Justice,thelastandgreatestofthefourcardinalvirtues,tookplace,accordingtothissystem,wheneachofthosethreefacultiesofthemindconfineditselftoitsproperoffice,withoutattemptingtoencroachuponthatofanyother;whenreasondirectedandpassionobeyed,andwheneachpassionperformeditsproperduty,andexerteditselftowardsitsproperobjecteasilyandwithoutreluctance,andwiththatdegreeofforceandenergy,whichwassuitabletothevalueofwhatitpursued。Inthisconsistedthatcompletevirtue,thatperfectproprietyofconduct,whichPlato,aftersomeoftheancientPythagoreans,denominatedJustice。
Theword,itistobeobserved,whichexpressesjusticeintheGreeklanguage,hasseveraldifferentmeanings;andasthecorrespondentwordinallotherlanguages,sofarasIknow,hasthesame,theremustbesomenaturalaffinityamongthosevarioussignifications。Inonesensewearesaidtodojusticetoourneighbourwhenweabstainfromdoinghimanypositiveharm,anddonotdirectlyhurthim,eitherinhisperson,orinhisestate,orinhisreputation。ThisisthatjusticewhichIhavetreatedofabove,theobservanceofwhichmaybeextortedbyforce,andtheviolationofwhichexposestopunishment。Inanothersensewearesaidnottodojusticetoourneighbourunlessweconceiveforhimallthatlove,respect,andesteem,whichhischaracter,hissituation,andhisconnexionwithourselves,rendersuitableandproperforustofeel,andunlessweactaccordingly。Itisinthissensethatwearesaidtodoinjusticetoamanofmeritwhoisconnectedwithus,thoughweabstainfromhurtinghimineveryrespect,ifwedonotexertourselvestoservehimandtoplacehiminthatsituationinwhichtheimpartialspectatorwouldbepleasedtoseehim。ThefirstsenseofthewordcoincideswithwhatAristotleandtheSchoolmencallcommutativejustice,andwithwhatGrotiuscallsthejustitiaexpletrix,whichconsistsinabstainingfromwhatisanother’s,andindoingvoluntarilywhateverwecanwithproprietybeforcedtodo。Thesecondsenseofthewordcoincideswithwhatsomehavecalleddistributivejustice,2*andwiththejustitiaattributrixofGrotius,whichconsistsinproperbeneficence,inthebecominguseofwhatisourown,andintheapplyingittothosepurposeseitherofcharityorgenerosity,towhichitismostsuitable,inoursituation,thatitshouldbeapplied。Inthissensejusticecomprehendsallthesocialvirtues:Thereisyetanothersenseinwhichthewordjusticeissometimestaken,stillmoreextensivethaneitheroftheformer,thoughverymucha-kintothelast;
andwhichrunstoo,sofarasIknow,throughalllanguages。Itisinthislastsensethatwearesaidtobeunjust,whenwedonotseemtovalueanyparticularobjectwiththatdegreeofesteem,ortopursueitwiththatdegreeofardourwhichtotheimpartialspectatoritmayappeartodeserveortobenaturallyfittedforexciting。Thuswearesaidtodoinjusticetoapoemorapicture,whenwedonotadmirethemenough,andwearesaidtodothemmorethanjusticewhenweadmirethemtoomuch。Inthesamemannerwearesaidtodoinjusticetoourselveswhenweappearnottogivesufficientattentiontoanyparticularobjectofself-interest。Inthislastsense,whatiscalledjusticemeansthesamethingwithexactandperfectproprietyofconductandbehaviour,andcomprehendsinit,notonlytheofficesofbothcommutativeanddistributivejustice,butofeveryothervirtue,ofprudence,offortitude,oftemperance。ItisinthislastsensethatPlatoevidentlyunderstandswhathecallsjustice,andwhich,therefore,accordingtohim,comprehendsinittheperfectionofeverysortofvirtue。
SuchistheaccountgivenbyPlatoofthenatureofvirtue,orofthattemperofmindwhichistheproperobjectofpraiseandapprobation。Itconsists,accordingtohim,inthatstateofmindinwhicheveryfacultyconfinesitselfwithinitsproperspherewithoutencroachinguponthatofanyother,andperformsitsproperofficewiththatprecisedegreeofstrengthandvigourwhichbelongstoit。Hisaccount,itisevident,coincidesineveryrespectwithwhatwehavesaidaboveconcerningtheproprietyofconduct。
II。Virtue,accordingtoAristotle,3*consistsinthehabitofmediocrityaccordingtorightreason。Everyparticularvirtue,accordingtohim,liesinakindofmiddlebetweentwooppositevices,ofwhichtheoneoffendsfrombeingtoomuch,theotherfrombeingtoolittleaffectedbyaparticularspeciesofobjects。Thusthevirtueoffortitudeorcourageliesinthemiddlebetweentheoppositevicesofcowardiceandofpresumptuousrashness,ofwhichtheoneoffendsfrombeingtoomuch,andtheotherfrombeingtoolittleaffectedbytheobjectsoffear。Thustoothevirtueoffrugalityliesinamiddlebetweenavariceandprofusion,ofwhichtheoneconsistsinanexcess,theotherinadefectoftheproperattentiontotheobjectsofself-interest。Magnanimity,inthesamemanner,liesinamiddlebetweentheexcessofarroganceandthedefectofpusillanimity,ofwhichtheoneconsistsintooextravagant,theotherintooweakasentimentofourownworthanddignity。Itisunnecessarytoobservethatthisaccountofvirtuecorrespondstooprettyexactlywithwhathasbeensaidaboveconcerningtheproprietyandimproprietyofconduct。