Astotheauthorityofourmoralfaculties,ofourperception,howsoeverderived,ofdifferentqualitiesinconduct,itis,inAdamSmith\'ssystem,anultimatefact,asindisputableastheauthorityofotherfacultiesovertheirrespectiveobjects;forexample,astheauthorityoftheeyeaboutbeautyofcolour,orasthatoftheearaboutharmonyofsounds。\"Ourmoralfaculties,ournaturalsenseofmeritandpropriety,\"approveordisapproveofactionsinstantaneously,andthisapprovalorjudgmentistheirpeculiarfunction。Theyjudgeoftheotherfacultiesandprinciplesofournature;
howfar,forexample,loveorresentmentoughteithertobeindulgedorrestrained,andwhenthevarioussensesoughttobegratified。Hencetheycannotbesaidtobeonalevelwithourothernaturalfacultiesandappetites,andendowedwithnomorerighttorestrainthelatterthanthelatteraretorestrainthem。Therecanbenomoreappealfromthemabouttheirobjectsthanthereisfromtheeye,ortheear,orthetastewithregardtotheobjectsoftheirseveraljurisdictions。Accordingasanythingisagreeableornottothem,isitfit,right,andproper,orunfit,wrong,andimproper。
\"Thesentimentswhichtheyapproveofaregracefulandbecoming;thecontrary,ungracefulandunbecoming。Theverywords,right,wrong,fit,proper,graceful,orbecoming,meanonlywhatpleasesordispleasesthosefaculties。\"
Hencethequestionoftheauthorityofourmoralfacultiesisasfutileasthequestionoftheauthorityofthespecialsensesovertheirseveralobjects。For\"theycarryalongwiththemthemostevidentbadgesofthisauthority,whichdenotethattheyweresetupwithinustobethesupremearbiterofallouractions,tosuperintendalloursenses,passions,andappetites,andtojudgehowfareitherofthemwaseithertobeindulgedorrestrained。\"Thatistosay,itisimpossibleforourmoralfacultiestoapproveofonecourseofconductandtodisapproveofanother,andatthesametimetofeelthatthereisnoauthorityinthesentimentwhichpassesjudgmenteitherway。
PerhapsthepartofAdamSmith\'stheorywhichhasgivenleastsatisfactionishisaccountoftheethicalstandard,ormeasureofmoralactions。This,itwillberemembered,isnoneotherthanthesympatheticemotionoftheimpartialspectatorwhichseemsagaintoresolveitselfintothevoiceofpublicopinion。Itwillbeofinteresttofollowsomeofthecriticismthathasbeendevotedtothispoint,mostofwhichturnsonthemeaningofthewordimpartial。