“Wearepersuadedthatpursuithashithertobeenonafalsescent，sofarasithasbeendirectedtotheBarri鑢eduRoule。Itisimpossiblethatapersonsowellknowntothousandsasthisyoungwomanwas，shouldhavepassedthreeblockswithoutsomeonehavingseenher；andanyonewhosawherwouldhaverememberedit，forsheinterestedallwhoknewher。Itwaswhenthestreetswerefullofpeople，whenshewentout……ItisimpossiblethatshecouldhavegonetotheBarri鑢eduRoule，ortotheRuedesDr鬽es，withoutbeingrecognizedbyadozenpersons；yetnoonehascomeforwardwhosawheroutsideofhermother’sdoor，andthereisnoevidence，exceptthetestimonyconcerningherexpressedintentions，thatshedidgooutatall。Hergownwastorn，boundroundher，andtied；andbythatthebodywascarriedasabundle。IfthemurderhadbeencommittedattheBarri鑢eduRoule，therewouldhavebeennonecessityforanysucharrangement。ThefactthatthebodywasfoundfloatingneartheBarri鑢e，isnoproofastowhereitwasthrownintothewater……Apieceofoneoftheunfortunategirl’spetticoats，twofeetlongandonefootwide，wastornoutandtiedunderherchinaroundthebackofherhead，probablytopreventscreams。Thiswasdonebyfellowswhohadnopocket-handkerchief。”
AdayortwobeforethePrefectcalleduponus，however，someimportantinformationreachedthepolice，whichseemedtooverthrow，atleast，thechiefportionofLeCommerciel’sargument。Twosmallboys，sonsofaMadameDeluc，whileroamingamongthewoodsneartheBarri鑢eduRoule，chancedtopenetrateaclosethicket，withinwhichwerethreeorfourlargestones，formingakindofseat，withabackandfootstool。Ontheupperstonelayawhitepetticoat；onthesecondasilkscarf。Aparasol，gloves，andapocket-handkerchiefwerealsoherefound。Thehandkerchiefborethename“MarieRog阾。”
Fragmentsofdresswerediscoveredonthebramblesaround。Theearthwastrampled，thebusheswerebroken，andtherewaseveryevidenceofastruggle。Betweenthethicketandtheriver，thefenceswerefoundtakendown，andthegroundboreevidenceofsomeheavyburthenhavingbeendraggedalongit。
Aweeklypaper，LeSoleil，{*12}hadthefollowingcommentsuponthisdiscoverycommentswhichmerelyechoedthesentimentofthewholeParisianpress：
“Thethingshadallevidentlybeenthereatleastthreeorfourweeks；theywereallmildeweddownhardwiththeactionoftherainandstucktogetherfrommildew。Thegrasshadgrownaroundandoversomeofthem。Thesilkontheparasolwasstrong，butthethreadsofitwereruntogetherwithin。Theupperpart，whereithadbeendoubledandfolded，wasallmildewedandrotten，andtoreonitsbeingopened……Thepiecesofherfrocktornoutbythebusheswereaboutthreeincheswideandsixincheslong。Onepartwasthehemofthefrock，andithadbeenmended；theotherpiecewaspartoftheskirt，notthehem。Theylookedlikestripstornoff，andwereonthethornbush，aboutafootfromtheground……Therecanbenodoubt，therefore，thatthespotofthisappallingoutragehasbeendiscovered。”