Itis,however,ofobviouspracticalimportancetoascertainhowfarthepowerofthewillwhethermetaphysicallyfreeornotactuallyextends:forthisdefinestherangewithinwhichethicaljudgmentsareinthestrictestsenseapplicable。Thisinquiryisquiteindependentofthequestionofmetaphysicalfreedom;wemightstateitinDeterministtermsasaninquiryintotherangeofeffectswhichitwouldbepossibletocausebyhumanvolition,providedthatadequatemotivesarenotwanting。Theseeffectsseemtobemainlyofthreekinds:first,changesintheexternalworldconsequentuponmuscularcontractions;secondly,changesinthetrainofideasandfeelingsthatconstitutesourconsciouslife;andthirdly,changesinthetendenciestoacthereafterincertainwaysundercertaincircumstances。
I。Themostobviousandprominentpartofthesphereofvolitionalcausationisconstitutedbysucheventsascanbeproducedbymuscularcontractions。Asregardsthese,itissometimessaidthatitisproperlythemuscularcontractionthatwewill,andnotthemoreremoteeffects;fortheserequiretheconcurrenceofothercauses,andthereforewecanneverbeabsolutelycertainthattheywillfollow。Butnomoreisitcertain,strictlyspeaking,thatthemuscularcontractionwillfollow,sinceourlimbmaybeparalysed,etc。Theimmediateconsequentofthevolitionissomemolecularchangeinthemotornerves。Since,however,wearenotconsciousinwillingofourmotornervesandtheirchanges,norindeedcommonlyofthemuscularcontractionsthatfollowthem,——itseemsamisuseoftermstodescribeeitherasthenormal`object’ofthemindinwilling:
sinceitisalmostalwayssomemoreremoteeffectwhichweconsciouslywillandintend。Stillofalmostalleffectsofourwillontheexternalworldsomecontractionofourmusclesisanindispensableantecedent;andwhenthatisoverourpartinthecausationiscompleted。
II。Wecancontroltosomeextentourthoughtsandfeelings。Itwouldseem,indeed,thatanimportantpartofwhatwecommonlycall`controloffeeling’comesundertheheadjustdiscussed。
Ourcontroloverourmusclesenablesustokeepdowntheexpressionofthefeelingandtoresistitspromptingstoaction:andasthegivingfreeventtoafeelingtends,generallyspeaking,tosustainandprolongit,thismuscularcontrolamountstoacertainpowerovertheemotion。Butthereisnotthesameconnexionbetweenourmuscularsystemandourthoughts: