[\"Theymayindeedappeartobe;letthemnotbeaffirmed(Letthemstatetheprobabilities,butnotaffirm。)\"
——Cicero,Acad。,n。27。]
butintherealconsequencetheydrawfromitthesehavemuchtheadvantage。Tokillmen,aclearandstronglightisrequired,andourlifeistoorealandessentialtowarrantthesesupernaturalandfantasticaccidents。
Astodrugsandpoisons,Ithrowthemoutofmycount,asbeingtheworstsortofhomicides:yeteveninthis,’tissaid,thatmenarenotalwaystorelyuponthepersonalconfessionsofthesepeople;fortheyhavesometimesbeenknowntoaccusethemselvesofthemurderofpersonswhohaveafterwardsbeenfoundlivingandwell。Intheseotherextravagantaccusations,Ishouldbeapttosay,thatitissufficientaman,whatrecommendationsoeverhemayhave,bebelievedastohumanthings;butofwhatisbeyondhisconception,andofsupernaturaleffect,heoughtthenonlytobebelievedwhenauthorisedbyasupernaturalapprobation。TheprivilegeithaspleasedAlmightyGodtogivetosomeofourwitnesses,oughtnottobelightlycommunicatedandmadecheap。Ihavemyearsbatteredwithathousandsuchtalesasthese:\"Threepersonssawhimsuchadayintheeastthree,thenextdayinthewest:atsuchanhour,insuchaplace,andinsuchhabit\";assuredlyIshouldnotbelieveitmyself。HowmuchmorenaturalandlikelydoIfinditthattwomenshouldliethanthatonemanintwelvehours’timeshouldflywiththewindfromeasttowest?Howmuchmorenaturalthatourunderstandingshouldbecarriedfromitsplacebythevolubilityofourdisorderedminds,thanthatoneofusshouldbecarriedbyastrangespirituponabroomstaff,fleshandbonesasweare,uptheshaftofachimney?Letnotusseekillusionsfromwithoutandunknown,wewhoareperpetuallyagitatedwithillusionsdomesticandourown。Methinksoneispardonableindisbelievingamiracle,atleast,atalleventswhereonecaneludeitsverificationassuch,bymeansnotmiraculous;andIamofSt。
Augustine’sopinion,that,’tisbettertoleantowardsdoubtthanassurance,inthingshardtoproveanddangeroustobelieve。\"