Methods of Ethics

第48章

试读中

第48章

Methods of Ethics Henry Sidgwick

后面的故事,去 App 接着看,下载后搜索书名即可继续阅读。

Methods of Ethics
阅读主题
字体大小

  ItmayeasilyseemthatwhenwehavediscussedBenevolence,Justice,andtheobservanceofLawandContract,wehaveincludedinourviewthewholesphereofsocialduty,andthatwhateverothermaximswefindacceptedbyCommonSensemustbesubordinatetotheprincipleswhichwehavebeentryingtodefine。

  Forwhateverweowedefinitelytoourfellow-men,besidestheobservanceofspecialcontracts,andofpositivelaws,seems——atleastbyaslightextensionofcommonusage——tobenaturallyincludedunderJustice:whilethemoreindefiniteobligationswhichwerecogniseseemtocorrespondtothegoodwillwhichwethinkoughttoexistamongallmembersofthehumanfamily,togetherwiththestrongeraffectionsappropriatetospecialrelationsandcircumstances。AndhenceitmaybethoughtthatthebestwayoftreatingthesubjectwouldhavebeentodivideDutygenerallyintoSocialandSelf-regarding,andagaintosubdividetheformerbranchintotheheadswhichIhavediscussedonebyone;afterwardsaddingsuchminordetailsofdutyashaveobtainedspecialnamesanddistinctrecognition。AndthisisperhapstheproperplacetoexplainwhyIdidnotadoptthiscourse。ThedivisionofdutiesintoSocialandSelf-regarding,thoughobvious,andacceptableenoughasaroughprimafacieclassification,doesnotoncloserexaminationseemexactlyappropriatetotheIntuitionalMethod。Forthesetitlesnaturallysuggestthatthehappinessorwell-being,oftheagentorofothers,isalwaystheendandfinaldeterminantofrightaction:whereastheIntuitionaldoctrineis,thatatleastcertainkindsofconductareprescribedabsolutely,withoutreferencetotheirulteriorconsequences。Andifamoregeneralmeaningbegiventotheterms,andbySocialdutiesweunderstandthosewhichconsistintheproductionofcertaineffectsuponothers,whileintheSelf-regardingweaimatproducingcertaineffectsuponourselves,thedivisionisstillanunsuitableone。

  Fortheseconsequencesarenotclearlyrecognisedintheenunciationofcommonrulesofmorality:andinmanycasesweproducemarkedeffectsbothonourselvesandonothers,anditisnoteasytosaywhichintheviewofCommonSensearemostimportant:andagain,thisprincipleofdivisionwouldsometimesmakeitnecessarytocutintwotheclassofdutiesprescribedundersomecommonnotion;asthesamerulemaygovernbothoursocialandoursolitaryconduct。Take,forexample,theactsmorallyprescribedundertheheadofCourage。ItseemsclearthattheprominencegiventothisVirtueinhistoricsystemsofmoralityhasbeenduetothegreatsocialimportancethatmustalwaysattachtoit,solongascommunitiesofmenarecontinuallycalledupontofightfortheirexistenceandwell-being:butstillthequalityofbraveryisthesameessentially,whetheritbeexhibitedforselfishorsocialends。

  ItisnodoubttruethatwhenweexaminewithaviewtodefinitionthekindsofconductcommendedorprescribedinanylistofVirtuescommonlyrecognised,wefind,toagreatextent,thatthemaximsweobtainareclearlynotabsoluteandindependent:thatthequalitydenotedbyourtermisadmittedlyonlypraiseworthyinsofarasitpromotesindividualorgeneralwelfare,andbecomesblameworthy——thoughremaininginotherrespectsthesame——whenitoperatesadverselytotheseends。

  Wehavealreadynoticedthisresultinoneortwoinstances,anditwillbeillustratedatlengthinthefollowingchapters。Butthoughthisisthecasetoagreatextent,itis,forourpresentpurpose,ofspecialimportancetonotethe——realorapparent——exceptionstotherule;becausetheyarespeciallycharacteristicofthemethodthatwecallIntuitionism。

后续内容在 App 继续看

精彩内容未完,打开 App 继续阅读

后面的故事已为你准备好,下载 App 后搜索“Methods of Ethics”即可继续阅读这一章。