwards,andthoughhehadnoMithridates,noranyotherenemyofconsequence,opposedtohim;thoughallhismilitaryfeatsconsistedinsurprisingandpillagingaparcelofhighlandersandwildCilicians;yetheassumedtheairsofaconqueror,anddescribedhisactionsinsopompousastyle,thattheaccountbecomesburlesque。