ChapterIII:ThatTheSentimentsOfDemocraticNationsAccordWithTheirOpinionsInLeadingThemToConcentratePoliticalPowerIfitbetruethat,inagesofequality,menreadilyadoptthenotionofagreatcentralpower,itcannotbedoubtedontheotherhandthattheirhabitsandsentimentspredisposethemtorecognizesuchapowerandtogiveittheirsupport。Thismaybedemonstratedinafewwords,asthegreaterpartofthereasons,towhichthefactmaybeattributed,havebeenpreviouslystated。
*aAsthemenwhoinhabitdemocraticcountrieshavenosuperiors,noinferiors,andnohabitualornecessarypartnersintheirundertakings,theyreadilyfallbackuponthemselvesandconsiderthemselvesasbeingsapart。Ihadoccasiontopointthisoutatconsiderablelengthintreatingofindividualism。Hencesuchmencannever,withoutaneffort,tearthemselvesfromtheirprivateaffairstoengageinpublicbusiness;theirnaturalbiasleadsthemtoabandonthelattertothesolevisibleandpermanentrepresentativeoftheinterestsofthecommunity,thatistosay,totheState。Notonlyaretheynaturallywantinginatasteforpublicbusiness,buttheyhavefrequentlynotimetoattendtoit。Privatelifeissobusyindemocraticperiods,soexcited,sofullofwishesandofwork,thathardlyanyenergyorleisureremainstoeachindividualforpubliclife。Iamthelastmantocontendthatthesepropensitiesareunconquerable,sincemychiefobjectinwritingthisbookhasbeentocombatthem。Ionlymaintainthatatthepresentdayasecretpowerisfosteringtheminthehumanheart,andthatiftheyarenotcheckedtheywillwhollyovergrowit。
[Footnotea:SeeAppendixW。]
Ihavealsohadoccasiontoshowhowtheincreasingloveofwell—being,andthefluctuatingcharacterofproperty,causedemocraticnationstodreadallviolentdisturbance。Theloveofpublictranquillityisfrequentlytheonlypassionwhichthesenationsretain,anditbecomesmoreactiveandpowerfulamongsttheminproportionasallotherpassionsdroopanddie。Thisnaturallydisposesthemembersofthecommunityconstantlytogiveortosurrenderadditionalrightstothecentralpower,whichaloneseemstobeinterestedindefendingthembythesamemeansthatitusestodefenditself。Asinagesofequalitynomaniscompelledtolendhisassistancetohisfellow—men,andnonehasanyrighttoexpectmuchsupportfromthem,everyoneisatonceindependentandpowerless。Thesetwoconditions,whichmustneverbeeitherseparatelyconsideredorconfoundedtogether,inspirethecitizenofademocraticcountrywithverycontrarypropensities。Hisindependencefillshimwithself—relianceandprideamongsthisequals;hisdebilitymakeshimfeelfromtimetotimethewantofsomeoutwardassistance,whichhecannotexpectfromanyofthem,becausetheyareallimpotentandunsympathizing。Inthispredicamenthenaturallyturnshiseyestothatimposingpowerwhichalonerisesabovethelevelofuniversaldepression。Ofthatpowerhiswantsandespeciallyhisdesirescontinuallyremindhim,untilheultimatelyviewsitasthesoleandnecessarysupportofhisownweakness。*bThismaymorecompletelyexplainwhatfrequentlytakesplaceindemocraticcountries,wheretheverymenwhoaresoimpatientofsuperiorspatientlysubmittoamaster,exhibitingatoncetheirprideandtheirservility。
[Footnoteb:Indemocraticcommunitiesnothingbutthecentralpowerhasanystabilityinitspositionoranypermanenceinitsundertakings。Allthemembersofsocietyareinceaselessstirandtransformation。Nowitisinthenatureofallgovernmentstoseekconstantlytoenlargetheirsphereofaction;henceitisalmostimpossiblethatsuchagovernmentshouldnotultimatelysucceed,becauseitactswithafixedprincipleandaconstantwill,uponmen,whoseposition,whosenotions,andwhosedesiresareincontinualvacillation。Itfrequentlyhappensthatthemembersofthecommunitypromotetheinfluenceofthecentralpowerwithoutintendingit。Democraticagesareperiodsofexperiment,innovation,andadventure。Atsuchtimestherearealwaysamultitudeofmenengagedindifficultornovelundertakings,whichtheyfollowalone,withoutcaringfortheirfellowmen。Suchpersonsmaybereadytoadmit,asageneralprinciple,thatthepublicauthorityoughtnottointerfereinprivateconcerns;but,byanexceptiontothatrule,eachofthemcravesforitsassistanceintheparticularconcernonwhichheisengaged,andseekstodrawupontheinfluenceofthegovernmentforhisownbenefit,thoughhewouldrestrictitonallotheroccasions。Ifalargenumberofmenapplythisparticularexceptiontoagreatvarietyofdifferentpurposes,thesphereofthecentralpowerextendsinsensiblyinalldirections,althougheachofthemwishesittobecircumscribed。