II。ANCESTRALTRADITIONANDCULTURE。
Origin,natureandvalueofhereditaryprejudice。—Howfarcustom,religionandgovernmentarelegitimate。
Nothingcouldbebetterhadthenewdoctrinebeencomplete,andifReason,instructedbyhistory,hadbecomecritical,andthereforequalifiedtocomprehendtherivalshereplaced。Forthen,insteadofregardingherasanusurpertoberepelledshewouldhaverecognizedinheraneldersisterwhosepartmustbelefttoher。HereditaryprejudiceisasortofReasonoperatingunconsciously。Ithasclaimsaswellasreason,butitisunabletopresentthese;insteadofadvancingthosethatareauthenticitputsforththedoubtfulones。
Itsarchivesareburied;toexhumetheseitisnecessarytomakeresearchesofwhichitisincapable;neverthelesstheyexist,andhistoryatthepresentdayisbringingthemtolight。——Carefulinvestigationsshowsthat,likescience,itissuesfromalongaccumulationofexperiences;apeople,afteramultitudeofgropingsandefforts,hasdiscoveredthatacertainwayoflivingandthinkingistheonlyoneadaptedtoitssituation,themostpracticalandthemostsalutary,thesystemordogmanowseemingarbitrarytousbeingatfirstaconfirmedexpedientofpublicsafety。Frequentlyitissostill;inanyevent,initsleadingfeaturesitisindispensable;itmaybestatedwithcertaintythat,iftheleadingprejudicesofthecommunityshouldsuddenlydisappear,Man,deprivedofthepreciouslegacytransmittedtohimbythewisdomofages,wouldatoncefallbackintoasavageconditionandagainbecomewhathewasatfirst,namely,arestless,famished,wandering,huntedbrute。Therewasatimewhenthisheritagewaslacking;therearepopulationstodaywithwhichitisstillutterlylacking。[4]Toabstainfromeatinghumanflesh,fromkillinguselessorburdensomeagedpeople,fromexposing,sellingorkillingchildrenonedoesnotknowwhattodowith,tobetheonehusbandofbutonewoman,toholdinhorrorincestandunnaturalpractices,tobethesoleandrecognizedownerofadistinctfield,tobemindfulofthesuperiorinjunctionsofmodesty,humanity,honorandconscience,alltheseobservances,formerlyunknownandslowlyestablished,composethecivilizationofhumanbeings。Becauseweaccepttheminfullsecuritytheyarenotthelesssacred,andtheybecomeonlythemoresacredwhen,submittedtoinvestigationandtracedthroughhistory,theyaredisclosedtousasthesecretforcewhichhasconvertedaherdofbrutesintoasocietyofmen。Ingeneral,theolderandmoreuniversalacustom,themoreitisbasedonprofoundmotives,onphysiologicalmotivesonthoseofhygiene,andonthoseinstitutedforsocialprotection。Atonetime,asintheseparationofcastes,aheroicorthoughtfulstockmustbepreservedbypreventingthemixturesbywhichinferiorbloodintroducesmentaldebilityandlowinstincts。[5]Atanother,asintheprohibitionofspirituousliquors,andofanimalfood,itisnecessarytoconformtotheclimateprescribingavegetablediet,ortotherace—temperamentforwhichstrongdrinkispernicious。[6]Atanother,asintheinstitutionoftherightoffirst—borntoinherittitleandcastle,itwasimportanttoprepareanddesignatebeforehandthemilitarycommanderwhothetribewouldobey,orthecivilchieftainthatwouldpreservethedomain,superintenditscultivation,andsupportthefamily。[7]——IftherearevalidreasonsforlegitimizingcustomtherearereasonsofhigherimportfortheconsecrationofreligionConsiderthispoint,notingeneralandaccordingtoavaguenotion,butattheoutset,atitsbirth,inthetexts,takingforanexampleoneofthefaithswhichnowruleinsociety,Christianity,Hinduism,thelawofMohammedorofBuddha。Atcertaincriticalmomentsinhistory,afewmen,emergingfromtheirnarrowanddailyroutineoflife,areseizedbysomegeneralizedconceptionoftheinfiniteuniverse;theaugustfaceofnatureissuddenlyunveiledtothem;intheirsublimeemotiontheyseemtohavedetecteditsfirstcause;theyhaveatleastdetectedsomeofitselements。Throughafortunateconjunctionofcircumstancestheseelementsarejustthosewhichtheircentury,theirpeople,agroupofpeoples,afragmentofhumanityisinastatetocomprehend。Theirpointofviewistheonlyoneatwhichthegraduatedmultitudesbelowthemareabletoaccept。Formillionsofmen,forhundredsofgenerations,onlythroughthemisanyaccesstodivinethingstobeobtained。Theirsistheuniqueutterance,heroicoraffecting,enthusiasticortranquilizing;theonlyonewhichtheheartsandmindsaroundthemandafterthemwillheed;theonlyoneadaptedtoprofoundcravings,toaccumulatedaspirations,tohereditaryfaculties,toacompleteintellectualandmoralorganism;
YonderthatofHindostanoroftheMongolian;herethatoftheSemiteortheEuropean;inourEuropethatoftheGerman,theLatinortheSlave;insuchawaythatitscontradictions,insteadofcondemningit,justifyit,itsdiversityproducingitsadaptationanditsadaptationproducingbenefits。——Thisisnobarrenformula。A