Inthefirstplace,CommonSensegivesusonly,atthebest,anestimatetrueforanaverageortypicalhumanbeing:and,aswehavealreadyseen,itisprobablethatanyparticularindividualwillbemoreorlessdivergentfromthistype。Inanycase,therefore,eachpersonwillhavetocorrecttheestimateofcommonopinionbytheresultsofhisownexperienceinordertoobtainfromittrustworthyguidanceforhisownconduct:andthisprocessofcorrection,itwouldseem,mustbeinvolvedinallthedifficultiesfromwhichwearetryingtoescape。
But,secondly,theexperienceofthemassofmankindisconfinedwithinlimitstoonarrowforitsresultstobeofmuchavailinthepresentinquiry。
Themajorityofhumanbeingsspendmostoftheirtimeinlabouringtoavertstarvationandseverebodilydiscomfort:andthebriefleisurethatremainstothem,aftersupplyingthebodilyneedsoffood,sleep,etc。,isspentinwaysdeterminedratherbyimpulse,routine,andhabit,thanbyadeliberateestimateofprobablepleasure。Itwouldseem,then,thatthecommonsensetowhichwehaveheretorefercanonlybethatofaminorityofcomparativelyrichandleisuredpersons。
Butagain,wecannottellthatthemassofmankind,oranysectionofthemass,isnotgenerallyandnormallyundertheinfluenceofsonicofthecausesofmal-observationpreviouslynoticed。Weavoidthe``idolsofthecave’’bytrustingCommonSense,butwhatistoguardusagainstthe``idolsofthetribe’’?Moreover,thecommonestimateofdifferentsourcesofhappinessseemstoinvolvealltheconfusionofideasandpointsofview,whichindefiningtheempiricalmethodofHedonismwehavetakensomepainstoeliminate。Inthefirstplaceitdoesnotdistinguishbetweenobjectsofnaturaldesireandsourcesofexperiencedpleasure。
NowwehaveseenBooki。chap。iv。thatthesetwoarenotexactlycoincident——indeedwefindnumerousexamplesofmenwhocontinuenotonlytofeelbuttoindulgedesires,thegratificationofwhichtheyknowbyampleexperiencetobeattendedwithmorepainthanpleasure。Andthereforethecurrentestimateofthedesirabilityofobjectsofpursuitcannotbetakentoexpresssimplymen’sexperienceofpleasureandpain:formenareapttothinkdesirablewhattheystronglydesire,whetherornottheyhavefounditconducivetohappinessonthewhole:andsothecommonopinionwilltendtorepresentacompromisebetweentheaverageforceofdesiresandtheaverageexperienceoftheconsequencesofgratifyingthem。