YouaskmetostatedefinitelysomeofthepointsonwhichImuchwishforinformation;butIreallyhardlycan,fortheyaresovague;andIratherwishtoseewhatresultswillcomeoutfromcomparisons,thanhaveasyetdefinedobjects。Ipresumethat,likeotherbotanists,youwouldgive,foryourarea,theproportion(leavingoutintroducedplants)tothewholeofthegreatleadingfamilies:thisisonepointIhadintended(and,indeed,havedoneroughly)totabulatefromyourbook,butofcourseIcouldhavedoneitonlyVERYIMPERFECTLY。Ishouldalso,ofcourse,haveascertainedtheproportion,tothewholeFlora,oftheEuropeanplants(leavingoutintroduced)ANDOFTHESEPARATEGREATFAMILIES,inordertospeculateonmeansoftransportal。Bytheway,Iventuredtosendafewdaysagoacopyofthe\"Gardeners’Chronicle\"withashortreportbymeofsometriflingexperimentswhichIhavebeentryingonthepowerofseedstowithstandseawater。Idonotknowwhetherithasstruckyou,butithasme,thatitwouldbeadvisableforbotaniststogiveinWHOLENUMBERS,aswellasinthelowestfraction,theproportionalnumbersofthefamilies,thusImakeoutfromyourManualthatoftheINDIGENOUSplantstheproportionoftheUmbelliferaeare36/1798=1/49;for,withoutoneknowstheWHOLEnumbers,onecannotjudgehowreallyclosethenumbersoftheplantsofthesamefamilyareintwodistantcountries;butverylikelyyoumaythinkthissuperfluous。Mentioningtheseproportionalnumbers,Imaygiveyouaninstanceofthesortofpoints,andhowvagueandfutiletheyoftenare,whichIATTEMPTtoworkout……;reflectingonR。Brown’sandHooker’sremark,thatnearidentityofproportionalnumbersofthegreatfamiliesintwocountries,showsprobablythattheywereoncecontinuouslyunited,I
thoughtIwouldcalculatetheproportionsof,forinstance,theINTRODUCED
CompositaeinGreatBritaintoalltheintroducedplants,andtheresultwas,10/92=1/9。2。InourABORIGINALorindigenousfloratheproportionis1/10;andinmanyothercasesIfoundanequallystrikingcorrespondence。IthentookyourManual,andworkedoutthesamequestion;
hereIfindintheCompositaeanalmostequallystrikingcorrespondence,viz。24/206=1/8intheintroducedplants,and223/1798=1/8intheindigenous;butwhenIcametotheotherfamiliesIfoundtheproportionentirelydifferent,showingthatthecoincidencesintheBritishFlorawereprobablyaccidental!
Youwill,Ipresume,givetheproportionofthespeciestothegenera,i。e。,showonanaveragehowmanyspecieseachgenuscontains;thoughI